• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, two things.

First, these people are a great deal more sophisicated about running crowd-funders and right now they've got a core following of contributors on the social network that numbers in the thousands.

Second, we don't know how much of what they've already collected and built they'll be allowed to keep in any settlement.

We all have opinions, some more informed and some less so, but I remind myself that legally knowledgeable folk didn't think Axanar could get pro bono representation to begin with.

Exactly. And in comparison, the original STAR WOLF kickstarter wasn't exciting or engaging. Regardless of what I actually think about the man, Alec Peters has proven that he can galvanize a fanbase and make a compelling pitch.
 
Regardless of what I actually think about the man, Alec Peters has proven that he can galvanize a fanbase and make a compelling pitch.

however, to achieve this, he may have removed from himself the constraints of promising only what could reasonably be delivered. tends to dilute credit otherwise due for the above.
 
I think one would have to be a fool to donate more money to the Axanar group. Unfortunately, the world is full of fools.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kor
Hmm. I wonder what could have gone wrong.

Think it might have been the "listen up, bad guys?" by any chance? :D

I was interested in the Star Wolf Kickstarter, but ultimately I couldn't pull the trigger and contribute to it. It was like the Free Enterprise: The Television Series Kickstarter; these projects, while interesting, may not have enough of an audience to be viable over the long-term, and if they viewed as viable then Gerrold (for Star Wolf) and Burnett (for Free Enterprise) would have found a production company and studio willing to invest in them.

Maybe because he said he wrote it because he wanted to read something like it but NOBODY WAS WRITING that kind of thing.

Um... okay. Massive ego so no wonder he and AP hooked up.

I don't see anything wrong with someone writing something because no one is writing the kind of thing he wants to read. A writer's first audience is himself; if what's in the market isn't entertaining him, writing something that does entertain him makes perfect sense. Tolkien's work, for instance, was written because that was the kind of story he wanted to read, but it didn't exist, so he had to write it himself.

The question then becomes, does this work appeal to an audience? It doesn't always. There are writers who have started and abandoned series because it turned out there wasn't an audience for it.
 
Apparently all production has stopped. About four hours ago, Peters posted on the Axanar Fan Group site that since they won't go ahead with production until they've replied to CBS in court, he has no more updates about production to give in his Captain's Log. So, they are encouraging fans to email them what Axanar and "Star Trek" mean to them. The best ones will be posted daily in the Captain's Log. The best one of the week will get sent a "Starfleet Emergency Response" patch. In the comments, someone asked him if costume and set work has stopped, too. His response was he can't say due to the litigation.
Apparenlty, things are percolating, Jerry!

Actually, the comment was "Hope we still get the occasional updates/pics of set and costume progress."

Alec made no reply to the post.
 
I was just looking through the guests list for the Vegas Convention and JG Hertzler will be there. I wonder what'll happen if someone brings up Axanar?
 
Last edited:
I'd contribute money to a crowdfunder for a movie or series I really wanted to see. The idea that the only way TV can be successful or worthwhile is for it to pass the gatekeepers at the big studios isn't one I subscribe to.

It's probably true that if a project can't arouse interest in the mainstream industry its unlikely to be something with mass appeal; that's what the studio people are putatively best at assessing.
 
Not quite.

The poked the bear.
The bear warned them that poking would provoke a reaction.
The continued to poke the bear.
The bear got pissed and reacted by filing suit.
Then they told everyone else to poke the bear as they continued to poke the bear.

While we don't know how the bear reacted, I don't think it was good.

And then the bear eats them all and the trek on the path of selfdestruction and megalomania comes to an end...
 
Here's how I am quite sure any conversation about Axanar (if one ever did happen) would've went down with Bryan Fuller:

Fuller: So what are you doing now? More extras on Blu-rays that no one watches?

RMB: No, I am working on a Star Trek independent feature. It's going to be awesome! Right down to the electricity and carpeting!

Fuller: Oh, that's nice. Did you see the game last night?
 
Here's how I am quite sure any conversation about Axanar (if one ever did happen) would've went down with Bryan Fuller:

Fuller: So what are you doing now? More extras on Blu-rays that no one watches?

RMB: No, I am working on a Star Trek independent feature. It's going to be awesome! Right down to the electricity and carpeting!

Fuller: Oh, that's nice. Did you see the game last night?

I mean, it's like I'm really there!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top