• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Case dismissed! Discovery and Tardigrade game "not similar"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Also, wasn't Discovery season 1 very successful on Netflix according to the third-party market research groups that track such things?
 
Having support to keep motivation up though. So there isn't some interview where they explained how they came up with the tardegrade idea?
It seems like an obvious idea, considering that tardigrades were the "thing du jour" that people were talking about back when Discovery was being created.

The idea that tardigrades regularly can be found in the upper atmosphere, and can routinely survive survive the vacuum of space to be able to reconstitute itself, was an ongoing theme of the TV science documentaries at the time, such as those on National Geographic TV or the Science Channel.

I bet Discovery's production team -- as well as the Tardigrade Project's game development team -- both had these science TV documentaries in mind when they were tasked with thinking up a plausible organism that could survive the vacuum of space.

"Hey, what about tardigrades?" seems like one of the more likely answers.
 
Thing is, tardigrades were very much in the public consciousness around the time the Tardigrades project started and the time Discovery was under development.

Exactly, there were Tardigrades as alien rebels (Voltron), Tardigrades as reality warping super computers (Doctor Who), aliens that lived in space (Doctor Who), space ships etc. Do a search on google for Tardigrades and Enterprise and the first link is a article about "How Tardigrades Saved the Enterprise" from 2013.

The TARDigrades In Space (TARDIS for short, I'm not joking) project lit up a lot of sci-fi writers imaginations.
 
Thing is, tardigrades were very much in the public consciousness around the time the Tardigrades project started and the time Discovery was under development. If you told me to think of an extremophile organism that can survive the vacuum of space, irrespective of the two projects, tardigrades are the first thing that would come to mind.

Not mine. I wouldn't have thought of the idea of using a living organism to teleport around the galaxy, especially in the 23rd century of all places. Unless it was a lost in space type concept, I wouldn't have used the idea in 23rd century star trek.
 
To me, it looks like the whole case is built around a bunch of common sci-fi tropes and a handful of coincidences, but I'm not a lawyer so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Not mine. I wouldn't have thought of the idea of using a living organism to teleport around the galaxy, especially in the 23rd century of all places. Unless it was a lost in space type concept, I wouldn't have used the idea in 23rd century star trek.

So... you wouldn't have, therefore nobody possibly could have?
 
A jury is unlikely to be comprised of hardcore sci-fi fans. If you compare the show with the game, I can see a jury deciding they are strikingly similar enough. Most people wouldn't think of teleporting around the universe with a tardigrade. Or even heard of a tardigrade for that matter. I think I heard of them in passing once or twice before discovery came out.
 
A jury is unlikely to be comprised of hardcore sci-fi fans. If you compare the show with the game, I can see a jury deciding they are strikingly similar enough. Most people wouldn't think of teleporting around the universe with a tardigrade. Or even heard of a tardigrade for that matter. I think I heard of them in passing once or twice before discovery came out.

Part of CBS’ defense will likely be proving parallel development. A part of that will be the history of tartigrades.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top