• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune systems?

Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

Well, it's not like the sarc is going to generate a new goa'uld for the Jaffa. They just need it, even if it is a separate organism. That's what symbiot means in the first place.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

I'd say that removal of the immune system qualifies as damage.

It isn't though, as it's 'natural'. It would be no more 'damage' than a frog losing the tail it had as a tadpole.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

I'd say that removal of the immune system qualifies as damage.

It isn't though, as it's 'natural'. It would be no more 'damage' than a frog losing the tail it had as a tadpole.

Sure it is. Losing its tail doesn't kill the frog.

A Jaffa has a functioning immune system when it's born. Giving them a symbiont forces them to lose that immune system, and afterward they can no longer survive without one. That counts as damage.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

I'd say that removal of the immune system qualifies as damage.

It isn't though, as it's 'natural'. It would be no more 'damage' than a frog losing the tail it had as a tadpole.

Sure it is. Losing its tail doesn't kill the frog.

A Jaffa has a functioning immune system when it's born. Giving them a symbiont forces them to lose that immune system, and afterward they can no longer survive without one. That counts as damage.

They lose their immune system at a certain age regardless of whether they get a symbiote or not, it's how their body is designed to function, the symbiote doesn't cause it.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

So you're saying that the Jaffa were genetically engineered to require the Symbiotes over time and eventually it became a part of their normal genetic make-up through subsequent generations?

Kind of like the bounty hunter's race from "Deadman Switch" in Season 3
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

The Jaffa were created as incubators by the Goa'uld by genetically altering humans, yes.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

So if the first genetically altered jaffa were put in a Sarcophagus would it have repaired their immune systems or just reset their natural genetic state?
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

Depends on how they were altered, but I bet it would have repaired their immune systems, just as it did for Jack.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

Perhaps the first ones, as they were actually altered, but not the generations afterwards.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

Rewatching SG1's Hathor tonight, I was wondering why the Jaffa never just used the sarcophagus to restore their immune systems?

They'd be human again and subject to illness and aging, but they'd also be free of Goa'uld dependence?

Is Tretonin the better option?

And while we're on the subject... Where is the SGC getting the goa'uld symbiotes to make the stuff if Egeria is dead? The Unas homeworld?

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ReedRichardsIsUseless

Read the above.
Because it would effectivly cure AIDS and like a load of other conditions..
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

^We've already determined that the Sarcophagus wouldn't work on the Jaffa due to their inherited genetic modifications as they start to loss their immune systems upon reaching puberty.

and FYI, Reed isn't useless, he's just an Absent Minded Professor. :-P
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

And while we're on the subject... Where is the SGC getting the goa'uld symbiotes to make the stuff if Egeria is dead? The Unas homeworld?

I'm guessing that the new tretonin is synthetically produced. They were never explicit about it, but it's the only way it makes sense. Unless one goa'uld yields more than enough tretonin to sustain a Jaffa for more than ten years or so (I think that's how long a symbiont incubates), it is in no way superior to just stealing a goa'uld and then killing it once it reaches maturity for the Jaffa.

They can certainly make it synthetically now, though, using the replicator on the Odyssey.

Doesn't explain why they don't use it as a medicine for humans, though.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

Good point, I'd forgotten about the Asgard replication tech.

As far as using in on humans though... once you're on it, you're on it.
No going back ever.
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

I thought that was just because the Tok'ra queen was intentionally giving birth to tainted symbionts, in an attempt to communicate, "Stop grinding up my babies."
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

What about the Krull warrior type symbiotes? Blank slates but not intended to damage their host? Would they still take control of the host?
 
Re: Can't the Jaffa use the sarcophagus to restore their immune system

What about the Krull warrior type symbiotes? Blank slates but not intended to damage their host? Would they still take control of the host?

Those were basically the same as the Pangaran symbiotes. In fact, it was from Jonas Quinn's memories of Pangara that Anubis got the idea.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top