• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

"Bush Trek"

HotRod

The Roddest Rod
Premium Member
I've heard from multiple people that Season 3 of Enterprise is often viewed as "Bush Trek," or that it's heavily right-leaning or something along those lines. I just can't say I've ever seen it that way.


I'll repeat what I said earlier today in response to @Lord Garth on the matter in a different thread. I figured it might make for an interesting conversation in a more appropriate location.

Yes, the Xindi attack on Earth is an obvious allegory for 9/11. That's not really in dispute. But people who stop there are ignoring where the story actually goes.

The entire point of the season is that Archer and the crew begin with understandable anger and a desire for justice, only to gradually discover that the Xindi themselves are victims of manipulation. They weren't acting out of simple hatred or blind aggression; they had been deceived into believing humanity was an existential threat. Once the truth comes out, many of the Xindi become our allies, and together they stop the real villains behind the conflict.

If the Xindi are meant to parallel Muslims after 9/11, then the message isn't "go get them." It's almost the exact opposite. The season argues against painting an entire people as the enemy and instead encourages understanding who is actually responsible for creating fear and conflict.

The arc repeatedly challenges Archer's assumptions. He wrestles with revenge, makes questionable decisions under pressure, and ultimately succeeds not through overwhelming military force, but through diplomacy, empathy, and uncovering the truth. That's a far more nuanced message than simply "America good, enemy bad."

If anything, Season 3 is a cautionary tale about fear, misinformation, and the dangers of demonizing an entire civilization because of the actions of a few. That doesn't strike me as a particularly right-wing message. It strikes me as a very Star Trek message.
 
"Bush Trek" is an oversimplifying shorthand for the third season. I've used it myself from time to time for convenience sake. You are right, the Xindi storyline overall is its own thing which doesn't really represent the mentality of Bush's administration, particularly with how the storyline ends, and I'd argue by halfway through the third season it had deviated enough from its start as a 9/11 and Iraq war allegory to be its own thing. Still, when you look at the start of the Xindi storyline, it is very much a reflection of the times it was made in and what is remembered about Bush's presidency, particularly his first term when the season was made which indeed is likely what future historians are going to associate with Bush's time in office. That is the Xindi storyline inserts into the show its own version of 9/11, the GWOT, the Iraq invasion (particularly the search for WMDs). In the end it does take a very distinctly Star Trek way of handling these subjects and aside from being a long term story arc you could almost see something like this playing out on TOS or TNG and having a similar resolution. So while calling the season "Bush Trek" is an inaccurate simplification, it's also a somewhat understandable one to make since anyone watching it today is most certainly going to see how the storyline is influenced by the times it was made in, those times being when Dubya Bush was in office.
 
I don't post in the ENT Forum. Yet here I am making a post in here! I can't have the type of debate with you that you probably want because I don't remember ENT Season 3 well enough to hold up my end of it. Just broad impressions. I'd have to watch it again, which I don't have time for.

So, while I appreciate the tag, I have to decline. Enterprise isn't my lane and you wouldn't be getting me at my A-Game. Everyone else, have at it!
 
"Bush Trek" is an oversimplifying shorthand for the third season. I've used it myself from time to time for convenience sake. You are right, the Xindi storyline overall is its own thing which doesn't really represent the mentality of Bush's administration, particularly with how the storyline ends, and I'd argue by halfway through the third season it had deviated enough from its start as a 9/11 and Iraq war allegory to be its own thing. Still, when you look at the start of the Xindi storyline, it is very much a reflection of the times it was made in and what is remembered about Bush's presidency, particularly his first term when the season was made which indeed is likely what future historians are going to associate with Bush's time in office. That is the Xindi storyline inserts into the show its own version of 9/11, the GWOT, the Iraq invasion (particularly the search for WMDs). In the end it does take a very distinctly Star Trek way of handling these subjects and aside from being a long term story arc you could almost see something like this playing out on TOS or TNG and having a similar resolution. So while calling the season "Bush Trek" is an inaccurate simplification, it's also a somewhat understandable one to make since anyone watching it today is most certainly going to see how the storyline is influenced by the times it was made in, those times being when Dubya Bush was in office.
I suppose my issue has never been with acknowledging that Season 3 was influenced by the post-9/11 world, it clearly was. It's more that I've seen "Bush Trek" used as a dismissive label, as if the season is simply promoting Bush-era politics, and I don't think that's a fair reading of where the story ultimately goes.

I honestly think it's one of the best seasons of Star Trek, and reducing it to a political soundbite ignores how much more thoughtful and nuanced the story actually is. By the end, it feels very Star Trek to me, which is why I've never been especially comfortable with the label.
 
It's more that I've seen "Bush Trek" used as a dismissive label, as if the season is simply promoting Bush-era politics, and I don't think that's a fair reading of where the story ultimately goes.
Oh, very much agreed.
I honestly think it's one of the best seasons of Star Trek,
It's certainly the best season-long story arc done in the franchise. And before anyone starts with "what of the Dominion War?" that doesn't really count since it last two seasons and aside from the opening 6 episodes of season 6 and the closing ten episodes of S7 those seasons were predominantly episodic. Though, granted the "Final Chapter" arc of S7 was a ten episode arc put together much better than any ten episode arc on Disco or Picard, but we're straying from the thread's topic there.
 
Copying my reply from the other thread:

It absolutely was Bush Trek. In a HUGE way. After 9/11 the zeitgeist was very strange. I won't go into tremendous detail on it but essentially the media and wider culture were in an "everything is different now, including norms of violence" and there was a rush to reflect Americans' fear and desire for revenge. The Bush administration and its media allies fanned the flames of this in a big way. Popular culture responded to this. There were lots of "very special episodes" of things and while the show 24 was planned and produced before 9/11 it made some tweaks after its first season to take this vibe into overdrive and became closely associated with the post-9/11 pre-Iraq II era of pent up...well....bloodthirstiness. There were people in the media asking if torture was ok if it stopped aa terror attack, politicians crowing about it, and 24 depicted that very thing.

ENT S3 and Dark Archer were absolutely a reflection of this vibe, 100%. I remember reading interviews and think pieces about it. Trek did its version of torture apologia. It wasn't as overt as 24 but characters were questioning things that NEVER would have been questioned in any prior series. Even DS9 at its darkest wouldn't have, I don't think.

The problem is that the writing on ENT was weak. There are a lot of rose colored glasses for it now but at the time it was not widely well-regarded. The metaphor and allegory was ham-fisted and unsubtle, and the vibe it was trying to reflect was very anti-Trek. All of this combined for a dark, gloomy, but ultimately flaccid third season. Other shows would handle similar issues better (BSG is one).

You are right that 1:1 match up isn't there but the post 9/11 vibe is all over ENT before S4 and I think the show was weaker for it. It was a really strange time and I'm not sure it could've worked any other way though.
 
Last edited:
One thing I think often gets overlooked is how the season actually treats Archer's actions.

People often point to the torture scene or the theft of the warp coil as proof that Season 3 is "Bush Trek." But those moments aren't framed as heroic or triumphant. They're compromises, and Archer clearly carries the weight of them.

To me, that's the important distinction. The season isn't glorifying those choices; it's showing the moral cost of them. Archer is pushed into doing things he never thought he'd have to do, and that matters.

That's one of the reasons I've never been comfortable with reducing Season 3 to "Bush Trek." Those moments aren't presented as examples to follow. They're portrayed as some of the darkest decisions of Archer's life, and the show never lets him, or the audience, forget the cost.

After those events, he's a different character. Gone is the naive explorer who left Earth believing every problem could be solved with optimism and good intentions. He's been hardened by what he had to do in the Expanse, and those experiences shape the captain he becomes for the rest of the series. To me, that's character development, not propaganda.
 
I’m pretty sure I’ve shared this story here somewhere before…

I was talking with John Billingsley about Season 3. He told me he was not a big fan of the “saber rattling” 9/11 metaphor in Season 3.

I told him that what I loved about it was when Enterprise and the Xindi discovered they were both being manipulated by a third species (Sphere Builders) and teamed up to save the day. It was, IMHO, a subversion of the 9/11 metaphor. To me that made it a much different story.

John replied “Well, I don’t remember that part.”

:lol:
 
I’m pretty sure I’ve shared this story here somewhere before…

I was talking with John Billingsley about Season 3. He told me he was not a big fan of the “saber rattling” 9/11 metaphor in Season 3.

I told him that what I loved about it was when Enterprise and the Xindi discovered they were both being manipulated by a third species (Sphere Builders) and teamed up to save the day. It was, IMHO, a subversion of the 9/11 metaphor. To me that made it a much different story.

John replied “Well, I don’t remember that part.”

:lol:
Everyone seems to forget that part.
 
One thing I think often gets overlooked is how the season actually treats Archer's actions.

People often point to the torture scene or the theft of the warp coil as proof that Season 3 is "Bush Trek." But those moments aren't framed as heroic or triumphant. They're compromises, and Archer clearly carries the weight of them.

To me, that's the important distinction. The season isn't glorifying those choices; it's showing the moral cost of them. Archer is pushed into doing things he never thought he'd have to do, and that matters.

That's one of the reasons I've never been comfortable with reducing Season 3 to "Bush Trek." Those moments aren't presented as examples to follow. They're portrayed as some of the darkest decisions of Archer's life, and the show never lets him, or the audience, forget the cost.

After those events, he's a different character. Gone is the naive explorer who left Earth believing every problem could be solved with optimism and good intentions. He's been hardened by what he had to do in the Expanse, and those experiences shape the captain he becomes for the rest of the series. To me, that's character development, not propaganda.
To be fair, it is possible that a viewing of S3 today, in a vacuum and outside of that particular time, might yield a different feeling for me. But at the time it was hard to ignore the post-9/11 vibes in ENT. To this day, I hear Trip Tucker's voice as a GWB pastiche. But it is possible that it would hit differently now!
 
One of the most powerful scenes in Berman-era Trek is in "Azati Prime", when Archer, reluctantly I believe, destroys the Xindi installation on the backside of the moon. The false-color targeting display evokes the infrared gun camera combat footage that has been ubiquitous on real-world news broadcasts at least since the first Gulf War. The scene doesn't exist outside of this context. This scene the primary reason why I have that episode on my best-episode card for ENT.

One thing I think often gets overlooked is how the season actually treats Archer's actions.

People often point to the torture scene or the theft of the warp coil as proof that Season 3 is "Bush Trek." But those moments aren't framed as heroic or triumphant. They're compromises, and Archer clearly carries the weight of them.

To me, that's the important distinction. The season isn't glorifying those choices; it's showing the moral cost of them. Archer is pushed into doing things he never thought he'd have to do, and that matters.

This is what makes the scene great. T'Pol questions whether Archer really wants to do it. It's "only" three Xindi lives, but Archer seems very unhappy about it. He just concludes that the mission depends upon it, and they have no choice.
 
I think a lot of what people criticize about Season 3 comes down to the fact that Archer simply isn't in the same position as someone like Picard.

I've always found Picard to be rather sanctimonious, even arrogant at times. It's a lot easier to take the moral high ground when you're commanding the Federation flagship, backed by one of the most powerful organizations in the galaxy. If diplomacy fails, odds are there's another starship on the way, or an admiral you can call.

Archer doesn't have any of that. He's commanding a prototype ship, representing a planet that most species have never even heard of, deep in hostile territory with no backup coming if things go wrong. Earth itself is at risk, and the responsibility for stopping that threat falls almost entirely on his shoulders.

That's why the choices he makes in the Expanse hit so much harder. Torturing a prisoner, stealing the warp coil, making morally questionable decisions... the show never presents those as moments of triumph. They're desperate choices made by a captain running out of options, and they leave scars that never really go away.

That's one of the reasons I've always preferred captains like Archer and Kirk. They spent much more time out on the frontier, where there wasn't always a clean solution or someone else to take over. Sometimes they had to make impossible decisions and then live with the consequences.

To me, that's what makes Season 3 so compelling. It's not glorifying those choices. It's showing what they cost.
 
To be fair, it is possible that a viewing of S3 today, in a vacuum and outside of that particular time, might yield a different feeling for me. But at the time it was hard to ignore the post-9/11 vibes in ENT. To this day, I hear Trip Tucker's voice as a GWB pastiche. But it is possible that it would hit differently now!

The fact that Connor Trinneer went on to play George W. Bush in American Made somewhat reinforces that.
 
Tucker: "I can't wait to get there, Captain, and find the people who did this. And tell me we won't be tiptoeing around. None of this non-interference crap that T'Pol's always shoving down our throats."

That bit of dialogue bothered me greatly when I first watched it.
 
That bit of dialogue bothered me greatly when I first watched it.
But isn't that exactly the point? It's supposed to bother you.

I've talked a lot about Archer's journey, but Trip's is just as important. He goes into the Expanse carrying nothing but anger, hatred and a desire for revenge. The Xindi aren't just an enemy to him, they're the monsters who killed his baby sister.

But throughout the season, that starts to change. The more Trip learns about the Xindi, the more he realizes they're not simply monsters. They were manipulated and lied to just like everyone else. His relationship with Degra is probably the best example of that. By the end, Trip has come to understand Degra and the impossible position he was put in. He may not forget what happened, but he respects the man Degra was trying to be, and his death genuinely affects him.

The man who started the season wanting revenge ends it saddened by the loss of someone who was once his enemy. To me, that's one of the clearest examples that Season 3 isn't about glorifying hatred or revenge. It's about learning to understand the people on the other side.
 
I told him that what I loved about it was when Enterprise and the Xindi discovered they were both being manipulated by a third species (Sphere Builders) and teamed up to save the day. It was, IMHO, a subversion of the 9/11 metaphor. To me that made it a much different story.
I always wondered how planned it was that the script would flip at the climax of the season and it would turn out the bad guys weren't the ones with the secret weapons of mass destruction deep in the Delphic no-fly zone, but were instead a fractious, pluralist society who'd been scared into a preemptive war by false intelligence and ended up biting off more than they could chew. They even had the then-obligatory evocation of George W. Bush in "The Council:"

DOLIM: You have a decision to make. We've taken control of the weapon. We're going to launch it.
HUMANOID: And you accuse Degra of being a traitor!
INSECTOID: We are acting on behalf of all Xindi.
DOLIM: Either you stand with us, or you stand against us.
JANNAR: That's not a choice, it's an ultimatum.

Dolim, Darth Vader, Lex Luthor, you couldn't swing a cat without hitting a villain saying "Bring it on" or "You're either with us or against us" in the mid-2000s.
 
Copying my response from the other thread, if I may:

Contrary to what some have posted here, it starts off seeming like “Bush Trek”, but by the end proves very much not. I can see how some would see it that way if they didn’t watch the arc through, but to still call it that after the fact is to completely miss its point.

(Declarative online fans, missing a point? Surely not!)

And by the way, like no doubt many of us, I was there for 9/11. I looked up on the way to work to see what people were looking at, and saw the huge gaping smoking hole in the nearer tower; I heard the roar when each came down later (and unlike some colleagues, did not rush to the window, not wanting to see it); I smelled what everybody in Manhattan smelled for the next couple of weeks. I know what the zeitgeist was. ENT S3 was a response to it, not an expression of it.
 
Tucker: "I can't wait to get there, Captain, and find the people who did this. And tell me we won't be tiptoeing around. None of this non-interference crap that T'Pol's always shoving down our throats."

That bit of dialogue bothered me greatly when I first watched it.
Given the moment, it was entirely understandable. The point of the season was their gradually learning better (and, yeah, stopping the ones who still wanted to go forward with the attacks — with the help of the ones who didn’t).
 
I was only 10 in 2001 so too young to understand the geopolitics of it all and I'm not American so a terrorist attack thousands of miles away doesn't have that personal feeling. But I strongly agree with what others have said about season 3 of ENT being a response and holding up a mirror to these attitudes the way it often does.

And it still tells a relevant story today about judging an entire race for the actions of a few, and how unresolved trauma can direct someone to taking revenge to try and resolve their pain.

Now a criticism for season 3 would be why on Earth did they make an upbeat remix of the theme tune for this season?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top