• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Breastfeeding toddlers

There are socialization concerns. The creation of a certain distance between parent and child is considered part of the child's development. Now I don't have a clue what point that point is, but it's not necessarily determined by the child.

It is determined by the child. About 99 percent of children will wean themselves at a proper age if given the opportunity. The world wide average is age 4. That's about right for optimal health and psychological benefits. My sister didn't work until her youngest boy went to kindergarten. Her three sons weaned themselves by age 5, 4, and 3. They never suffered colic. Not one single ear infection or food allergy. They never so much as had a cold until they were in school around other kids. The idea is that the child will be stronger psychologically if he has that comfort available and can wean himself at the proper time that nature intended. There's nothing sexual about it and they don't do feed all the time at that age. It's only adults who seem to have a problem.

One's in graduate school at Stanford, the other at Georgia Tech. The third is enlisting in the military and going to school later. The two oldest went overseas as teenagers to visit Lebanon (their grandfather's home) and they enjoy playing rugby. My point? They "separated" from their mother just fine at the proper time when they were ready. Breastfeeding didn't make them mama's boys, but my sister was judged negatively for it. That's sad.

Nursing a five year old is not only icky but i believe detrimental to the child.

It sure was detrimental to Matt. That master's degree he's going to get from Stanford won't be helpful to him at all in life. There is nothing wrong with breastfeeding a toddler. It won't doom them to being pussies.
 
Last edited:
A little late to this discussion, but my two cents: I nursed both of my kids. My son was 9 months old when i weaned him, my daughter weaned herself at 8 months. I would have preferred weaning her at 12 months, but by 8 months she had enough and refused the breast. There is no denying the health benefits of nursing over bottle feeding. But there comes a point where the child HAS TO learn to comfort him/herself without the breast. Nursing a five year old is not only icky but i believe detrimental to the child. They MUST learn ways to comfort themselves otherwise there will be problems down the road for that child. There are other ways to show you love your child and comfort them other than the breast. Five years old? Just plain icky.

I just had a vision of Kelso from That 70's Show saying "You do NOT refuse the breast!" :lol:
 
There is nothing wrong with breastfeeding a toddler. It won't doom them to being pussies.

At what point does it stop being ok, though? Two? Four? School age? I mean, if it's acceptable still at 5 years, old, what changes that 6 years old is suddenly a no-no? 7? 8? College? Once they get married and have their wife's breast to replace it? There's a line somewhere, right? I had trouble falling asleep the other night, maybe a warm breastmilk nightcap would have taken the edge off?

Seems like everyone defending it has STILL picked an age where it starts being 'wrong' in their own heads, but they are coming down on anyone who picked a younger age as sexist or backwards...
 
There is nothing wrong with breastfeeding a toddler. It won't doom them to being pussies.

At what point does it stop being ok, though? Two? Four? School age? I mean, if it's acceptable still at 5 years, old, what changes that 6 years old is suddenly a no-no? 7? 8? College? Once they get married and have their wife's breast to replace it? There's a line somewhere, right? I had trouble falling asleep the other night, maybe a warm breastmilk nightcap would have taken the edge off?

Seems like everyone defending it has STILL picked an age where it starts being 'wrong' in their own heads, but they are coming down on anyone who picked a younger age as sexist or backwards...

what goes around comes around
 
A little late to this discussion, but my two cents: I nursed both of my kids. My son was 9 months old when i weaned him, my daughter weaned herself at 8 months. I would have preferred weaning her at 12 months, but by 8 months she had enough and refused the breast. There is no denying the health benefits of nursing over bottle feeding. But there comes a point where the child HAS TO learn to comfort him/herself without the breast. Nursing a five year old is not only icky but i believe detrimental to the child. They MUST learn ways to comfort themselves otherwise there will be problems down the road for that child. There are other ways to show you love your child and comfort them other than the breast. Five years old? Just plain icky.

If the kid is going to school then it should stop. I mean is the kid going to school talking about he sucked on mom's teat lastnight? No that's just wrong. If the kid can eat adult foods, granted in child-sized pieces/portions then he shouldn't be drinking from mommy's boob.

Just a side note: Trekker - you have no kids and no girlfriend. You whine constantly about your life. Why should we take your opinion as gospel when you obviously have no idea what you're talking about and can't even get your own shit together??
 
New research published a week ago suggests that although breastfeeding is advised up to 6 months, 'lumpy food' should be introduced before that.

This does not mean that there are no benefits of breast feeding afer 6 months. Research shows that the immune system recieves benefits for at least 2 years. I'm not sure about the nutrition side of things. But, they have found that breastmilk changes with time to match the changing needs.

Mr Awe
 
Just a side note: Trekker - you have no kids and no girlfriend. You whine constantly about your life. Why should we take your opinion as gospel when you obviously have no idea what you're talking about and can't even get your own shit together??

How about you get your shit together and jam something up your ass?
 
I have a friend who breastfed her 3yr old, it seemed a little odd to me, but I'm male, wtf do I know about the ideal age to wean children?
 
Seems like everyone defending it has STILL picked an age where it starts being 'wrong' in their own heads, but they are coming down on anyone who picked a younger age as sexist or backwards...

Not at all. But if I had to pick an age, I'd pick the onset of puberty. :lol: Kids will wean themselves when they need to do so. They aren't going to go on breastfeeding forever. This would not be an issue if adults weren't so absolutely hung up about womens' breasts. It's ridiculous. The breast milk content changes as the child grows. The nutritional benefits are just out of this world.
 
There is nothing wrong with breastfeeding a toddler. It won't doom them to being pussies.

At what point does it stop being ok, though? Two? Four? School age? I mean, if it's acceptable still at 5 years, old, what changes that 6 years old is suddenly a no-no? 7? 8? College? Once they get married and have their wife's breast to replace it? There's a line somewhere, right? I had trouble falling asleep the other night, maybe a warm breastmilk nightcap would have taken the edge off?

Seems like everyone defending it has STILL picked an age where it starts being 'wrong' in their own heads, but they are coming down on anyone who picked a younger age as sexist or backwards...

Kids will wean themselves naturally. My wife and I agreed that we'd let our daughter wean herself on her own time. She stopped totally around age 5. But, before that it was really slowing down a lot, usually just once in the evening before bed.

It certainly has not harmed her. She's a smart, independent kid that is very sociable. She's rarely ever sick. Now, I don't know if that's because of the breastfeeding (it could be the brilliant parenting ;) ), but it did not hurt one bit. And, recent research shows that extended breastfeeding produces kids that tend to be more intelligent and independent.

But, anyone who thinks kids will keep breastfeeding indefinitely if they aren't forced to wean are just wrong. Anyone who thinks "extended" breastfeeding will harm the kids, are also plain wrong. I don't care if parents stop breastfeeding earlier, often there are many practical reasons to do so. But, certainly it's not wrong or harmful to breastfeed longer.

Mr Awe
 
Just a side note: Trekker - you have no kids and no girlfriend. You whine constantly about your life. Why should we take your opinion as gospel when you obviously have no idea what you're talking about and can't even get your own shit together??

How about you get your shit together and jam something up your ass?

Kid - check

wife - check

Non-obsession with what others think of me - check.

Looks like I'm doing ok.
 
Just a side note: Trekker - you have no kids and no girlfriend. You whine constantly about your life. Why should we take your opinion as gospel when you obviously have no idea what you're talking about and can't even get your own shit together??

How about you get your shit together and jam something up your ass?

Kid - check

wife - check

Non-obsession with what others think of me - check.

Looks like I'm doing ok.

Going on line to pick on people like a heartless douche? - Check
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top