• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Best Stand-Alone Episodes in Enterprise?

Twilight - if that one can be considered a standalone, but in that regard it is not so different from Similitude, is it - both are parts of the Xindi arc, but tell standalone self-contained stories
I'm scratching my head trying to figure out what makes it like Similitude.
Instead of scratching your head, you may have tried to read the rest of the sentence, which spells out exactly in what way it is similar. If you missed it the first time, you might have at least tried to read the quote in your own post. Here, I'm even helping you with the bold font this time. :rolleyes:
 
The best standalone episode of the entire series is, in my eyes, "Shuttlepod One" from the first season. Hands down. A classic of Trek storytelling in most senses of the word...touching...hilarious...human...revealing...and appropriately tense without being over-the-top.
 
Cogenitor
Regeneration
Dear Doctor

If Enterprise coulda pulled off episodes like this more often it could have rivaled the best of DS9.
 
And what makes SP1 all the more impressive is that it came so early in the show's run. Midway through the first season at the latest. Later seasons had their share of incisive, well-crafted episodes about the characters and their personalities and relationships, but this was the first one to hit the ball outta the park and did so with few special effects and little more than a cramped shuttlepod set.
 
And what makes SP1 all the more impressive is that it came so early in the show's run. Midway through the first season at the latest. Later seasons had their share of incisive, well-crafted episodes about the characters and their personalities and relationships, but this was the first one to hit the ball outta the park and did so with few special effects and little more than a cramped shuttlepod set.
I definitely agree with you Cooleddie.I felt the same way when I saw Shuttlepod 1 for the very first time it aired.The great acting with Connor and Dominic is what really made this show standout.
 
And what makes SP1 all the more impressive is that it came so early in the show's run. Midway through the first season at the latest. Later seasons had their share of incisive, well-crafted episodes about the characters and their personalities and relationships, but this was the first one to hit the ball outta the park and did so with few special effects and little more than a cramped shuttlepod set.
Yup. And they did it to save money. No guests, no special sets. One of the best episodes of Trek EVER!
 
Even TV GUIDE ranked "SP1" as one of the 100 Greatest Moments in the TV franchise. It was one of maybe two ENT moments on the entire list, but it was placed pretty high...somewhere in the Top Dozen or 20 series moments.
 
Twilight - if that one can be considered a standalone, but in that regard it is not so different from Similitude, is it - both are parts of the Xindi arc, but tell standalone self-contained stories
I'm scratching my head trying to figure out what makes it like Similitude.
Instead of scratching your head, you may have tried to read the rest of the sentence, which spells out exactly in what way it is similar. If you missed it the first time, you might have at least tried to read the quote in your own post. Here, I'm even helping you with the bold font this time. :rolleyes:
Brofist, DevilEyes! :techman::lol:
 
My favorite stand-alones are:
* Twilight
* The Forge (you don't need to see the rest of the arc)
"Twilight" is part of the Xindi arc and is not a standalone. "The Forge" is part of the Vulcan arc and also is not a standalone.

Every episode of Ent was no doubt written to be a self contained episode that could be understood and (hopefully, for the writers), enjoyed without needing to be supported or "explained" by the viewer having seen other episodes. This includes all the arc episodes as well as those thought to be standalones.

I think they generally succeeded, though the enjoyment part was always in the eye of the beholder.
 
My favorite stand-alones are:
* Twilight
* The Forge (you don't need to see the rest of the arc)
"Twilight" is part of the Xindi arc and is not a standalone. "The Forge" is part of the Vulcan arc and also is not a standalone.

Every episode of Ent was no doubt written to be a self contained episode that could be understood and (hopefully, for the writers), enjoyed without needing to be supported or "explained" by the viewer having seen other episodes. This includes all the arc episodes as well as those thought to be standalones.

I think they generally succeeded, though the enjoyment part was always in the eye of the beholder.
Actually, I agree that Twilight is a stand-alone episode.

It's a self-contained story within the season's arc, but if it had been dropped from the episode lineup, it would have no impact on the continuity of the season.

OTOH, in the season 4 Babel arc, if you had dropped United or the Aenar, the arc collapses and you lose the resolution to the story.
 
^ Thanks!

Instead of scratching your head, you may have tried to read the rest of the sentence

I read what you said. I'm just telling you what I disagree with what you said. Stand alone, as Jinx indicates, to me means it has little or no impact into the season. Because it's a time-travel episode where a reset was hit, means it has no impact to me.
 
First Flight is an excellent standalone episode I liked seeing how Archer &Trip met and the testflights of the Phoenix project.A.g.Robinson is a great character and I also liked seeing more of Maxwell Forest.I also liked the fact Trip.A.G. and Archer went against Starfleet's orders and the Vulcans trying to stop their testflights and they proved Henry Archer's warp engine worked.
 
I'm scratching my head trying to figure out what makes it like Similitude.
Instead of scratching your head, you may have tried to read the rest of the sentence, which spells out exactly in what way it is similar. If you missed it the first time, you might have at least tried to read the quote in your own post. Here, I'm even helping you with the bold font this time. :rolleyes:
Brofist, DevilEyes! :techman::lol:
And your point is... what, exactly?
 
^ Thanks!

Instead of scratching your head, you may have tried to read the rest of the sentence
I read what you said. I'm just telling you what I disagree with what you said. Stand alone, as Jinx indicates, to me means it has little or no impact into the season. Because it's a time-travel episode where a reset was hit, means it has no impact to me.
What impact did Sim's existence and fate have on the rest of the season?
 
^ Thanks!

Instead of scratching your head, you may have tried to read the rest of the sentence
I read what you said. I'm just telling you what I disagree with what you said. Stand alone, as Jinx indicates, to me means it has little or no impact into the season. Because it's a time-travel episode where a reset was hit, means it has no impact to me.
What impact did Sim's existence and fate have on the rest of the season?
Sim's confession to T'Pol led directly to Harbinger, and the fact of his existence haunted Archer and caused him to do something foolish (which ended up advancing the arc) in Azati Prime. So, I don't think it's accurate to say that Similitude had no impact on the rest of the season. It shaped characters' choices down the line.

Having said that, I do agree that someone with only a passing knowledge of ENT's S3 could sit down and enjoy - even understand - the entirety of the story without extensive explanation beforehand. In Similitude, the mission is the clock ticking in the background, not the focus of the story ("Earth needs Enterprise; Enterprise needs Trip."). In Twilight, T'Pol's exposition to Archer sets up the conflict enough that a casual viewer would at least get the gist, if not the details. I contrast that with, say, Countdown, which requires pretty detailed knowledge of the episodes preceding it. To me, Similitude and Twilight (along with North Star, Doctor's Orders, and Extinction (ugh!)) are sufficiently understood as stories all by themselves to be considered standalone, even though they may have subtle repercussions that show up later on in the arc.
 
My favorite stand-alones are:
* Twilight
* The Forge (you don't need to see the rest of the arc)
"Twilight" is part of the Xindi arc and is not a standalone. "The Forge" is part of the Vulcan arc and also is not a standalone.

Every episode of Ent was no doubt written to be a self contained episode that could be understood and (hopefully, for the writers), enjoyed without needing to be supported or "explained" by the viewer having seen other episodes. This includes all the arc episodes as well as those thought to be standalones.

I think they generally succeeded, though the enjoyment part was always in the eye of the beholder.
Actually, I agree that Twilight is a stand-alone episode.

It's a self-contained story within the season's arc, but if it had been dropped from the episode lineup, it would have no impact on the continuity of the season.
I adhere to the strict definition of "standalone", which is a term, I believe, initially coined to describe episodes of the X-Files that did not involve the overall "myth arc". For Ent's purposes, that would not define "Twilight", and especially not "The Forge". This would be true even if the episode does not push the arc story forward which admittedly, Twlight did not. "The Forge" of course, certainly pushed it's mini arc forward.

In my estimation, the only standalone in season 3 was "North Star". The episode had nothing to do with the Xindi arc, except that the crew would probably not have discovered the planet if they had not been in the Expanse.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top