Best Episode of Season 3, Part 1

[Necros]

A tough choice again but I'll vote for Twilight, Impulse and E2.

Damn, this voting stuff makes me want to watch some episodes of Enterprise again, and I should be doing something else. Oh well, the day is far from over...

 

[KayArr]

Not my favorite season by a long shot, but Azati Prime, Damage, and The Forgotten was a hell of a trilogy. First time in all these polls I've voted three in row like that, but there you go.

p.s. I think Similtude is the worst ep in all Trek, worse even than Tuvix. Hope it doesn't win!

 

[cooleddie74]

IMO Similtude was the most over-rated though it did feature that great scene between Phlox and Archer. The premise and the science are ludicrous though it did present a clue about T'Pol's mental state starting to decline.

One downside to "Similitude"(it didn't have many IMHO)was the sophisticated cloning tech used by Phlox. Something we never saw in TOS or TAS or their associated movies or even alluded to...and even better than the tech used by the 22nd, 23rd and 24th century descendants of the S.S. Mariposa crash mentioned and seen in "Up the Long Ladder(TNG)." We wouldn't see(chronologically)anything this rapid and complex until DS9 and the Dominion War.

 

[gblews]

Azati Prime/Damage, Similitude

 

[angie]

The deplorable cloning in Similtude was what ruined it. Memories aren't in cells and if they were in the alien cells used it would be likely Sim had memories of hanging around Phlox's lab over Trip's sappy ones.To me this showed that Manny Coto is all about the froth not body. I think he was ok as a showrunner but his writing was weak.LeVar Burton's directing gave it a great look and feel though so if you don't look closely the ep seems deep and moving which pleased many viewers. Twilight however had strong writing, great directing and was poignant on many levels not just to certain fans.

 

[Michael]

I voted ...

Exile
Stratagem
Damage

BTW, this poll is closed. Here is part two.

 

[LegateDamar]

I voted for Countdown. Great action and Major Hayes goes out a hero.