Best Episode of Season 2, Part 1

[Skywalker]

Carbon Creek
Dead Stop
First Flight

Dead Stop is aptly named. The season started out pretty well, and then went to crap (for the most part) after that episode.

 

[indranee]

I voted ANIS 'cos I love it

 

[Trekwatcher]

I am continually amazed at all the praise Cogenitor always receives.

It has to be second most overrated ENT episode. Where to start?

Let's see two unnecessary subplots(those subplots themselves prevent the episode from being excellent IMO) that were a distraction from the meatier A-plot which deserved and needed the full hour dedicated to it in order to flesh things out. This could have been ENT's "The Measure of a Man" but wasn't. I enjoy a good meaty dilemma but this episode failed to supply necessary information and arguments to flesh out the debate plus we never were let in on how or why Archer came around. The asylum hearing was too short and rushed. I was just shaking my head at all the interesting arguments glossed over. Archer should have asked the would-be parents how they would feel if the child they so desperately want turned out to be a cogenitor. Would they mind if she were treated like their cogenitor?

I actually think "Cogenitor" is far superior to "The Measure of a Man." I acutely felt the dilemma that the Cogenitor faced, and she is portrayed as desperately wanting to leave her ship and stay on the NX-01. In the TNG episode, which I also like, because it was Data I was not nearly as concerned and you knew it would all work out just fine in the end.

To each his own.

 

[Garth Rockett]

I voted for Dead Stop, The Catwalk, and The Expanse.

 

[Necros]

ENT's season two is highly underrated, to say the least. In my humble opinion that is.

True.

Shockwave, Part II
Singularity
The Expanse

This time I could choose three but damn, it was still difficult.

 

[Temis the Vorta]

Oy. Hard to find three worth voting for.

Minefield
Dead Stop
The Expanse

Episodes that still annoy me for the reasons they originally annoyed me:

Cogeniter
Judgement
Regeneration

And of course we all know the horrible, horrible ones...lead by Precious Cargo...