• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Batman v Superman

Batman v Superman???


  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .

Taylirious

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
[yt]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10yAerkDf4o[/yt]
[yt]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IFwOS2R9o_8[/yt]

Batman: Strange Days" - Bruce Timm's Batman 75th Anniversary Short (Official)

75 YEARS, 75 BATMEN

v

[yt]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ebXB0lBoaQ0[/yt]

Superman 75th Anniversary Animated Short

VOTE! :evil: :bolian:

ETA: It is who you like more rather than who would win but that is fun to discuss too. I feel Batman gets more attention these days, like a billionaire with toys is more relatable than an alien with superpowers! :p
 
Last edited:
Is this poll about which character you like more, or which one you think would win in a fight....?
 
I like Batman more because he doesn't have actual super powers, so he's forced to be clever and precise instead of using brute force.

In a fight, Superman obviously, but if Batman had prep time and good intel he might be able to set up traps with kryptonite and trick him into them.

Superman vs Batman would be like Gorn vs Kirk. Superman easily wins the direct confrontation but Batman may be smart enough to deny him the direct confrontation.
 
Who would win in a fight? Superman.

Batman could prepare with kryptonite traps all he likes. All Supes has to do is think: "Bats wants to fight me? Let me go get my lead supersuit," break through the traps and beat Brucie into the ground.

Who do I like better? Superman.

I get it's in vogue to say you like the superheroes without powers and just their wits, and Bats is smart and has lotsa gadgets, but same goes for Tony Stark, and Oliver Queen, and Hank Pym, etc.

There ain't no other Superman. He was first and always has been unique.
 
Superman wouldn't necessarily be able to find Batman. I still say Batman's chances depend on his ability to deny Supes the direct confrontation.

Nobody prefers powerless heroes because it's chic or fashionable. I just find heroes who are invulnerable with single exceptions and can otherwise just power through fights with brute force incredibly dull. Just like rooting for Lebron James is boring if his opponent is a ten year old girl.
 
Superman wouldn't necessarily be able to find Batman. I still say Batman's chances depend on his ability to deny Supes the direct confrontation.

Superman is "faster than a speeding bullet." (double-digit Mach numbers...)

Superman can see through anything but lead.

Superman can see tiny objects from miles away.

Superman can see microscopic objects with his naked eyes.

Superman's hearing is so good he can pick individual heartbeats out of crowds.

Superman can fly.

Superman is strong enough to dead-lift thousands of tons (rocks in a fault (the movie), Luthor's yacht (Man of Steel))

Given these abilities the amount of ground he could cover in a search is potentially staggering, so Bats really only has two options for trying to stay hidden:

!. Never stand still in any edifice that isn't completely lined with lead. (Which would actually give supes more info than bats would prefer...)

2. Leave the planet. Even Superman can't get him in space without a space ship.

See eventually, no matter how much hide and seek bats wants to play, if there's a direct confrontation to be had, Superman will have it. And he will win.

Nobody prefers powerless heroes because it's chic or fashionable.
I disagree. Everybody on this board (including me) likes to be intellectual about this thing or the other, and in this case the idea of backing the powerless hero is an intellectual favorite, because it's romantic. The guy with no powers is supposed to get trounced, but he can prepare, and he can be determined and he can beat the odds, yadda and yadda. Right.

But every now and then I like to be an objectivist, and in an objective universe, if two guys want to kill each other and one has no powers and one has Superman's powers the guy with Supe's powers will eventually win. The other guy can't hide forever, no trap will stop the powered guy completely, and using his one weakness against him only works if he doesn't have a countermeasure for the weakness.

I just find heroes who are invulnerable with single exceptions and can otherwise just power through fights with brute force incredibly dull. Just like rooting for Lebron James is boring if his opponent is a ten year old girl.
If the ten year old girl is wearing the jersey of a division or conference rival, I'm sure there are plenty of Cavs fans who would scream themselves hoarse rooting for King James to send her home crying.

The trick to not making Superman boring is finding villains he can't beat with brute force alone (or at least with one shot). You put him up against Mr. Mxyzptlk or Doomsday or Darkseid and watch what happens.
 
I like that Bruce Timm animated short. I generally love the vintage approach when it comes to superhero portrayals. I wish they would do a live-action movie like that.

Kor
 
Always Batman

While they have similar starts (parents both died though Bruce had the misfortune to have to see them die) Superman seemed always too "Boyscout" for me.

Always doing the right thing, never (or almost never) losing control or even in danger of losing control.. he's too much posterboy of what Americans want to be (and rarely are).

Batman is a much darker character, a well trained fighter but still human. A single bullet at the wrong time is the end for him but he still does what he does.

As i'm not much of a DC man i don't know all the details but Batman's villains always seemed far more intriguing and interesting (Joker and Ras al Gul being the best examples), the ones Superman has to fight always seemed to be just over the top (Doomsday, Darkseid).
 
I like them both a lot, but Batman comes out just a little bit ahead. He's a regular human who is able to use cool tech and his trainging to stand alongside powered heroes like Superman, the Flash, and Green Lantern. That's pretty impressive, and just plain cool.
 
I just find heroes who are invulnerable with single exceptions and can otherwise just power through fights with brute force incredibly dull. Just like rooting for Lebron James is boring if his opponent is a ten year old girl.

It probably doesn't help that the main reason Superman seems to be out of everyone's league is because he powers rose to ridiculous levels during the Silver Age and any efforts to bring them back to a more reasonable level usually leads to endless complaining about it.

Remember in the 1930s Superman could get knocked on his ass by an artillery shell.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top