• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Batman - The Black Glove and R.I.P.

coolghoul

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
This thread may contain spoilers for recent storylines....

So I got the collections for the stories prior to the Final Crisis - specifically The Black Glove and also RIP from my friendly neighborhood library. The HC for RIP looks especially gorgeous. The Black Glove HC looks a little lurid with all the faded red.

I think these are both part of Grant Morrison's run on the Batman. I have read some of the collections prior to this. So I am familiar with Damian eg.

However, the two stories left me plenty non-plussed. Either I am not getting it or I'm missing a lot of background.

The Black Glove has Batman attending a meeting on a special island owned by a rich millionaire (John Mayhew). It seems this rich dude had financed the operations of several crimefighters who are similar to Batman but from different nations. "Batmen of All Nations" (never heard of them before). The story itself is inspired from the Agatha Christie classic "And then there were none" - People arrive on an island to find the host absent. And then one by one, people start dying. However, the Batman seems to think that this is the work of an organization called The Black Glove. What was the prior setup for this? What does the Batman know at this point. Didn't much like the artwork - and a couple of the Batmen look very much alike - tho' the female Robin-like character Beryl aka the Squire (I think) was visually interesting. And some of the art at critical places is hard to decipher. (eg. It was only after reading a panel following that I realized that the previous spread had the planes by which they had arrived blowing up). And then there's a story about Bruce on a date with Jezebel Jet (there's even a joke about how his girlfriends have names straight out of a Bond film ;) ) and getting attacked by the Black Glove's minions.

The RIP title is interesting - I have no clue what's real and what's justsomething in the Batman's mind. It starts with him getting attacked by a police-Batman. It seems that at some time during the past (before Gordon was commish) three policemen were identified to take over as the Batman if the real Batman died. (That sounds real hokey to me for several reasons - but maybe it refers to an actual storyline). One of the 3 Batman even looks vaguely like Bane but I don't think it is. And then he gets dragged to the basement and drugged and he becomes a street vagabond and then talks to Honor Jackson (who may or may not be a figment of his imagination) and then talks to Bat-mite who he calls "Might" who (I think) is a figment of his imagination. And then becomes a Batman dressed in rags with a costume that has some of the Robin's colors... and... I don't know whether you get it from my description but I was just plain confused as to what is going on. There is mention of Thogal ( a Buddhist ritual) that he underwent on Nanda Parbat and Joker who tries to give him clues which didn't mean anything to me etc etc. He also becomes the Batman from Zur-en-arrh (don't ask!!) a different personality or something and the Joker (yep, the master of mirth himself who here is referred to as the Thin White Duke of Death (or something similar) ) actually is present when the rags-Batman takes off his mask to reveal Bruce Wayne's face underneath. Also, it's implied that Batman has shot the Joker in the forehead (actually used a gun!!) and the bullet seems to be lodged there or something... There's somebody called John Hurt, who pretends to be Thomas Wayne. There are tabloid pictures of Thomas Wayne and Martha Wayne where Martha is a drug addict... The weird stuff just goes on and on...

My understanding is that at the end when Bruce Wayne gets "better", he returns to the mansion and Alfred and Robin and says that "he will make things better" when he comes back from a Justice League mission (presumably this is Final Crisis). And then we have the current Battle of the Cowl event. But all that (for me) is yet to come since I haven't read any of it. What I want to know is what the h3!! is going on in this storyline.

Per the comments from Grant Morrison - this was the first storyline that he had come up with when he had come to writing the Batman. I don't know whether he had discussed with his editors and they had thought this is the guy who should be the main Batman writer. The storyline seems to have originated with the fan-trope that the Batman can take on anything if he has time to prepare but this takes that to fairly weird lengths. I mean there's talk of a backup personality, a human OS.

Was this storyline well-received? Do you like it? Do you understand it all? Is there an article (not wikipedia which just tells me what I read) that explains the whole thing?
 
It is a very confusing storyline and I'm also catching up on the trades. The first trade "Batman and Son" introduces Damian and the Three Police Batman. The Cop-Batman is the one who shoots Joker in the head, not the real Bats. I believe Black Glove wasn't mentioned before the "Black Glove" trade. But they did talk about Doctor Hurt helping Bats do the sensory deprivation thing, that was connected to the 3 Cop Bats right I forget. I just read a Morrison interview where he reveals that Mayhew/Black Glove was in fact the devil trying to break Bats just before his "death" in Final Crisis. ... I too did a double take when Brucie unmasked in front of Joker!!! For Morrison's run on Bats in trade it goes "Batman and Son", "Ressurection Ra'sh Al Ghul" (which doesn't really impact this story), "Black Glove", "RIP", and then "Final Crisis", then Morrison doesn't write Bats for like a year and he comes back this Fall I believe.
 
You have to read it twice for it to really sink in and then I think you'll understand and enjoy it all the more. I'd start from Batman and Son and read all the way through RIP.
 
I liked RIP but I read it all at once in trade so that probably helped. I liked the idea of this all knowing criminal mastermind trying to systematically destroy him and the creepy Joker involvement as well. RednPurple Bats looked silly but I can forgive it. It's just so cool that Bats is so amazing he developed a "back up personality" in case anyone ever broke him. I also love that Alfred line in the FC two parter at the end of the trade where he says someday some invincible villain will have him captured and think he's beaten but then they'll falter for one second and then he'll have them (I paraphrase).
 
Mr. Light - Thanks for the list of the trades. I think I have read both Batman and Son and also The Resurrection of R'as Al Ghul (gorgeous cover artwork - Bats and R'as always work well). But I guess I must have forgotten about the 3 Cop-Bats. Will try to read it all thru like sidious618 suggests.

I don't really understand what is meant by a 'back up personality'. Also how is it that Bats' main personality gets "broken" - are we talking due to the drugs he is injected with? Why doesn't he just sleep it off ? Bats has gone thru a lot worse (I'm thinking of Knightfall and Bane's master-plan) without it breaking his mind. Also I don't understand what is real and what is not. Does he really meet Honor Jackson and One-eye Lincoln? Or is it all in his head.

Also - Joker knowing Bats' identity is huge! Are they going to reset it due to Final Crisis? (Did it do another continuity reboot?) Also - a question re the Crises and some of the names mentioned here - Silver St. Cloud is mentioned and Julie Madison and Vicki Vale are actually seen. Have they been brought up in the comics since the last DC continuity reset? (Infinite Crisis?) Or should I give up that line of thinking since all I'll get is a headache?
 
I also completely forgot Jezebel Jet and the Three Batman being in "Batman and Son" which I read like a year ago. I think that the hobo and Bat-Mite were supposed to be either a) mental hallucinations or b) extra-dimensional angels helping him along to beat the devil. The back-up personality they stated in RIP... as I dimly remember he created it in the sensory deprivation chamber thing or in the Thurgal ceremony in "52". Hurt created the "Zurr En Argh" codeword during the sensory chamber to break his mind, but Bats' back-up personality managed to overcome it. ... I don't think the Joker has appeared since RIP but I imagine Morrison will continue that storyline when he returns to the title in a few months with the new "Batman and Robin" mag. The Wizard interview with him also hinted the Black Glove would return as well.
 
I liked Batman and Son, but Batman RIP left me scratching my head. One day I might sit down and read all of the issues again. But the first time through I was disappointed and confused. The Black Glove was a good idea, I liked many of Morrison's original villains, and the artwork was great. However, I thought the 'ending' was crap, and a cop-out.

From what I take of it, Simon Hurt was supposed to be the Devil (lame). I read that in a Wizard article review of the RIP. And I guess RIP was supposed to show how badass Batman was by one-upping the Devil himself. Then there was this lump thing and two scientists working for Darkseid and I think they were trying to create an army of Batmen or something in the following Last Rites storyline.

I am liking the Morrison-less Battle for the Cowl a whole lot better though.
 
Batman R.I.P. was confusing to me as well...if you guys get an opportunity Wizard recently had "audio" commentary from Morrison on Batman R.I.P. and he explains the meanings or at least his intentions or inspirations behind the story arc. What I got out of it was that the entire Black Glove episode was part of a larger plan devised by Joker...it's all part of the plan. Morrison will be back by the way later this summer with Batman and Robin after BFTC is completed. The first page or whatever of R.I.P. actually shows the new Batman and Robin six months later then flashes back, at least that is what Morrison explains.

Batman was captured by Granny Goodness during Final Crisis...not sure what issue because I haven't read it, just the wiki synopsis and I assume that scene where the two scientists are torturing Bruce or shifting through his memories takes place during this sequence.

It's pretty confusing for sure...but enjoyable, especially after you hear the explainations for what was intended. I enjoyed it more on the second read through.
 
I just read that Wizard interview a few days ago and I definitely did not get the impression that the Joker was behind the Black Glove. He was just a wild card that got involved. That's like saying the Joker is the force behind the Devil ;) ... Yeah "Last Rites" took place in the middle of Final Crisis when Bats was being held prisoner by Darkseid, that was pretty clear. The scientists using "The Lump" on his mind were working for Darkseid trying to create a Batman army of clones. Everything in that story was just a mental hallucination in Bats' head created by the Lump.
 
The story is so much better when you read the annotations. They really give a sense of how well Morrison crafted the story and the hints he placed throughout.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top