• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Avatar: The Last Airbender - Netflix Live Action Version

AS HE SHOULD BE!!

As to watching the animated series first... it depends on if you would rather see the remixed version or the original. I don't think there's anything wrong with watching it (and Korra of course!) first, it's just a matter of if you want to finish at least the first season before Netflix drops the live action adaptation.
 
If they do show the Zhao flashback they could just show him taking advantage of the spirit's relative benevolence and have it be fairly quick. I hope that they keep Wan Shi Tong's true nature mysterious until Season 2 and do a pretty straightforward adaption of his episode. Having him appear as one of several spirits when Aang travels to the Spirit World would be one thing, but emphasizing his sinister nature is something I'd prefer they spend time building towards, especially if they're doing Koh (and I presume that's where Kuruk will come in?).
Is Wan Shi Tong the spirit that looks like a giant Panda sometimes?
 
The core trio are really well-cast. The more I see them, the more I feel it's like they're the animated characters brought to life. Not as convinced by Zuko and Iroh yet.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I watched the first episode. I think it was great.
Structured different than the animated show, of course, probably for the better.
We already know in broad strokes how things will unfold, so the show starts with the downfall of the Southern Air Temple and reintroduces Aang before he got trapped in the ice.
The story still unfolds as we‘ve seen in the animated show, with Katara and Sokka finding him during fishing, Zuko attacking the village in search of the Avatar etc.

The show compresses the story a bit and includes Aang‘s rescue from Zuko‘s ship and ends with Aang discovering the destruction of his home going into the Avatar state before accepting his destiny.
The 1 hour episode basically covers 3 episodes of the original, which makes sense.

Little changes from the animated show: Aang gets a short personal conversation and introduction with Iroh, hinting at Iroh not being on board with the Fire Nation‘s actions.
The opening lines of the show were changed slightly and spoken by I believe Avatar Kyoshi?

Katara‘s Original opening lines were still included later but spoken by Sokka‘s and Katara‘s grandmother who gets the role of Avatar exposition for the rest of the cast.

Aang is allowed to show vulnerability and grief and I think they struck a good balance with his light hearted nature.
He is not quite the goof and jokester yet, but still many episodes to watch yet. :)

The visuals are amazing. If this were a theatrical release I still would have been amazed at the production values.
Everything looks like the cartoon come to life but still realistic enough.
The different bending styles are convincing and actually feel powerful and balanced.

So far it is exactly what I hoped it would be.
 
Definitely more violent in live-action than I expected given a PG rating.

In the first episode
You see multiple people burned alive and corpses with horrible wounds.

The opening sequence showing earth bending was very cool.

I thought the actors playing the leads all seemed pretty good. Zuko is a bit over the top, but Zuko is an overly theatrical drama queen so can't really blame the actor there.

It can be difficult walking a line between adapting from the animated medium faithfully, while also realizing some things play better animated than live.
 
They know that their original audience is all adults now and adapt accordingly. Sure, the depiction of violence, especially the fire bending implied pretty gruesomeness and didn’t shy away away from showing it at all. At the same time I don’t think the show went too dark for a younger audience.
Parental Guidance is appropriate.
 
Two episodes in, and I find it very impressive. It's remarkably faithful, yet not afraid to put the pieces together in new ways that make it interestingly different. The visuals are excellent and the fight choreography is impressive, with authentic bending styles. The cast is superb. The core trio in particular look and feel like the animated characters brought to life, and Gordon Cormier is terrific as Aang. I'm still not entirely sold on Ken Leung as Zhao; he comes off initially as weaker and less arrogant. But there are signs of a devious menace beneath the surface, so hopefully that will come out more.

Not sure I like having Aang pull himself out of the Avatar State by remembering Gyatso, instead of Katara doing it and solidifying their bond. But it kind of makes sense structurally, given the larger role Gyatso had in the episode, to give him that payoff.

Also, Aang did no waterbending during his escape, so technically Zuko never got conclusive proof that he's the Avatar.

I do like giving Aang and Iroh a new scene together to establish a bond. Iroh was a little underdeveloped in the early episodes of the original show, but this has the advantage of being able to fold in later developments from the start.

I like the change that the waterbending scroll is a gift from Gran-Gran. They didn't have room to do a whole episode about Katara stealing it from pirates, so reworking it as a connection to her heritage is a nice substitute.

People were worried about Sokka losing his sexism, but they replaced it with a nice dynamic of Sokka seeing Suki as a fellow protector and Suki doubting his qualifications. Their training scenes together were excellent. I'm a little disappointed they didn't change things so Suki became a full member of the Gaang from here on.

The biggest change is having Kyoshi be the first past life Aang connects with, and using the idea of a past Avatar manifesting physically through Aang to do battle. The former makes sense in context of the episode, though it breaks with the logic of Aang connecting with his past lives in reverse order. It certainly works to set up the contrast between Kyoshi's warrior values and Aang's pacifism, bringing up the past-life dialogues from "The Old Masters" to a much earlier point in the story. The latter has precedent in "Avatar Day," so it's authentic (though Kyoshi only spoke there, so it could've been an illusion), but it opens up an impressive new potential, even if he can only do it at the Avatars' shrines.

It's also an interesting change that the season arc is driven by the prophecy of disaster befalling the North. That lets them dodge the whole Sozin's Comet deadline while still having a quest driver and a ticking clock. And it's nice foreshadowing for the big finish.

So far, my one real disappointment is that Aang's glider is just a featureless wooden rod in its furled state. I can buy that in animation where I can assume there are just details that aren't drawn, but in live action I was hoping to see a more realistic design with visible grooves that the wings were furled up within.


one thing that has stood out to me is how faithful the music is

It bugs me that, if IMDb's credits are complete, there's no credit for Jeremy Zuckerman. He really should get a "themes by" credit immediately before or after the new composer's credit, since they're using so much of his work.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top