I was wondering if this 1998 film would get a brand new HD telecine for a Blu-ray...
Another review feels differently about the 5.1 surround mix though:
Sure the film itself is very stylized and over the top and the darkest space shuttle ever (lighting-wise) but the production design is really great.
As some of you may already know, the original master was apparently destroyed in a fire, so a new print had to be struck and a new HD digital master created just for this release. That means the transfer is brand spanking new, and the 1080p image really benefits from it. Colors are bold and vibrant. Contrast is terrific too - the shadows are deep and detailed, yet the brightest areas of the picture are never overblown. Meanwhile, the detail and textures are crisp and plentiful, without appearing edgy or digitally over-scrubbed. There's just enough grain visible to leave the image looking nicely film-like. Disney's just done a great job with this image. (Note that the Blu-ray contains the theatrical cut of the film, not the slightly longer version that appeared on DVD from Criterion.)
The only issue is that the original 5.1 mix isn't quite up to the standards of Bay's more recent films - say Transformers. The soundfield is just a little more front-biased than more recent action 5.1 mixes, with more directional surround play. What probably needs to happen, is that Bay himself needs to come in and remix the film.
Unfortunately, the extras are virtually nonexistent. If you have Disney's very first non-anamorphic DVD release - one of the studio's first DVDs from WAY back in 1997 - be aware that everything on that disc carries over here.
NONE of the superior extras from the 1999 Criterion DVD release are included here.
The new transfer is just too good looking in my opinion for fans to pass up on. You have to take into consideration here that Armageddon was never released on DVD with a true anamorphic widescreen transfer - both of the previous DVDs were letterboxed widescreen only.
http://www.thedigitalbits.com/reviewshd/bdreviews041410.html#armYou'll obviously want to hang on to that Criterion DVD, but you can finally pitch the original DVD in the trash
Another review feels differently about the 5.1 surround mix though:
http://www.blu-raydefinition.com/reviews/armageddon-blu-ray-review.htmlThe DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 (48kHz/24-bit) soundtrack for Armageddon is an absolute aural assault, as one would expect. Sounds come from every direction, explosions absolutely BOOM and resonate right through your bones. There is hardly a moment when there isn’t discrete sound coming from the surrounds in this mix. There is also a good amount of ambient sound effects used to bring everything all together in a cohesive manner.
Sure the film itself is very stylized and over the top and the darkest space shuttle ever (lighting-wise) but the production design is really great.