• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Anybody else sick of Brett Favre?

Pegaritaville, I don't think this whole fiasco had anything to do with "patience" on the Green Bay front office's end. When Favre first retired, the front office gave a half-assed, half-hearted goodbye which was essentially "don't let the door hit you on the way out." They didn't treat him with any respect, they acted like he was beneath them, and then Mark Murphy tries to speak on what was in Favre's heart during his retirement? They don't want him to come back and they don't want him to play for another team. They want to treat him the same way the Lions treated Barry Sanders.

And today, they say Favre can return to the Packers as a backup.
 
^^^

Just a few weeks after he retired, shortly after the owners meeting, Brett called the GM in Green Bay and said he wanted to come back. He and the coach chartered a jet to fly down to Mississippi to meet with Favre. They were going to bring him back and they had informed Rodgers that he would be riding the pine once again. Just before they left, Favre called back and said he had changed his mind and would stay retired. I don't blame the Packers for being pissy with him. He has "cried wolf" far too many times. He is acting like a spoiled child, not the gridiron hero we all thought he was.
 
Now, before anyone jumps on me about how awful I am for hoping that, keep in mind that the Packers' defense is so pathetic that they don't have anyone capable of actually doing that.

But the Bears' offensive line is even worse
emot-haw.gif
I hope the Bears pick him up. He won't last more than a quarter against Green Bay.

Fucker.
 
Green Bay shouldn't cut him. If he's reinstated, they should make him sit on the bench. Enough with these retired/unretired shenanigans.
 
I hope that wherever he ends up he falls flat on his face. What a jerk!!! Here was a guy any football fan could respect, and now his reputation is ruined and rightly so. People gave Jerry Rice a bunch of shit for not retiring with the niners and going to play for other teams. But Jerry never pulled this namby pamby BS that Favre did. He's a joke.

Gotta agree. I gave him the benefit of the doubt at first, but the more I hear, the more disgusted I am with him.

That was the problem with Barry Sanders here in Detroit, it wasn't what he did but how he went about it. At the time, head coach Bobby Ross had to send him a letter to find out if he was going to play that year!
 
Not a Packer fan, but I've always enjoyed watching Favre play. Last season proved he's still a good QB. Carolina would probably be a nice fit for him.
 
Doing to Favre what the Lions did to Barry Sanders will not go over very well, especially when the front office already comes across as being smug and arrogant, and acting like they're more responsible for the Packers legacy than Favre.
 
I like Brett Farve a lot, but I'm fed up with this as I'm sure the Packer front office is. After going back and forth so many times and making the Pack hold all the plans while he made up his mind... well it has knocked him down a bit in my book.
 
:guffaw:

I saw this coming a LONG time ago. Of COURSE he was going to waffle.

http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=50608&highlight=Favre


Way back then I said this (while others didn't believe he'd come back):

Not surprised in the least. How could you be? The guy has hemmed and hawed back and forth for a few years now. Always leaving the Pack hanging as to what he might do and when. Just because he said he was retiring and shed a few tears...that all means nothing if he changes his mind in a week or two. It's happened before with so many other athletes in the past (and bands playing "farewell tours"). Why should Favre suddently be any different? Especially when he's been the king of "can't make up his mind" in the last few years.

I wanna play. No, I'm done. No, I wanna play. Umm, I'm done. Wait - I got the itch! The Packers have done the right thing by saying they're done playing games. You wanted to play, Brett? Just said you wanted another season initially. You made your bed...
 
Channel 3 in Madison is now reporting that Favre wants the Packers to let him play for someone else. Article: http://www.channel3000.com/sports/16882072/detail.html

Let's face it.... how long is it going to take before they bench Rogers in favor of Favre? A whole game? A quarter? Two games? And now, because of this: http://www.bringbackbrettfavre.com/ the fans are going to try to hold Ted Thompson's feet to the fire over it.

This has more potential for teh_dramaz than a HS girls' locker room the week before Prom.
 
After tonight, the Packers are officially right up there with the Lions. Favre may be a hassle, but Thompson and Murphy botched this every way possible.
 
Aragorn, are you saying that the Packers should reinstate him as the starter? Does that mean that the superstar runs the team and the coaching staff and front office aren't actually in charge? Lombardi would have done the same damn thing, and he'd be kicking anyones' ass who said different.
 
After tonight, the Packers are officially right up there with the Lions. Favre may be a hassle, but Thompson and Murphy botched this every way possible.

I fail to see how Thompson has botched this situation, given that he was ready and willing to welcome Favre back with open arms after he first notified the team of his intention to un-retire (back in March), and made sure that the team was having open discussions with him throughout the offseason.

You can't fault Thompson for refusing to draft blind for yet another year. As the GM of the team, his responsibility is to build a roster and develop talent, not bow to the whims of his former starting quarterback. The simple fact is that Thompson needed to know whether or not Favre was going to play before the team went into the draft (which gave Favre several months to decide).

The crux of this matter is that Favre has decided that he is bigger than the team. Green Bay may be Favre's team for life, but those players are NOT Favre's players. They're Rodgers' players. Those players came up with Rodgers. This generation of Packers was tailored towards Aaron Rodgers.

But people don't want to hear about the future. Because apparently Packers fans have turned into Eagles fans, and the Packers absolutely have to win a Super Bowl right now or sack the entire team. I know people like to say "I'd rather have one Super Bowl year and a bunch of miserable years," but that's not a choice given to you. Well-run football organizations strive to win consistently; it's the only real shot any team has at making it to the big game (and to staying financially solvent). The Packers are thinking about how they're going to win now, how they're going to win a year from now, how they're going to win 5 years from now. They shouldn't have to put up with this shit.
 
The crux of this matter is that Favre has decided that he is bigger than the team. Green Bay may be Favre's team for life, but those players are NOT Favre's players. They're Rodgers' players. Those players came up with Rodgers. This generation of Packers was tailored towards Aaron Rodgers.

Very well said! I agree 100%
 
Brett needs to stay retired, it's just getting sad at this point.

And GB is in a no-win scenario here, so might as well stick to their plan.

If they take him back as a starter, it screws up their long-term plans, their recent draft, etc. Will also lose Rodgers when his contract is up.

Take him back as a backup (or offer that), and Farve is pissed, plus Rodgers has him looking over his shoulder, slightest injury kills the deal.

Trade him, and there's a potential that he hurts you by helping an opponent. Same if they release him.

What is GB supposed to do? I'd stick with what they've done for the moment. If Farve FORCES his way back, then eventually they'll have to try and trade him, I guess, and see if they can get anything...
 
From ProFootballTalk:

According to the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, Favre slams Thompson in the segment that will air Tuesday night on Fox News, and Favre points to three incidents that caused him to not trust Thompson.

First was Favre’s desire that the team add receiver Randy Moss in 2007. We reported, numerous times, that Favre was actively lobbying the team to acquire Moss after two failed seasons with the Raiders. There was also a rumor that the team’s failure to try to land the star receiver, who revived his career in a big way with the Patriots last season, prompted Favre to make noise about leaving the team. Though it’s still unclear whether the latter proposition is accurate, it’s now obvious that Favre wanted Moss — and that Favre didn’t appreciate Thompson’s decision not to be honest about that fact with the public.

“I worked my butt off . . . to try to get them to sign Randy Moss,” Favre told Fox News.

Second, Favre says he tried to get Thompson to re-sign guards Marco Rivera and Mike Wahle, both of whom left via free agency.

Third, Favre pushed hard for Thompson to consider hiring former 49ers and Lions coach Steve Mariucci, but Thompson rebuffed Brett, hiring Mike McCarthy instead.

“[N]one of those had anything to do with me retiring once again,” Favre says, “but, you know, it’s hard for me to trust, you know, this guy when I — either I’m told one thing and everyone else is told another, or he’s telling the public one thing and telling me another. And so — and that’s part of the reason for the [request for a] release.”

So Favre didn’t retire from the Packers because of mistrust for Thompson, but now Favre wants out in part because he doesn’t trust Thompson.

But, Brett, didn’t you say you want out because the Packers told you that they don’t want you to play?

More importantly, Brett, when did you become the quarterback/General Manager of the Packers?

Maybe we finally understand why Favre kept quiet for so long on this topic. Now that he’s opening his mouth, he’s sounding like an idiot.

Regarding this apparent effort to smear Thompson by dredging up outdated and irrelevant pisses and/or moans, Favre needs to realize that he hasn’t always been truthful, either. On July 2, for example, he said that the talk of his desire to return is “rumor” and that there’s “[n]o reason for it.”

So before Brett says “you know, it’s hard for me to trust, you know, this guy when I — either I’m told one thing and everyone else is told another, or he’s telling the public one thing and telling me another,” Favre should ask “this guy” in the mirror whether he has been doing the very same thing.

Brett Favre ... please kindly eat a dick.

Love,
A Bears fan enjoying all the turmoil taking place in Ashwaubenon right now
 
I can understand his frustration. While he's not the GM or head coach, he is the field general, and if there are troops he wants under his command, that should at least be entertained.

I don't know if they song and danced him over Randy Moss or the guards, but I wouldn't expect someone who is bitter to be completely truthful about it either. If very possible that he lobbied for Moss and was told, "No. That guy's a dickhead and we don't want him on our team." At that point, Favre's options would have been to suck it up or try to leave.


That said, why is he needing to do this song and dance now. Either he wants to play or he doesn't. If he hangs around GB as the back-up, you know he's going to play. I don't think Aaron Rogers is that good, and starting QBs often sit because of injury, even if it's only for a set of downs. Favre could have some miraculous comeback and the Pack could turn around and screw Rogers.

Bottom-line is that they need to be looking to the future and planning for him to be gone. He needs to let them do that. Quit dicking around, Brett.

And props to JKTim for getting the actual city right.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top