Only if that debate was very short and ended with a consensus of "obviously not". @Shalashaska is right - TNG needed fresh blood and when it got it, it soared. It no more needed the writers of a twenty year old show than it needed the cast from one. The same is true now - you can't just get the writing team from TNG back, change the name of the Captain and expect new stories for a 2016 audience. Fuller and Meyer are hardly spent when it comes to Trek ideas, having only done a few stories each, but no regular staff writers from the old shows please. I'd much rather they pinch from successful modern streaming shows.
