Spoilers Andor season one

[fireproof78]

Saying vague nonsense like, "Bad writing", "I didn't like this!" and "This isn't what I like about SW!" are not flaws. They're barely even opinions.

Well, they could be if they were more descriptive. Bad writing is pretty simple descriptor that could be expanded upon. But, not everyone will consider it bad writing either. I think Cassian is a bad character, but that doesn't stop me from watching the show or others from enjoying the character.

 

[Set Harth]

Hopefully Vader shows up and kills Luthen.

I mean, he has to die somehow.

 

[Ithekro]

The thing that keeps circling in my head in this is that while we are getting Luthan and Mothma's input into the Rebellion, my mind keeps wanting to compare and contrast with Bail Organa's groups. He has been in this just as long as Luthan for sure, since we saw Bail's interactions with the surviving Jedi and Padme on Empire Day. We know he is actively seeking more rebels, but we haven't seen such drama from his view (well other than Inquisitor's using his connection to hunt Kenobi).

 

[Turtletrekker]

Hopefully Vader shows up and kills Luthen.

I mean, he has to die somehow.

I think Admiral Yularen is as far up the food chain as the show will reach.

 

[cooleddie74]

I feel Kino Loy. I can't swim, either.

 

[Imaus]

Hopefully Vader shows up and kills Luthen.

I mean, he has to die somehow.

What...vader...Why? Why the hell would you want that?

Luthen probably is much more liable to die from a imperial trooper shooting him while rescuring andor than that. Vader coming in would be such a forced fanservice wedge it wouldn't be funny.

 

[Ithekro]

Vader is probably busy on Mustafar going over reports to see if he is needed in the ongoing investigation of a Jedi going by the name Kanan Jarrus and his assumed apprentice going by the name Jabba.

 

[valkyrie013]

Well, they could be if they were more descriptive. Bad writing is pretty simple descriptor that could be expanded upon. But, not everyone will consider it bad writing either. I think Cassian is a bad character, but that doesn't stop me from watching the show or others from enjoying the character.

Okay, the writing is sub par, as in, what they wrote is boring. Mainly, they take plots and draw them out for to long, what can be done in 1 episode takes 3, and what is writen to fill it in is junk. Boring and doesn't further anything.
And to me , the character is badly written, he's a good actor but what given to him is as said .. Sub par.
The past 2 episodes were decent , I'd say 4 of 10 were decent, rest were sub par filler.

 

[TheForge]

Episode 10 was the best writing Star Wars has ever produced. Really impressed. Someone deserves an award or two.

I wouldn't say that.

Perhaps in your opinion, not in mine.

 

[Dee1891]

Perhaps in your opinion, not in mine.

Exactly.

 

[Set Harth]

I feel Kino Loy. I can't swim, either.

He should have just jumped along with the others. One of the swimmers could presumably have kept him from drowning.

What...vader...Why? Why the hell would you want that?

 

[fireproof78]

What...vader...Why? Why the hell would you want that?

Luthen probably is much more liable to die from a imperial trooper shooting him while rescuring andor than that. Vader coming in would be such a forced fanservice wedge it wouldn't be funny.

Vader is pure fan service and strikes me as way out of proportion for what the series is presenting.

Andor would do well to avoid it.

 

[cooleddie74]

He should have just jumped along with the others. One of the swimmers could presumably have kept him from drowning.

In my head canon and until shown otherwise that's what he did.

 

[Crewman6]

In my head canon and until shown otherwise that's what he did.

Same!

 

[Crewman6]

Vader is pure fan service and strikes me as way out of proportion for what the series is presenting.

Andor would do well to avoid it.

Literally no way in hell the show does that. It's 100x smarter than that.

 

[fireproof78]

Literally no way in hell the show does that. It's 100x smarter than that.

I hope so, but despite its different approach people still expect fan service.

 

[Crewman6]

I hope so, but despite its different approach people still expect fan service.

Yes, because people aren't smart, but the makers of Andor are.

 

[Arpy]

It might actually work. It’d show again why Vader is to be feared. Hell, most of the time he seems to lose or play second fiddle. It would also compliment his role in Rogue One. It’d show him killing the last leader of the Rebellion here and make his charge for the plans at the end of RO scarier still with that in mind. All depends on how next season plays out. Could go either way.

Also in my head canon Kino (til or better yet if we ever find out whatever became of him) is either captured and probably executed or drowned. All the more tragic and speaks to the cost of it all.

 

[shapeshifter]

Well, that escalated quickly.

After incorrectly thinking E8 was the finale, the final two episodes really kicked it up a notch or two for me. S1 ended swimmingly.

 

[cooleddie74]

It's not over yet. We still have two episodes to go before Season 1 is completed!