• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

America's Attack on the Lemonade Stand

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm sure being disenfranchised, poverty stricken, having little to no education, and living in hostile territory played absolutely no part in that decision making process.



Right, because slaves were never hunted down and murdered.

Meh...you are blind to the war crimes of your ancestors...

The Irish? Fucking potato killers.

I'm not a fan of the Irish, they signed them up right off the boat to fight in the war, they were nothing but mercenaries...
 
When fighting against northern education created fanatics no proof I give will be good enough, you will just go back to worshipping the historic figure known as Lincoln...

Yeah, don't let my university education get in the way of your "facts".

Ancestral facts coming from my ancestors, one who served as as officer in the confederacy...trumps your rewritten northern "universities"...

Because oral history narrated by the individuals involved is always completely unbiased and shows the truth? Somebody interview some ex SS-officers, quick. I'm sure they have some fun things to say.
 
When fighting against northern education created fanatics no proof I give will be good enough, you will just go back to worshipping the historic figure known as Lincoln...

Yeah, don't let my university education get in the way of your "facts".

Ancestral facts coming from my ancestors, one who served as as officer in the confederacy...trumps your rewritten northern "universities"...

:guffaw::guffaw::guffaw:

I love this. I have German relatives so I should find one who fought in WWII and use their interpretation of events as gospel as opposed to historians. If ninjacore had relatives who fought for Germany I guess she'd be a holocaust denier.
 
When fighting against northern education created fanatics no proof I give will be good enough, you will just go back to worshipping the historic figure known as Lincoln...

Many of the historians who are highly critical of the southern cause are southerners, in universities in the deep south.
 
History is always rewritten by the victor...have you never heard this...

Ex-Confederates were free to write what they thought about their cause. Lee was free to run an university. Longstreet worked with Grant.

Ex-confederates could have easily rewritten their own history as well.
 
History is always rewritten by the victor...have you never heard this...

You're right. The Nazis were just misunderstood. They were trying to help the Jews, not hurt them! How dare the Allies give them all that bad press.


Not the same...tho their is the diff btw nazi soldiers and ss soldiers/gestapo, there were plenty of germans just fighting to pretect their people as well, don't paint a brush stroke to wide...
 
Meh...you are blind to the war crimes of your ancestors...

The Irish? Fucking potato killers.

I'm not a fan of the Irish, they signed them up right off the boat to fight in the war, they were nothing but mercenaries...

Yeah, but mine were still in Ireland. Did they fight by telekinesis like Irish X-Men?

You're not a big fan of a lot of people. You seem to be as angry as you are misinformed. You should work on that.

PalpatineSide.png
 
I'm not going to play fetch for you, especially since by name I should be throwing the stick for you...
The burden of proof is on you. If you cannot support your claims with verified evidence then you might as well give up now.


When fighting against northern education created fanatics no proof I give will be good enough, you will just go back to worshipping the historic figure known as Lincoln...
I'm not worshiping Lincoln, but based off that reply I'll assume that you have no evidence to support your claims.

Please remember, you are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own facts.
 
History is always rewritten by the victor...have you never heard this...

Ex-Confederates were free to write what they thought about their cause. Lee was free to run an university. Longstreet worked with Grant.

Ex-confederates could have easily rewritten their own history as well.

Our history is properly documented by those who know the truth...

If that were true then you'd be able to get me a solid link. But it appears you can't.
 
History is always rewritten by the victor...have you never heard this...

And that still doesn't mean that the loser was right or fighting for a good cause.

But is does mean they often lie about their reasons for fighting afterwards to look better in the history books.

You mean like your ancestors in the confed army did?


A historian's job is a critical analysis of all accounts (yes, both sides) and then trying to put the pieces together. Not blindly believing what one side tells you. Maybe you should actually just read some books or articles from scientific journals.
 
The burden of proof is on you. If you cannot support your claims with verified evidence then you might as well give up now.


When fighting against northern education created fanatics no proof I give will be good enough, you will just go back to worshipping the historic figure known as Lincoln...
I'm not worshiping Lincoln, but based off that reply I'll assume that you have no evidence to support your claims.

Please remember, you are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own facts.

So you support the slash and burn policies of Grant and Lincoln...
 
History is always rewritten by the victor...have you never heard this...

Ex-Confederates were free to write what they thought about their cause. Lee was free to run an university. Longstreet worked with Grant.

Ex-confederates could have easily rewritten their own history as well.

Our history is properly documented by those who know the truth...
Idiots with internet connections?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top