• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

AMC's The Walking Dead Season 1 Discussion & Spoilers

Shut up. Don't make me go up to Illinois with my rowdiest friends, have you make us a bunch of drinks and leave you a $5 tip. :p
 
The only thing I really didn't like was Dixon the Cliched Racist. Like, were we supposed to feel bad that he was getting left behind? Because I sure as hell didn't. I probably would have shot him in the head to put him our of his misery, but I wouldn't have been upset that I couldn't save him.

I would have shot him too but we have to realize these characters are at the beginning of their journey. They are still stuck to the old rules of society.

I only made it as far as the "Officer Friendly" scene so far, but there's a couple of things I don't understand. First, why was he in such a hurry to get out of the tank? Couldn't he just wait a while for the Zombies to wander off, and then find a better escape route? A lot of the roads were completely clear when he arrived.

See the sweat that was coming off him? It wasn't from running. Any tank can get very hot just sitting there in the sun. Stay there too long without water or AC (and thats if the tank has one which I doubt) and he dies.

Second, what's the advantage of camping out in the open rather than finding a secure place to hunker down? The campers don't seem to be going anywhere; they seem to have created a very vulnerable encampment.

Rookies. They haven't learned yet what they are truly facing. Give it time.

For anyone who has read the comic, do they explain how the Walking Dead came to be?

No. But they will eventually figure out how you become one.
Everyone on the planet, including them, is infected with the Zombie "virus" and will turn into a Zombie upon death. A Zombie bite doesn't make you a Zombie. It simply kills you. Then you turn into a Zombie. If you have a heart attack you become a Zombie. If you die in your sleep of natural causes? Zombie. If Glenn had crashed that car and died? Zombie Glenn.

The characters don't know that yet but they will figure it out. This is why the Zombies were able to take over so fast. Dead people just started getting up and attacking.

As for what caused the Zombie virus they have not yet explained it in the comics and I don't know if they ever will.

And, with the racist and the key....I really wished the guy hadn't dropped it. Easy out. I really wish the guy had said, suck it, and chucked the key. I want to see people start acting like this is a world without rules. I want to see people struggling with humanity. Basically, I felt like it was an easy out, having the key fall into a whole.

Time. Give it time. They have not yet separated themselves from the old society rules.

This was pretty well done. The Zombie disguise sequence was very suspenseful, with the ominous rumblings of thunder, followed by the rain (although it did end pretty quickly and conveniently). The Zombies seem to have an eerie intelligence sometimes. And some of them can really move if they want to; I hope they don't overdo that.

Perhaps the intelligence of the Zombie is based on the intelligence of the human. If you were a very smart person you're liable to be a smart Zombie. Smart in terms of doing certain things.

I also think that even though you're a Zombie your brain still holds memories and that can help you in your Zombie goal of hunting down people to eat. You know there are two people in this house and if you turn this knob you can get in the house and eat them. However you don't remember that the people you want to eat are your husband and kid.

I'm waiting to see if they do anything with that one particular Zombie that got off the bus when Rick rode by. The Zombie with the black hair and black suit. When Rick jumped up to close the hatch on the top of the tank that Zombie stood out from the crowd in the way it looked at him. There was somthing there besides thoughts of food. At least IMHO.....


I loved the scene where they took time to recognize the identity of the guy they had to chop up.

The last scene with Glenn on the highway was hilarious. Although I find it hard to believe that the inbound lanes would be empty like that; lots of people would have tried to get out that way, too.

Actually I believe it. People are bound by rules. Even criminals. Most people wouldn't even think of crossing over to the other side.

It's also possible that plenty did and that is why the road is empty as well. I sure as would have gone on that road.

Also, I think the sex (between the wife and the best friend) was just a one-time even that was revealed later in the storyline.

It's been a long time since I read the opening story arcs, so I could be wrong.

You're not wrong. They are deviating on this point.

I thought it was a bit odd that they could hop the fence but couldn't figure out the ladder.

I think they did figure out the ladder but they were crowded and the ladder was too high up for a Zombie too pull it's weight up. (The ladder didn't go all the way down to the ground)

The fence was easier to handle. It does go to the ground and it's easier to climb.
 
Yeah that bugge dme too. If you're going to have a moment, do it somewhere where its not going to get the zombies even more worked up. Or if you're going to stand around, do something productive like move some of those racks or display cases in front of the doors.

Or cover the windows with table clothes or sheets so the Zombies can't see inside. Eventually they might leave.
 
And, with the racist and the key....I really wished the guy hadn't dropped it. Easy out. I really wish the guy had said, suck it, and chucked the key. I want to see people start acting like this is a world without rules. I want to see people struggling with humanity. Basically, I felt like it was an easy out, having the key fall into a whole.
This character wasn't that type of guy, but with the comics as a roadmap, the show definitely will go there.

Some differences from the comics:
I don't remember the zombies being able to climb fences. It also seemed to be implied that they didn't move very fast (in comparison to the half-run of some of the zombies in this episode).
Also, I think the sex (between the wife and the best friend) was just a one-time even that was revealed later in the storyline.
It's been a long time since I read the opening story arcs, so I could be wrong.
All correct. As I recall, in the comics, Lori and Shane had sex one night when both were particularly depressed, rather than the apparent ongoing situation implied by the scene in this episode. Zombies definitely couldn't climb fences
otherwise the gated community and the prison both would have been abandoned quickly, and the zombies definitely slowed down as winter set in.

I thought it was a bit odd that they could hop the fence but couldn't figure out the ladder.
It did look like one of them had gotten its hands onto the rungs, but might not have been able to pull up due to the weight of the other zombies around it.

Good news, Zomfans! TWD got renewed for a 2nd season! :D
It did? When? ;)
 
I'm waiting to see if they do anything with that one particular Zombie that got off the bus when Rick rode by. The Zombie with the black hair and black suit. When Rick jumped up to close the hatch on the top of the tank that Zombie stood out from the crowd in the way it looked at him. There was somthing there besides thoughts of food. At least IMHO.....

He just wanted his close-up. That was Charlie Aldred, the penciller of all but the first 6 issues of the series.
 
Zombies definitely couldn't climb fences
otherwise the gated community and the prison both would have been abandoned quickly, and the zombies definitely slowed down as winter set in.

I might be misremembering, but I didn't think the zombie actually got over the fence but sort of made a half-baked attempt to get over the gate, failed, and then the walkers knocked the fence down.

They certainly didn't successfully climb the ladder early in the episode either so I don't get the feeling that the zombies will be able to overcome a fence that isn't easily pulled down by the weight of the crowd.

As for the "affair" between the wife and friend........I really hope that is dealt with and over in an episode as I could sincerely less about a love triangle in the context of an apocalyptic zombie story. I didn't care for them in Lost and I certainly don't think this series will benefit from their use beyond just being an easy crutch for writers to lean on for easy story-telling.
 
Zombies definitely couldn't climb fences
otherwise the gated community and the prison both would have been abandoned quickly, and the zombies definitely slowed down as winter set in.
I might be misremembering, but I didn't think the zombie actually got over the fence but sort of made a half-baked attempt to get over the gate, failed, and then the walkers knocked the fence down.
I had looked away from the tv screen for a few moments and when I refocused on it, the fence was down, but I suspect you're remembering correctly.

As for the "affair" between the wife and friend........I really hope that is dealt with and over in an episode as I could sincerely less about a love triangle in the context of an apocalyptic zombie story. I didn't care for them in Lost and I certainly don't think this series will benefit from their use beyond just being an easy crutch for writers to lean on for easy story-telling.
If the tv series keeps to the comics roadmap, the affair itself (and most of Rick's reactions to it) should be over pretty quickly, though there will be some lingering effects for quite some time.


For those of us who've read the comics, where do you think this season will end, if it ends in similar comics-inspired events?
I'm thinking it'll end with the zombies attacking the camp and the survivors setting out in Dale's RV. I can't recall, though, was that before or after Rick knew about Herschel's farm?
 
And, with the racist and the key....I really wished the guy hadn't dropped it. Easy out. I really wish the guy had said, suck it, and chucked the key. I want to see people start acting like this is a world without rules. I want to see people struggling with humanity. Basically, I felt like it was an easy out, having the key fall into a whole.
This character wasn't that type of guy, but with the comics as a roadmap, the show definitely will go there.


Yeah. I know. But, what I'm really getting at: we're AHEAD of the show. I KNOW they're going there. So I would rather they get there more quickly and THEN start surprising me. Because right now, that's where I am. I'm waiting to be surprised, or shocked by their behavior.

I know people are going to start making awful choices. It's like waiting for the twist that you know is coming. I hate being ahead of shows.
 
I'm waiting to see if they do anything with that one particular Zombie that got off the bus when Rick rode by. The Zombie with the black hair and black suit. When Rick jumped up to close the hatch on the top of the tank that Zombie stood out from the crowd in the way it looked at him. There was somthing there besides thoughts of food. At least IMHO.....

He just wanted his close-up. That was Charlie Aldred, the penciller of all but the first 6 issues of the series.

You mean the one that sort of looks like a Zombie Jim Carrey?
 
I'm waiting to see if they do anything with that one particular Zombie that got off the bus when Rick rode by. The Zombie with the black hair and black suit. When Rick jumped up to close the hatch on the top of the tank that Zombie stood out from the crowd in the way it looked at him. There was somthing there besides thoughts of food. At least IMHO.....

He just wanted his close-up. That was Charlie Aldred, the penciller of all but the first 6 issues of the series.

Oh......I thought it was something important. :lol:
 
Zombies definitely couldn't climb fences
otherwise the gated community and the prison both would have been abandoned quickly, and the zombies definitely slowed down as winter set in.

I might be misremembering, but I didn't think the zombie actually got over the fence but sort of made a half-baked attempt to get over the gate, failed, and then the walkers knocked the fence down.

They certainly didn't successfully climb the ladder early in the episode either so I don't get the feeling that the zombies will be able to overcome a fence that isn't easily pulled down by the weight of the crowd.

Oh they definitely climbed the gate before the weight of all the other Zombies knocked it down.

They showed at least three get up to the top and then Rick shot them down, then while they showed Glenn getting the keys to the truck (amazing lucky IMHO to find and then get the right truck) they show Rick shooting several more times. Then as they get in the truck one final Zombie jumps the gate and trys to get Glenn just as he gets in the truck. At this point the gate falls.

Maybe if a Zombie see you do it the Zombie can do it. Or attempt to do it.

Zombie see, Zombie do?

Makes some sense.

As for the "affair" between the wife and friend........I really hope that is dealt with and over in an episode as I could sincerely less about a love triangle in the context of an apocalyptic zombie story. I didn't care for them in Lost and I certainly don't think this series will benefit from their use beyond just being an easy crutch for writers to lean on for easy story-telling.

You ain't going to have to worry about that. :lol:
 
I'm waiting to see if they do anything with that one particular Zombie that got off the bus when Rick rode by. The Zombie with the black hair and black suit. When Rick jumped up to close the hatch on the top of the tank that Zombie stood out from the crowd in the way it looked at him. There was somthing there besides thoughts of food. At least IMHO.....

He just wanted his close-up. That was Charlie Aldred, the penciller of all but the first 6 issues of the series.

Thanks for the explaination. I always worry when a single zombie gets an extended close up. It's probably from watching too much Romero, but it always seems thats the one zombie who seems to find the secret way in to the survivors and winds up popping up later in the film to threaten a main character (see the Hari Krishna zombie in DotD).
 
One of the characters said that it was just a cloud burst, that they get them all the time, and it would pass pretty quick.
Yeah, they did justify it, but it still came off as a convenient plot device. They should have let it keep raining for a while.

I also noticed that one of the zombies was using a rock (or maybe a piece of broken pavement) to try to break through the glass doors of the department store. That use of a simple tool has me wondering just how intelligent these zombies are. Who knows what else they could figure out?
Yeah, I saw the tool-using Zombies as well. And some of them knew how to climb the fence. And some of the looks Rick and Glenn got in the street were really creepy, like the Zombies were really mulling them over.

See the sweat that was coming off him? It wasn't from running. Any tank can get very hot just sitting there in the sun. Stay there too long without water or AC (and thats if the tank has one which I doubt) and he dies.
Okay, that makes perfect sense.
 
For those of us who've read the comics, where do you think this season will end, if it ends in similar comics-inspired events?
I'm thinking it'll end with the zombies attacking the camp and the survivors setting out in Dale's RV. I can't recall, though, was that before or after Rick knew about Herschel's farm?

They left the field, met Tyree, found the gated community, then Hershel's farm. Their pace is a bit slower than I thought it would be. I thought the best place to end season one would have been after they move into the gated community. The camera pans outside and we see the snow fall off the sign revealing the message Do Not Enter All Dead Inside. Then to be continued...
 
Yeah, I saw the tool-using Zombies as well. And some of them knew how to climb the fence. And some of the looks Rick and Glenn got in the street were really creepy, like the Zombies were really mulling them over.

Yeah the Zombies were thinking: "They look weird even for one of us but they smell like us.....their faces though look too fresh......"

:lol:
 
Another great episode, filled with ingenuity and gore. :bolian:

The redneck guy was maybe too cliched for me, but overall they're doing great so far. Grant is now my favorite character.
 
This show is definitely interesting, if for no other reason than it is very different for TV :rommie:. In terms of effective scenes, what stand out are:

(1) The tank scene at the end of Episode 1. Crawling under the tank seemed hopeless, then the sudden transition to the pristine interior of the tank, the close-in zombie shot, the resulting noise dislocation, then the shot of ant-like zombies around the tank from above. Visually, that was just a very well-done sequence. Very sensory.

(2) The father and son in Episode One, culminating in his inability to shoot the zombie of his wife. It was somewhat cliched but effective.

(3) Yeah, the guts-smearing thing. You just don't expect to see that on TV.

I'm curious whether they can keep this going given the one-dimensional nature of zombies, but it's surprisingly effective so far.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top