• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

2011-12 pilot buzz thread

Renewed Happy Endings :eek: ffs ABC you realise no one is watching it. Unhappy to learn Poe has been dropped the concept sounded cool.
 
I wanted to see Identity for Wentworth Miller but the premise sounded like a snooze.

Agh! ABC just picked up the cringeworthy drag comedy, Work It! :rommie:

Funny how all the networks are skewing female this year while female-skewing ABC is picking up some male-skewing comedies...

And why is the CW being so quiet? Or is nobody paying attention to them?
 
NBC has cancelled Outsourced.

CBS and the CW are scheduled last in the upfronts next week - on Wednesday and Thursday respectively - so that's why they haven't been making calls on cancellations, renewals, and pick-ups yet.
 
Since I can guess what CBS and CW are going to do, I can start assessing how many shows I'll be checking out next fall. Practically everything will be new, and it's definitely more than I've been interested in, in previous years, and way more than I can watch so hopefully about half of these will suck and/or get cancelled early: :rommie:

NBC
Awake
Smash
Playboy Club
Grimm

Chuck - at least the series finale

ABC
Once Upon a Time
The River
Pan Am
Apt 23

maybe I'll check out Revenge if I have time

FOX
Alcatraz
they passed on Exit Strategy, right?
hey - did we ever hear about Touch???
Terra Nova, assuming it ever happens

CBS
Person of Interest
How to Be a Gentleman


CW
The Secret Circle

And that's not even counting cable.

AMC
Breaking Bad
The Walking Dead
Hell on Wheels

Showtime
Dexter

TNT
Falling Skies
(summer)

Cartoon Network

Star Wars: The Clone Wars

FX
Sons of Anarchy
Archer
American Horror Story


Jayzus. I better quit my job. :rommie:
 
I just read an interesting interview with Dan Harmon, creator of Community. I agree with what he has to say here:

If there was one thing you could change about how network shows are made, what would it be?

I would air all of the pilots. You know? Or put them on the web or something. At the risk of offending the people who are most in charge of whether I ever work again, it seems a little antiquated that in a world where everyone can watch anything all the time, we spend all this money making all of these shitty pilots and throwing them all at the wall and seeing which stick. It seems weird that we don't just make it part of the fun of network television, to have festivals or special website events, or even on-air marathons or something, where the audience [gets to see them]. They like to vote for their favorite singers, wouldn't they like to vote for their favorite show?
 
Ah, some CBS news earlier than I expected: they've picked up Person of Interest and Two Broke Girls.

In cable news, HBO has renewed Treme for a third season. That's very surprising given how low its ratings have sunk. HBO really does put creative commitment over ratings at times (and I know ratings don't matter as much to them since they're a subscriber service, but very low ratings would seem to indicate a lack of interest in the show from their subscribers).
 
should play Robert Franklin Stround aka Birdman on Fox's Alcatraz.

Ooh, good idea!

Re, airing the pilots online, here's my idea: assemble internet focus groups of a few dozen or hundred people each and show the pilots to them. (Or, just allow everyone to view the pilots after signing onto various teams of random people: Red Team, Yellow Team, Blue Team, etc.)

The first year, don't factor in the groups' opinions into show decisions; just take note of which group said what. Then when the shows air, note which groups correctly predicted successes and failures.

The next year, go back to only those groups and ask for their opinions on shows. Maybe don't even factor in their opinions that year either but check them again to make sure the first year wasn't a fluke. The third year, you can start trusting the opinions of whatever group got things right two times in a row.

That eliminates the problem of listening to anyone on the internet: that they are not representative of anything but themselves. Make them prove that they actually can predict success.

In lieu of the team idea, people could just be followed individually and the most accurate ones will be given the privilege of shaping future network picks.

Of course the networks will never do this because it would expose that a bunch of random idiots on the internet can do a better job of picking shows than the network bosses can.
 
Like Alcatraz, I'll sample Persons of Interest but J.J. Abrams' stuff can be hit--LOST but mostly miss--Fringe, Undercovers, Star Trek XI. And Ben Brafman (The 4400), Margot Lulick (Kings) and Greg Plageman (Chase) and Dave Semel (No Ordinary Family) are working on it and I didn't care for any of those shows.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top