It's actually on MTV, which is probably worse.
It's different in that, while there's a sense of heightened reality to it, it's one of the more realistic and graphic teen dramas out there, and it's an actual proper drama, not dumbed down cos that's what the kids want... although I wouldn't expect that from MTV (or The CW for that matter).
Each episode mostly focuses on a different member of the group, and so far the second series has been the best, the most serious stories, the strongest writing.
I preferred the first two seasons of Skins with the original cast to the new group mainly because the whole Effy/Cook/Freddie triangle is really annoying and Cook is probably the most irritating and stupid character the show has created yet. How hard is it to write the character? Just have him mumble something and try to sound badass and then shout IM COOK!
The only saving grace of the 3rd series going into 4th is the whole Emily/Naomi relationship and how it develops. I also like that they have an autistic character who isn't treated like a complete outcast by everyone else.
Yeah, series 3 was pretty hit and miss with the new characters. They all seemed very try-hard at first. I like Pandora, Naomi, Emily and JJ though. Did seem like they split the group too much, and the stories suffered for it.
I guess the first 2 series you were coming in to a group of established friends, whereas series 3 it was the group coming together. I think it showed that they'd gone with a young group of writers though, I read that most of the writers were under 20.