
Saw it on a cold day. Loved the flyaround and then the movie went south. Spock was a cold **** and well, the damned thing was more 2001 and less Trek.
Still don't like it.
That was you, Jeff? I couldn't hear half the dialog.I was 7. I went with my sister and a friend of hers. I remember nothing. I'm told I talked incessantly throughout the entire movie much to the audience's irritation. I have no idea why we weren't accompanied by an adult. It was a different era.

Your opinion, and your loss. IMHO, the film is one of the best in the STAR TREK canon. It's not a shoot-'em-up running and jumping movie like today's Trek's are. Instead, it's a thinking-person's movie, well more in line with the original TV series. I'll watch it anytime and in any iteration - the theatrical version, the TV version, or the director's cut.
*Note, I had to delete a quoted word due to the carefully delineated rules of the Forum. I wouldn't want to get in trouble, even though the word in question wasn't mine.
Why isn't this in the movies forum?
Sorry to say, it doesn't hold up to continuous viewing. Better to watch it every couple of years. The plot is a bit flimsy. The writing is off as far as characterization goes. Kirk especially comes off badly. He's a bit of a jerk really. The visuals are nice, but never really serve the plot ( such as it is) A lot of ooh and ahhh, but no substance.Well, we're all entitled to our opinion and I don't expect everyone to agree with mine.
It was boring and Spock was not the Spock I loved. There was too much drifting through space and it became tedious. A little tighter editing and a Spock more like the Spock of the TV series would have saved it. Plus - it was too much like an expanded version of The Changeling.

We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.