• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Search results for query: * (refine your search)

  1. S

    Starfleet Academy General Discussion Thread

    My assumption (and I've pretty sure I've seen before) is that the Relva induction were for some sort of accelerated program, possibly a fast-track Command School one that graduates you as a Lieutenant who can be immediately assigned as a Bridge Shift Duty Officer on a starship or OIC/pilot of a...
  2. S

    Keeping Tasha

    Was Data actually confirmed as being Second Officer in S1? I mean logically he probably should have been, but I sometimes thought that Yar was actually depicted as next-in-line after Riker.
  3. S

    Keeping Tasha

    Agreed. It never really made much sense that they were combined anyway. Tactical/Armory are engineers/technicians (unless you also separate out those roles), whereas Security are operators/specialists. Not in S1, but certainly by mid to late series as LaForge was. Voyager got it right with...
  4. S

    Strange New Worlds' showrunners advise fans to write to Skydance and Paramount if they're interested in a "Year One" Kirk sequel series

    Which I always find hilarious, given that entire books where written by several different authors exclusively about the contradictions and other goofs of TOS, TNG and DS9.
  5. S

    Scotch for Scotty from a modern bar

    The Bladnoch Lowland Malt has been associated with the IRL Scott family in the past, so that's a possibility, as is the Glasgow Lowland Malt. Based on his varied birthplaces/youth haunts, we could also add: Glen Garioch, GlenDronach, Fettercairn, Royal Lochnagar (Aberdeen); Glen Moray*, Glen...
  6. S

    Why Didn't Harry Get Promoted?

    Well, we have: Regulation 191 (Article 14): In a combat situation involving more than one ship, command fell to the vessel with tactical superiority, should there not be a higher ranking officer present. Given that Picard also has decades of experience as a commanding officer and has been...
  7. S

    Why Didn't Harry Get Promoted?

    True, though no more than one or at most two levels would be pretty unusual outside of explicitly temporary appointments in an emergency. Given that he was reporting to a three-pip Admiral and the only other example of someone who could be in that role who we see canonically is a Commodore...
  8. S

    Why Didn't Harry Get Promoted?

    There's a certain amount of ambiguity about the issue, but originally the organisation (or at least the management authority of it) was the Surgeon-General's Office, and a couple of the more specific references to "Starfleet Medical" in "BermanTrek" suggested that at least some of the time it...
  9. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    Well, a version of the four-shift system may have endured, though it should be noted that only Alpha and Gamma shifts not Delta were actually mentioned and Jellico's Delta Shift ran from 15:00 to 23:00, giving an even more ridiculous start time of 23:00 for Alpha Shift (whereas Gamma Shift could...
  10. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    And Jellico was the one who flouted the chain-of-command by dangerously and arrogantly assuming that he knew how to get the best out of a ship and crew that he had zero practical experience with and no interest in learning. Being given the opportunity to present their case and have it heard...
  11. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    You do realise the next thing that happens after "being relieved from duty" for a senior officer like Riker who is in the bad books of a flag officer (Necheyev) unless it's reversed* is being dismissed from the service right or forced into retirement, right? That's very public and final. OTOH...
  12. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    Which is why while Jellico was arguably right to ignore Riker's "demand" and I'd even go for a formal reprimand for his insubordinate way of presenting his opinion, relieving him of duty was inappropriate and over-the-top, particularly given that Jellico should have been violating enough...
  13. S

    Why Didn't Harry Get Promoted?

    My assumption has always been that Chakotay had the option to fully reinstated (for the same reason as Paris), but chose to accept a Provisional Commission instead out of solidarity with "his crew".
  14. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    Only after several days of Jellico disrespecting and dismissing him at every turn, while he was dangerously overworking the Engineering Department, and possibly other sections as well. The first time Riker was actually defiant/insubordinate was when he insisted that Starfleet acknowledge that...
  15. S

    Spoilers WATSON: New Sherlock Holmes-based series on CBS

    Which is why the Jeremy Brett series is my favourite "classic" Holmes. Though ironically despite the Cumberbatch/Freeman version doing a good job of this aspect, it's probably my least favourite of the three "main" adaptions from that era (IMO, the Downey/Law version gets points for leaning...
  16. S

    What's your personal headcanon for your favourite TV series, movies etc?

    Fifty years prior would been 2351, which we know nothing about. That said, even as a tribute to ENT, then reusing Federation Day would have been better as that would also call back to TNG and the 240th Anniversary of a famous event is as good or better than the 250th Anniversary of a more...
  17. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    There are some shift systems that change the time of day that personnel stand each day (though neither of the systems in play appear to) but pretty much every shift system that has teams at all (which starship crews would need to) keeps all but the most senior officers on the same team for...
  18. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    Even with legitimate concerns, "time and place" still applies... he's messing around with the crew in potentially very dangerous ways at a time when they most need to present a strong, united front. Again, there are right and wrong ways of addressing that and right and wrong times to do so...
  19. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    My take isn't so much that he "made the crew work hard" as he didn't work with the crew so that they worked as smartly and efficiently as possible which is always the best place to start IMO.
  20. S

    Retroactive justification for Riker's friction towards Jellico?

    He appears to have been right about the Cardassians (and the politics of the mission in general) but he was wrong about the Enterprise and its crew.
Back
Top