• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is rock ‘n’ roll dead? The data suggests it might be

Shaka Zulu

Commodore
Commodore
We’ve long heard about rock ‘n’ roll’s restorative power: Conventional wisdom says that the genre soothes souls. It saves lives. Its most defiant platitudes say that it never dies.

Well, maybe not never. Since 1993, Australian radio station Triple J has been compiling the top 100 songs of each year, and the Guardian made an amazing interactive infographic of it all, breaking down the dominant genres of the year. Here’s how rock ‘n’ roll has been faring.

http://www.aux.tv/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Rock-Graph1.png

http://www.aux.tv/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Screen-Shot-2014-01-30-at-11.22.16-AM.png

And this is the music that's taking over the top spot as far as popularity and sales are concerned:

http://www.aux.tv/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Screen-Shot-2014-01-30-at-11.28.52-AM.png

Is rock ‘n’ roll dead? The data suggests it might be

Personally, I think rock might thrive a lot more in (in North America at least) if radio stations weren't owned by one conglomerate (especially this one) and radio stations were able to play what they wanted instead of having to depend on consultants, but that's just me.:shifty:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This premise that the Hot 100 is still any indication of what people are listening to is utterly ridiculous.

"Mainstream" music hasn't actually been mainstream for over a decade.
 
This premise that the Hot 100 is still any indication of what people are listening to is utterly ridiculous.

"Mainstream" music hasn't actually been mainstream for over a decade.

This. The amount of singles you actually need to sell to get platinum for example is steadily declining in most countries. The Top 100 aren't really as important as they used to be.

I find plenty of great rock music around easily. There's no shortage. The live scene is alive and well, too.
 
I don't know much about the new acts they mentioned, but as far as I am concerned The Prodigy, Fatboy Slim and the Chemical Brothers are all rock artists :lol:

They all exist alongside my rock listening habits, and they do so because they have the same ethic as rock. The Prodigy are kick ass live, go see them and then tell me you did not just go see a rock band.

Anyway, this all sounds very faddish. Rock concert tours and attendance seem to be at an all time high, with rock artists just recording to give them an excuse to tour these days.
 
Am I reading this right? This whole thing is based on an Australian's radio station's annual list of listeners' favorite records of the year?
 
I don't know much about the new acts they mentioned, but as far as I am concerned The Prodigy, Fatboy Slim and the Chemical Brothers are all rock artists :lol:

They all exist alongside my rock listening habits, and they do so because they have the same ethic as rock. The Prodigy are kick ass live, go see them and then tell me you did not just go see a rock band.

True that.

Saw a Japanese band called Crossfaith last week. They were themes exciting thing I've seen for ages. They're going to be huge. And they rock...
 
I find plenty of great rock music around easily. There's no shortage. The live scene is alive and well, too.
Yes.

Also, thanks to technology, "indie" rock has become so accessible and easy to find that it really isn't independent anymore.

This is very true. Indie Rock these days seems to fall into the same category as Alternative Rock.

That said, everybody I know listens to music. Almost none of them listen to the radio.
 
AC/DC is still around so rock isn't dead. ;)

As for the rest, in Europe we've got a lot of metal, gothic metal, symphonic metal and you name it metal around, not much played on mainstream radio but the fans are plenty and loyal. :cool:
 
I don't know much about the new acts they mentioned, but as far as I am concerned The Prodigy, Fatboy Slim and the Chemical Brothers are all rock artists :lol:

They all exist alongside my rock listening habits, and they do so because they have the same ethic as rock. The Prodigy are kick ass live, go see them and then tell me you did not just go see a rock band.

They exist along mine too (*reminds self to order the AMP I and AMP II compilations from Amazon next week.) But as I said, stations like this should look around their local scenes and play the rock groups that might be there.

Am I reading this right? This whole thing is based on an Australian's radio station's annual list of listeners' favorite records of the year?

Yep.
 
Last edited:
Alternative rock has been rock for much of my life. It's going strong. What some alt rock artists have done is incorporate electronica into their music. Music changes and rock has been a nebulous term for quite some time. I don't expect it to play in clubs, but it should be fine.
 
Alternative rock has been rock for much of my life. It's going strong. What some alt rock artists have done is incorporate electronica into their music. Music changes and rock has been a nebulous term for quite some time. I don't expect it to play in clubs, but it should be fine.

This is very true. I'm not even sure what "rock" means these days.

According to this article, it would seem to mean anything with a guitar...
 
This premise that the Hot 100 is still any indication of what people are listening to is utterly ridiculous.

"Mainstream" music hasn't actually been mainstream for over a decade.

What sells the most and/or gets the most airplay (in various formats) is, by definition, the "mainstream."

Does that mean that rock is, literally, dead?

No. It still has an audience.

However, that audience is aging and shrinking.

Every generation has "it's" own pop (i.e., mainstream) music. Eventually, that generation stops buying records. At that point, whatever genre was pop recedes and becomes more of a niche sound.

The baby boom was such a large generation (encompassing, in some respects more than one generation), however, that it artificially extended the life of rock as the dominant format.

But now, the youngest baby boomers are in their fifties. They don't buy music-in any format-as much as they used to.

Meanwhile the generation that traditionally buys a lot of music--the teenagers and young adults--have different tastes: dance, hip hop, that horrible stuff that people call "country" these days. They're the dominant form of pop music now.

Sure some rock records get sold, just like some blues and folk music get sold. And occasionally, just like those genres, a particular rock record will sometimes break through. However, those occasional breakthroughs don't mean rock is back on tap any more than, for example, the "O Brother Where Art Thou" soundtrack sales somehow meant that folk was now the longterm chart king.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top