• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Was the reveal of the Enterprise-A a big surprise?

No, it is very relevant. If a person can't be bothered to express themselves clearly, then that person has a problem, not others.

OTOH if someone can't grasp the concept that somebody can just be expressing an opinion even when they don't explicitly state "In my opinion..." (or lacks to reading comprehension ability to understand when this is being done) then that is their problem.

In my opinion, of course.
The thing about opinions is that they don't have to be remotely true. Some can even be total nonsense, but if it works for that person, then it's their thing.
 
My pet theory was always that the Enterprise-A was built from 'spare parts' left over from the Constituion refit cycle, similar to the space shuttle Endeavour. It's based on nothing but supposition, of course. A pulled-from-mothballs Constitution about to be retired works too. I think we all know the Yorktown tale from Gene comes from the Enterprise originally being called Yorktown in his initial treatments.
 
The real star of Star Trek, at least TOS, at least to a 60's kid, was always the "classic Enterprise." (Constitution class)

Just like the real star of the American space program wasn't any of the individual astronauts, it was always the hardware...the Saturn V rocket + Apollo module + LM.

There's almost an Art Deco quality to classic Enterprise. I would analogize it to the Chrysler building. There are lots of other skyscrapers that are bigger, more modern, more bells and whistles, but there's only one Chrysler building.

What do we see in the opening credits of TOS?

Enterprise slowly transiting Vulcan--the "beauty" shot--Enterprise flashing back and forth to the theme music--the show is all about the Enterprise.

Who was the space chick that Kirk always carried his biggest torch for? Enterprise.
 
My pet theory was always that the Enterprise-A was built from 'spare parts' left over from the Constituion refit cycle, similar to the space shuttle Endeavour. It's based on nothing but supposition, of course. A pulled-from-mothballs Constitution about to be retired works too. I think we all know the Yorktown tale from Gene comes from the Enterprise originally being called Yorktown in his initial treatments.

I like this theory. Works well with the Enterprise-A being a glitchy mess in STV.
 
I remember several gasps in the audience at that moment and a few cheers that it wasn't 'that other ship' as a friend put it.
 
My pet theory was always that the Enterprise-A was built from 'spare parts' left over from the Constituion refit cycle, similar to the space shuttle Endeavour. It's based on nothing but supposition, of course. A pulled-from-mothballs Constitution about to be retired works too. I think we all know the Yorktown tale from Gene comes from the Enterprise originally being called Yorktown in his initial treatments.

I like this theory. Works well with the Enterprise-A being a glitchy mess in STV.

Thank you. I thought it was a happy compromise. I would assume they built it, did whatever tests they meant (having never intended it for full service) and then it sat quietly in some drydock for a while collecting dust.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top