• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Could the Doctor survive an Alien chestburster?

All-Seeing I

Commander
Red Shirt
After the arrival of Prometheus on Blu-ray this week, a recent rewatch of the David Tennant episodes (notably the specials) and more than a bit of idle speculation, I got to wondering... In some alternate universe once shared by Engineers and Time Lords, a derelict spacecraft on a world dubbed LV-426 is still sending out a distress signal - or is it a warning? The 10th Doctor, travelling alone, bored and insatiably curious - how could he possibly resist investigating when the TARDIS alerts him to the signal?

Landing on LV-426, the Doctor dons his Sanctuary Base 6 orange and yellow spacesuit and exits the TARDIS onto the hostile surface, using a hand tracker to locate the derelict beached and broken on a rocky reef; he finds a crack in the skin of the craft and clambers inside.

Within, he finds the Engineer in his cockpit, the chest of its pressure suit exploded from within; wary but still curious, the Doctor notices the hole burned through the floor and cautiously climbs down - but he loses his footing and slips down into the cavernous hangar below.

In the belly of this beast are thousands of egg-shaped objects, protected by the blue haze of a stasis field, which reacts when the Doctor tumbles underneath it; he finds himself staring directly at one of the egg-shaped objects, which has turned translucent, something fluttering wetly within. The Doctor scrambles back, belatedly realizing that curiosity has its limits, but it's too late - the top of the leathery egg creaks open, centuries of dust cascading from the four fleshy petals, and something slurps and slithers within. A moment of tense stillness, and then an obscene creature from his worst nightmares explodes forth, streamers of slime trailing from scuttling spider legs and thrashing snake-like tail - it clamps onto the Doctor's helmet, a tube-like protuberance melting through his faceplate with some kind of acid. The Doctor gasps as hostile alien atmosphere breaches his environmental integrity - and the creature's ovipositor tube strikes out and slithers down his throat; it squeezes the rest of its body through the hole in the melted faceplate, clutching the Doctor's head in its vice-like grip and snaking its tail tightly around his throat.

Clutching his helmet, the Doctor staggers and collapses, lying there amongst the slimy tendrils interconnecting the eggs, mercifully slipping into a coma as the creature attached to him lays its seed within him...

I'm presuming that when the deed is done and he recovers, the Doctor could withstand LV-426's hostile atmosphere long enough to return to his TARDIS, but what then? It seems that victims suffer amnesia after the attack, so he might not think to run a check on himself, which means that chestbursting is inevitable. But would he survive the trauma long enough to regenerate? We know that the Alien exchanges genetic material with its host - what Time Lord powers would the newborn acquire? And if it's tainted the Doctor's DNA with its own, then how would it affect him if he was lucky enough to regenerate? I don't think we'd get Matt Smith...
 
The Doctor's more perceptive than your average human - plus two hearts equals less room in the chest cavity. Depending on how far along he is when he wakes up, he'll sense something's wrong with him - even if he's not sure what. One quick sonic screwdriver scan later and he'll be rushing back to the TARDIS as fast as he can go.

Using the first Alien as the example, Ten probably doesn't have much time at all once he wakes up. At which point "Sexy" will either refuse to let him in (at which point he's screwed - the atmosphere/chest trauma will be simply too much), OR she will rush him in and immediately dematerialize before he can do anything, clanging the Cloister Bell as she does. (I'm leaning towards the latter - she'll want to save her "thief" any way she can.)

If chestbursting is inevitable, that means regeneration is inevitable. In the cases of One/Two, Three/Four and Seven/Eight, the Doctor was flat-out DEAD before he regenerated. As soon as the bug emerges, Sexy will throw open her doors and eject the little bastard out into the Vortex (if she simply doesn't just vaporize it on the spot, she can always regenerate her flooring). Then she'll pump as much artron energy as she has to into Ten's blown-out corpse (as she did with One) to help him through his most difficult regeneration ever. Matt Smith would still emerge, wondering why he has long black fingernails, immense strength and sharper senses than he's used to...

And IF the Chestburster somehow evaded getting vaporized/ejected and fled into the labyrinth of the TARDIS...then we've really got a problem.
 
Nightowl1701, you're mentioning of the Seven/Eight regeneration got me to thinking... That instrument Grace was using during his heart surgery (and which caused Seven's "death") - Eight literally expelled it from his body, pulled it out of his own chest. Perhaps Doctor Ten in our hypothetical scenario could do the same with other foreign matter such as an embryonic chestburster? Or would they be too interlinked, maybe?
 
Here's something else to consider that is if the aliens take on the traits of their hosts then would it be capable of regenerating?
 
Last edited:
Hmm. Now this would be an interesting idea for Matt Smith's doctor when he does leave and regenerates.

A parasite growing in him.

Similar to how the 3rd doctor went out.
 
I suspect undergoing a chestburster would be fatal, but he'd more likely have to regenerate before the burst in order to get rid of it and survive.
 
I think the combination of the Aliens' own mutagenic nature and the sheer randomness of the regeneration process would produce some bizarre results - a drone could metamorphose into a queen, or the DNA extrapolated from the original host could exert a greater influence, resulting in a creature maybe something like the Newborn from Alien Resurrection.

Also Time Lords had a genetic factor called the Rassilon Imprimatur, which stabilised their molecular structure to prevent them from dissipating into the vortex when time travelling; the Aliens are the ultimate in adaptation - perhaps if they absorbed the Imprimatur, limited time travel or time jumps might become an organic function? Part of their fight or flight reflex, jumping back or forward a few seconds, attacking a victim from several fronts, or riding the time winds to escape attack itself.

It's a likely prospect that the gestating Alien would simpy be expelled in a cloud of atoms in the sheer explosive energy of regeneration, before it's had the chance to burst through the Doctor's chest. But we've seen how human DNA can influence the regenerative process, Donna inadvertently creating the hybrid 10th Doctor in Journey's End; would all that Alien RNA/DNA infiltrating his system be flushed out after regeneration? Even the Doctor's admitted that he's sometimes lucky to end up with the two arms/two legs/one head combo - Doctor#11 could have ended up like Ripley#8, at best, or like one of her predecessors floating in their tanks...

At least we know for certain that Captain Jack would resurrect even after a chestbursting, and that we'd end up with an indestructable, immortal Alien. Good God, what a thought!

The 11th Doc's future regeneration... Death by alien parasite certainly would be something new - we've had 1) old age 2) execution 3) ego/radiation poisoning 4) falling from a great height 5) poisoning 6) head injury 7) shooting/surgical mishap 8) ? 9) absorbing time vortex energy 10) shot by Dalek energy bolt and 10) ego/radiation poisoning, again. Always thought that a botched transmat/teleport would be a good one, having to stabilise his scrambled molecules by regenerating...
 
There are certain kinds of trauma that are a 'final death' and which would defeat regeneration, aren't there? This would probably be one of those. A chestburster would probably destroy both of a Time Lord's hearts and kill him or her immediately.
 
There are certain kinds of trauma that are a 'final death' and which would defeat regeneration, aren't there? This would probably be one of those. A chestburster would probably destroy both of a Time Lord's hearts and kill him or her immediately.
Yea, I'm pretty sure we learn in Gallifrey Audioplays that stabbing both hearts will prevent Regeneration (Consider that as Canon as you will)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top