OK, I'm breaking this up into two posts because I'm loosing track of all the damn quotes: -
I am clearly the superior problem solver here as I intended to shoot the bloody thing and I went and shot the bloody thing!
...not that it makes a blind bit of difference of course.
Just playing devil's advocate (rather literally) but in star child's defence, after tens of millions of years (if not more) his plan had a 100% success rate for synthetics not wiping out *all organic life*. Not much of a recommendation I know, but I think you can see how a machine intelligence would see this as a valid approach based on the statistical evidence.
Rather begs the question though, if all the cycles follow a larger pattern which always involves synthetics like the geth or that other machine race the Protheans were fighting when the reapers showed up, what happens to the synthetics? Do they get harvested too? or just destroyed?
Also, if the purpose of the reapers is to preserve the continued existence of organic life then why can't the reapers just wait around in dark space until a machine race pops up *then* return, wipe them out, tell the organics to quit making AIs and bugger off back into dark space and wait a few eons for the organics to forget the lesson and start the whole thing over. I mean at least this way there's a *chance* lessons can be learnt, but by resetting galactic civilization to zero every fifty millennia nothing is learnt and organics are trapped in a never ending cycle.
I think what really disappointed me about the "revelation" of the reaper's true purpose was that it was so mundane. I mean they'd been built of as these vast, timeless, unknowable Cthulhu like demi-gods...and they turn out to me massive indoctrinated attack dogs for some ancient AI that went to the HAL 9000 school of ethics?
I thought they'd turn out to be something *huge*, like they were from another universe, either something totally alien (EDI's little 1+1=3 talk got my hopes up for this theory) or perhaps an earlier incarnation of *this* universe and they created this form to survive the big crunch and subsequent big bang that created our universe. The idea behind harvesting advanced life was to preserve worthy races to survive the next universal collapse and rebirth.
...that or they're guard dogs against some *even worse* external threat and by destroying them you end up exposing the milky-way to a threat that has scourged most of the rest of the universe.
Same problem, I wanted to destroy them and ended up accidentally controlling them because the seemingly paragon action was a renegade one and vice versa. Only realised it later by watching Youtube clips, then went back and fixed my mistake. Same damn ending, only a different colour.I picked the control Reapers (blue though I thought I was killing em the game needs to label it better).
I am clearly the superior problem solver here as I intended to shoot the bloody thing and I went and shot the bloody thing!

...not that it makes a blind bit of difference of course.

And at the end of the day, the Catalyst was the being whose original solution to the organic/synthetic problem was to build the Reapers. This thing clearly has a few screws loose and there's no reason to believe that its solutions are the only ones available.
Just playing devil's advocate (rather literally) but in star child's defence, after tens of millions of years (if not more) his plan had a 100% success rate for synthetics not wiping out *all organic life*. Not much of a recommendation I know, but I think you can see how a machine intelligence would see this as a valid approach based on the statistical evidence.
Rather begs the question though, if all the cycles follow a larger pattern which always involves synthetics like the geth or that other machine race the Protheans were fighting when the reapers showed up, what happens to the synthetics? Do they get harvested too? or just destroyed?
Also, if the purpose of the reapers is to preserve the continued existence of organic life then why can't the reapers just wait around in dark space until a machine race pops up *then* return, wipe them out, tell the organics to quit making AIs and bugger off back into dark space and wait a few eons for the organics to forget the lesson and start the whole thing over. I mean at least this way there's a *chance* lessons can be learnt, but by resetting galactic civilization to zero every fifty millennia nothing is learnt and organics are trapped in a never ending cycle.
I think what really disappointed me about the "revelation" of the reaper's true purpose was that it was so mundane. I mean they'd been built of as these vast, timeless, unknowable Cthulhu like demi-gods...and they turn out to me massive indoctrinated attack dogs for some ancient AI that went to the HAL 9000 school of ethics?
I thought they'd turn out to be something *huge*, like they were from another universe, either something totally alien (EDI's little 1+1=3 talk got my hopes up for this theory) or perhaps an earlier incarnation of *this* universe and they created this form to survive the big crunch and subsequent big bang that created our universe. The idea behind harvesting advanced life was to preserve worthy races to survive the next universal collapse and rebirth.
...that or they're guard dogs against some *even worse* external threat and by destroying them you end up exposing the milky-way to a threat that has scourged most of the rest of the universe.