• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Video Game Heroes All-Star Battle

Who would win in an all out battle?


  • Total voters
    20

HotRod

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
So I think it's time we have a pointless poll and debate over which gaming all-star's would win in an all out fight on some distant battleground.

I've gone to the trouble of selecting a few characters I could think of off the top of my head but do feel free to add more.

My selections all kind of fit into the futuristic soldier category as I figured it was the only way it could work in that they all are armored to some degree and would actually present a challenge in combat. As much as I love someone like Lara Croft or Nathan Drake, i don't think they would present much of a challenge to someone like Master Chief. One shot and they are pretty much dead.

Rules are pretty simple. Each combatant is armed with what would consider their standard weapon and one additional weapon. No heavy weapons allowed. So Shepard can't just whip out the M-920 Cain and call it a day. So Master Chief would be armed with his Assault Rifle and pistol. Shepard would have an Avenger Assault Rifle and his Heavy Pistol. Clarke would have his Plasma Cutter and Pulse Rifle, Freeman would have the Gravity Gun and anything but a crowbar. You get the idea.

The battleground would be very large with a good mix of terrain and buildings for cover.

Ok, so who do you beileve would walk out alive?

Commander Shepard
CommanderShepard3.jpg

CommanderShepard2.jpg

CommanderShepard1.jpg


Master Chief
MasterChief3.jpg

MasterChief2.jpg

MasterChief1.jpg


Marcus Fenix
MarcusFenix3.jpg

MarcusFenix2.jpg

MarcusFenix1.jpg


Samus Aran
SamusAran3.jpg

SamusAran2.jpg

SamusAran1.jpg


Issac Clarke
IssacClarke3.jpg

IssacClarke2.jpg

IssacClarke1.jpg


Gordon Freeman
GordonFreeman3.jpg

GordonFreeman2.jpg

GordonFreeman1.jpg


Alcatrez
Alcatrez3.jpg

Alcatrez2.jpg

Alcatrez1.jpg
 
War of the space marines, huh? Well, my vote's going to Samus. Assuming she has all her upgrades/weapons she's pretty much unstoppable.
 
Ghost, Roach and Soap when they call in their AC-130 and their Predator UAVs...

GAME OVER, MAN! GAME OVER!

other wise, the Quake 2 Marine. Railgun and Hyperblaster. Kthnxbai.
 
War of the space marines, huh? Well, my vote's going to Samus. Assuming she has all her upgrades/weapons she's pretty much unstoppable.

Thats just the thing though, she can only have 2 fairly standard weapons.
 
Ghost, Roach and Soap when they call in their AC-130 and their Predator UAVs...

GAME OVER, MAN! GAME OVER!

other wise, the Quake 2 Marine. Railgun and Hyperblaster. Kthnxbai.

I would have a hard time believing any standard, run of the mill soldiers armed with current tech level firearms would be able to take down Master Chief, Shepard, or anyone else equiped with futuristic armour AND shields. Plus calling in an airstrike is not an option. Otherwise i would think the COD guys would be a little out of their league. Lets see, AC-130 gunship......or calling down the Normandy or a UNSC Frigate. Game over is right.

Now the Quake marine is a fine option.
 
Master Chief :) C'mon, where all my Halo fanboys at? I like Commander Shepard, but he/she hasn't been biologically overhauled the way Master Chief has. I'll give Marcus 3rd since I don't know who the other characters are.
 
Master Chief :) C'mon, where all my Halo fanboys at? I like Commander Shepard, but he/she hasn't been biologically overhauled the way Master Chief has. I'll give Marcus 3rd since I don't know who the other characters are.

Wait... you don't know who Gordon Freeman is? :(
 
Master Chief :) C'mon, where all my Halo fanboys at? I like Commander Shepard, but he/she hasn't been biologically overhauled the way Master Chief has. I'll give Marcus 3rd since I don't know who the other characters are.

God knows I love The Chief, I'm just not sure he could do much to Shepard. The UNSC weapons in Halo aren't much to brag about. For the most part they seem to be pretty standard chemically propelled projectiles. Shepard uses shields and armour designed to stop rounds the size of a grain of sand, propelled using mass accelerators, that hit with ALOT more kinetic energy. The Chief bullets might just bounce off. Now if we were to give the Chief Covie weapons, he might have a chance. Otherwise he would have to go in for a much closer kill.
 
I gotta go with Master Chief. Cybernetic upgrades. Battle suit.

I've never heard of Alcatraz? Judging by the photo I guess it's that new Crysis 2 game?
 
Hmmmm. It appears I have committed a Mortal Gaming Sin. I'll admit that for most of my life my game preferences were few and limited.
 
Hmmmm. It appears I have committed a Mortal Gaming Sin. I'll admit that for most of my life my game preferences were few and limited.

Gordon Freeman is from Half-Life and Samus Aran is from Metroid. Two of the most popular gaming franchises around today. Samus also gets special attention for being a rare female example of a badass space marine.
 
The Master Chief wouldn't fight Commander Shepard because it's insubordination to assault an officer. :p

Plus Shepard's biotics would put the Master Chief down before he could get close enough to do anything, anyway.
 
To keep things somewhat fair I think we should leave biotics out of this battle. Have Shepard be the standard Soldier class.
 
Surely Samus would win all day long. She's had all sorts of weapons and can jump like a crazy.

Plus, her standard weapons are a badass beam weapon and missiles. It's hard to beat that.

SmithW, I strongly recommend you go play Half-Life and Half-Life 2. They're absolute classics, both of them, still hold up well, and were very important to the development of the FPS genre.
 
Regarding Master Chief vs. Shepard:

1. Shepard can't duel wield.

2. Shepard can't perform "halo jumping/bunny hopping".

Master Chief wins.
 
Q2 Marine can use the BFG 10K. Q2 Marine FTW.

MC and the others with shields are still gonna die cuz they "can't repel firepower of that magnitude!"
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top