All Occupants of the island are Perfect logicians.
No Humans are Perfect logicians.
Therefore, no Occupants are Human.
This syllogism commits no fallacies, and the truth table checks out.
There are no people on the island. There are only polar bears and a smoke monster.
No Humans are Perfect logicians.
Therefore, no Occupants are Human.
This syllogism commits no fallacies, and the truth table checks out.
There are no people on the island. There are only polar bears and a smoke monster.