• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sucker Punch (Film 2011) Grading/Discussion

Grade The Film!


  • Total voters
    45
  • Poll closed .
I loved this movie it was great . who was the actor that played the mentor . he looked like david carridaine if that is the right spelling of the last name . Now she goes into a mental instution right ? and then it ends up turning into a play and I am not sure where there at this point. some of it is confusing to be sure . But over all
I loved it and I agree with admiral young see it before you bad mouth it .

The brothel reality was used by Babydoll as an escape from her reality of being in the Asylum. Was she better off in the brothel reality? Not really, she was still a prisoner, but it helped her deal with her situation better.

Why would any girl want to imagine herself in a brothel of all places? That's like a guy imagining himself getting whacked in the balls because it's better than having them removed.
 
^^^I'm the opposite actually. While I enjoyed the score well enough, I loved all the cover songs used in the film. Especially when you realize that each song used was selected for it's thematic material and used in the film accordingly.

Emily Browning's cover of Sweet Dreams is simply sublime.

That was originally in response to the Admiral's post...Archer just happened to post as I hit submit ;)

And now to respond to him:

I loved this movie it was great . who was the actor that played the mentor . he looked like david carridaine if that is the right spelling of the last name . Now she goes into a mental instution right ? and then it ends up turning into a play and I am not sure where there at this point. some of it is confusing to be sure . But over all
I loved it and I agree with admiral young see it before you bad mouth it .

The brothel reality was used by Babydoll as an escape from her reality of being in the Asylum. Was she better off in the brothel reality? Not really, she was still a prisoner, but it helped her deal with her situation better.

Why would any girl want to imagine herself in a brothel of all places? That's like a guy imagining himself getting whacked in the balls because it's better than having them removed.

Her main goal is to escape the asylum, therefore her illusion has to also be something that she wishes to escape from.
 
^ Exactly. The brothel was a construct designed to represent the asylum it's self, not an escape from the asylum. That's just what her conscienceness depicted the Aslyum as. I loved Emily's cover of "Sweet Dreams" too and the use of it at the start of the movie. I believe that it set the tone for the rest of the film perfectly.
 
I may have had some problems with the but I did enjoy it . I had problems with inception saw three times did'nt fully understand all of it . but I liked it and I like sucker punch as well. liked the rock sound track on sucker punch . I thought best part was were they went after the map.
 
Really? You guys liked that? I have nothing to say about her version of the song - I'm pretty indifferent to it - but the use of that song tied to those scenes was so amateur that it hurt. Most of the music in this felt that way to me, but this one really stood out as a rookie movie mistake that Snyder probably shouldn't be making at this point.
 
^ All the movie's songs had a specific reason for being included according to Snyder. I don't really like most of the choices used in the soundtrack myself to be honest. Bjork did a cover of Army of One that only really works in the movie. Hearing her on the soundtrack at all is meh.
 
Yeah, I just didn't like that there are some good songs on there that were done as terrible to meh covers and they were just used really poorly and hamfistedly in the movie.
 
Really? You guys liked that? I have nothing to say about her version of the song - I'm pretty indifferent to it - but the use of that song tied to those scenes was so amateur that it hurt. Most of the music in this felt that way to me, but this one really stood out as a rookie movie mistake that Snyder probably shouldn't be making at this point.

Different strokes for different folks I guess. I absolutely adored the first five minutes of the movie. It completely sold me before the title was even displayed :p
 
Speaking of music, that version of Where Is My Mind is just... awful. That song was used to haunting perfection in the Fight Club apocalypse, and to see is mishandled like this in another movie is just terrible.
 
I added the songs used the trailers to the soundtrack...and Emily Browning covers Where is My Mind. Interesting to see that more people here think the movie is good compared to those who don't.
 
Well, the good outweigh the bad by only 3 votes with one average vote in between. And it is a genre movie and this is a genre message board. It's not that weird, though I am surprised (by this and other movies) that there aren't more critical people here.
 
I think there are extremely critical people here...and that doesn't reflect someone liking the film or not liking the film.
 
Don't take it as insulting - it's not how it was intended - it just seems like everyone on here likes everything and usually there's no better reason given for why other than "it's exactly what I expected".
 
^ Yeah sorry I seem to be overly sensitive about this film and I don't know why really. I wasn't insulted really. I know what you mean, about not furthering their views.
 
Don't take it as insulting - it's not how it was intended - it just seems like everyone on here likes everything and usually there's no better reason given for why other than "it's exactly what I expected".

I gotta say I must not follow the grain then. The movie really wasn't what I expected at all, and that might be why I like it so much. Going in I thought it was going to be a movie about a girl trapped in an asylum who retreated into her mind in order to escape. Now while I suppose that is a simplistic explanation of what the movie was, I never expected two different realities in addition to the main one.

And as for the music, a lot of people have thought the covers were bad. I didn't, I can't really explain that except to say that everything is subjective. I like them, you don't, no big deal.
 
I found the Eurythmics cover in the intro distracting, as they had someone narrate over the lyrics. I thought that was a really weird choice.
 
And as for the music, a lot of people have thought the covers were bad. I didn't, I can't really explain that except to say that everything is subjective. I like them, you don't, no big deal.

I don't know that I thought any one of the covers stood out as "bad", but I did think there were a few times where they should have de-musicvideoized some scenes in favor of a bit of interesting dialog or some more action or something else. I thought they worked well over the first 2-3 minutes (Sweet Dreams) and then over each of the dream world fighting scenes though......especially Bjork's Army of Me. If I had any complaint, it was just that it was too much of a good thing(s).

The stylized fighting was cool.......most of the music was cool.....the special FX were cool.......the layers of reality was cool.....it was all fine, but it was almost like they had everything dialed to 11 all the time except for a few scenes
when some of the girls died.
. I think if he could have balanced out the movie with a bit more diversity in his approach to telling the story this could have easily gone from a critically panned movie to a critically praised one.
 
*SPOILER ALERT*

I have to admit, the scene in your spoiler code there, label, was one of the scenes that was evidence of weak plotting to me. It seems like those two girls were dispatched merely because they couldn't figure out what to do with them for the end of the movie. So we have a cackling villain moment that robbed the film of some of its integrity.
 
Just curious - I haven't seen the film... But are the other girls figments of Babydoll's imagination? Or is it some bizarro shared imagination/dream state where what happens to the other girls also happens in the asylum and is experienced by them?
 
The other prossies' involvement in the action scenes is sometimes representative of what Baby Doll imagines them to be doing in the brothel construct while she strips.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top