oldBSG was very attractive visually, but the content was dumb junk, the "Chocolate Frosted Sugar Bombs" of 70s sf. Moore and his people turned that effects-laden crap into something that reasonably intelligent adults could stand to watch without sacrificing their higher cerebral functions. Moore wins.
For someone who re-wrote his own original sci-fi story(Tin Woodman, 1979)just to fit it into TNG format, I'm not all that surprised to hear you make a statement as inept and empty as that. And from what I have seen and read about Polaris' storyline, it looks and sounds like a recycled episode from that godawful Star Trek-Voyager.
But that is neither here nor there.
Ron Moore quoted in an interview that he was not a fan of old Battlestar Galactica.
And since Moore was not a fan, it makes one wonder why he even bothered with the property to begin with.
I wouldn't go so far as to say Battlestar Galactica was effects-laden crap. Yes, it was a product of the science fiction renaissance set forth by the success of Star Wars. And yes, it was riding on the success of George Lucas' Oscar-winning space opera.
Nevertheless, it was still successful in the ratings and earned a huge fan following. The only reason it lasted one season was because it was too expensive to produce.
Think about it. One Million Dollars per hour on the making of those episodes in 1978 was a huge chunk of change at that time.
Content that was dumb junk? Not really. "Chocolate Frosted Sugar Bombs" of 70s sf? Hardly. It certainly gave the old 'Ancient-Astronaut' theory set forth by Erich Von Daniken(?)a new dimension, if not a brilliant edge.
And it was a show that also dealt with humanity's ongoing
journey in life. It also dealt with themes of family. Let alone values and ethics that have unfortunately been discarded by mankind's ignorance and foolishness in the past several decades, resulting in the scary, violent, f****d up world that we are currently living in now.
Moore and his people turning what you call effects-laden crap into something that reasonably intelligent adults could stand to watch without sacrificing their higher cerebral functions? Maybe in your opinion, but to old schoolers who grew up with the original, let alone old fashioned values, Not likely.
Regretfully, it was turned into something that actress Kyra Schoen(the 1968 version of Night Of The Living Dead)once said about remakes in general.
"A cheap way to make a buck."
Ron Moore loses in that field. He may have done a decent job when writing Star Trek - First Contact, but when he remade a classic, he did a piss-poor job.
Obviously, he was influenced by another sci-fi atrocity.
That one being Galactica 1980.