• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Would you rather live in the SW universe or the ST universe?

Temis you're forgetting the Peacekeepers.
They're the ones I was talking about when I said "Evil Galactic Empire." ;) They used to be Starfleetish but they ain't anymore. And the reason is, the cosmos is a nasty place so you need to be even nastier. That implies that there's no alternative to a Starfleet that morphs into an Evil Galactic Empire - very sobering thought.

Farscape
is how Star Trek goes "in the real world." If you're going to let me have the kinder, gentler fantasy version, I'll take it.
 
Star Wars. The Trek universe always seemed a bit sterile, and a future ran by a military government* with no material wealth to work for doesn't appeal to me.

*Now the Empire isn't much better, but I think I'd feel safer living under Republic rule than the Federation.
 
Star Wars. The Trek universe always seemed a bit sterile, and a future ran by a military government* with no material wealth to work for doesn't appeal to me.

*Now the Empire isn't much better, but I think I'd feel safer living under Republic rule than the Federation.

You trust the corrupt, doddering Republic more than the Federation? Why? At least the Feddies can whomp up a military of volunteers eager to defend it. The Republic has to grow them in a cloning factory. That tells you all you need to know about which system is healthy and which is utterly degenerate and probably deserves destruction. Even if the Empire ain't much of an improvement, at least it motivates people to fight against it of their own free will.
 
How's the Federation a military government? I notice the asterisk next to the comment. Starfleet is a defense and exploratory branch of the Federation. It doesn't enforce anything or dictate policy.
 
Star Wars. The Trek universe always seemed a bit sterile, and a future ran by a military government* with no material wealth to work for doesn't appeal to me.

The Federation is not a military government. It's governed by a civilian council and president. Starfleet is merely the military organization that works for that government; we've seen instances where Starfleet personnel were subordinate to the authority of civilian officials such as High Commissioner Ferris in "The Galileo Seven." The one and only time that a Starfleet admiral did try to institute martial law, in "Homefront"/"Paradise Lost" on DS9, the coup attempt was promptly thwarted (by other Starfleet personnel) and civilian rule restored.

The only reason the Federation seems dominated by Starfleet is because all the Trek shows are set on Starfleet vessels or installations, giving a view of the Federation that's heavily filtered through a Starfleet perspective. If your only knowledge of the United States came from The Rat Patrol, Hogan's Heroes, M*A*S*H, and JAG, you might think the US was a military state.
 
Material wealth isn't the be all and end all of existence. That's a thing of current mentality. Something we as humans strive for today. There would be no desire or need to obtain material wealth in the Star Trek universe but that doesn't mean that there isn't anything worth while to achieve just because you're not making money.
 
The technology of Trek is so much cooler too. You got phasers, tricorders, transporters, universal translators, androids, holodecks, time travel...

With SW, it's basically just blasters and lightsabers. And droids that roll around beeping cute noises you can't understand. lol
 
The technology of Trek is so much cooler too. You got phasers,

Lightsabers do more damage.

tricorders,

Artoo carries all the sensors I need.

transporters,

Star Wars ships can land.

universal translators,

Everybody speaks Galactic Standard.

androids,

What do you think "'droid" is short for? Alouisciousdroid?

holodecks,

Overrated when you own your own ship and can go anywhere you like.

time travel...

Overrated and unnecessary.


With SW, it's basically just blasters and lightsabers.

Which work quite well.

And droids that roll around beeping cute noises you can't understand. lol

Unless the ones that actually talk interpret for you. Not a huge setback...
 
The original poster stated you're an average citizen in either universe so an average person would not own a lightsaber or have access to any of the "high" technology in the Star Wars universe while an average citizen in the Trek universe pretty much would have carte blanche over everything except maybe weapons.
 
Lightsabers do more damage.

Including to your own anatomy if you're pointing them in the wrong direction. Too dangerous.

Plus, phasers have stun settings. Not only is that ethically preferable, but do you really want to be inundated in lawsuits from a bunch of people whose arms you've cut off? Or look at the flip side: since you wouldn't be the only person armed, would you rather endure brief unconsciousness or amputation?


Artoo carries all the sensors I need.

But he can't be folded up and carried on one's belt.


Star Wars ships can land.

Takeoff and landing are by far the most hazardous actions peformed by any spacecraft, aside from combat. They're also time-consuming, and you probably have to pay hangar fees. Beaming is faster, safer, and pedestrian-friendly.


Everybody speaks Galactic Standard.

Except for Wookies, Hutts, astromech droids, Rodians, that guy whose arm Ben cut off, etc., etc. And yet they all seem to understand each other. Either they have some kind of translator implants, in which case the only difference is one of presentation, or they all have to learn one another's languages the hard way even if they don't speak them, in which case there's a lot more studying involved than in Trek.


What do you think "'droid" is short for? Alouisciousdroid?

Except that most "droids" are not actually androids (a word that means "human-shaped"). C-3PO broadly qualifies, but most don't.


holodecks,
Overrated when you own your own ship and can go anywhere you like.

But there's money in the SW universe, so presumably it costs a lot more to buy, maintain, and fuel a ship, as well as paying any necessary license, berthing, and customes fees, than it does to say, "Computer, run program."

Besides, at least Trek holograms have full color and opacity and don't constantly have scan lines sweeping through them. The technology to cross the galaxy in days and they can't make a hologram that looks better than a 1950s TV transmission?
 
Trek is obviously where I would want to be as an average kind of person. As others mentioned, SW is a little scary for the average jane.
However, to your second question, I think I might prefer being a Jedi to a starship captain. I can't really explain that choice with logic, being a Jedi just always sounded cool.
 
Hmm, let's see...

Governments: Benevolent Federation versus Corrupt Republic or Evil Empire

Peacekeeping institutions: Some kind of paramilitary explorer thing which anyone can join versus some weird order of sexless fighting monks with superpowers who take & raise children from birth

Technology: Holodecks and replicators versus, um, blue hologram telephones.

Yeah, it's not really a contest. Gotta go with Trek.

And, yeah, I'd rather be a starship captain than a Jedi Master. Being a Jedi Master might look cool but if you really think about it, as a life it'd be kind of awful.
 
As an average working middle class human??

Subsequently, would you rather be a captain of a Federation star ship (any star ship of your choosing) or would you rather be a Jedi Master?

I could never decide, but I'm leaning towards being a Federation captain because of the holodeck and the replicators. I imagine I could probably build myself a light saber in the ST universe.

Trek on both. Average life seems more pleasant in Trek. A captain don't have to give up as much as a Jedi Master.
 
Okay, let's cut the crap. Let's get down to brass tacks. There is one thing that Star Trek has that puts it head and shoulders above Star Wars:

Safety railings.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top