• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchises

23skidoo

Admiral
Admiral
For anyone who doesn't know, Doctor Who Unbound was a series of Big Finish audios based upon "What if..." scenarios and alternate, non-canon Doctors. For example, Geoffrey Bayldon played a Doctor who never left Gallifrey in the Type 40. Arabella Weir played a female regeneration. David Warner played a version of the Doctor in a couple of them. And Michael Jayston reprised the Valeyard in a story set after the defeat of the Doctor in The Trial of a Time Lord...

The other day I read something interesting. Paul Cornell, creator of the Scream of the Shalka webcast, which featured Richard E. Grant's version of the Ninth Doctor, is quoted somewhere as saying it is his version of "Unbound". And, of course, he's right. There's really little difference between the Grant Doctor and some of these alternates.

And I got to thinking that the whole Unbound concept can be extended further to include "Doctor Who", the character who travelled with John and Gillian in the 1960s comic strips, as well as "Dr. Who", the Peter Cushing movie version (what if the Doctor was human?). Trevor Martin's stage version from Seven Keys to Doomsday can be included here. So can the Nicholas Briggs version of the Doctor from the unofficial Audio Visuals series (which later evolved into Big Finish).

But there's more. In the 1990s Colin Baker played "The Stranger", an arms-length version of the Doctor who appeared in several independent films (along with Nicola Bryant as "Miss Brown") before I think the BBC rattled a chain and "The Stranger" became "Soloman" and a new backstory was created for him. But especially in the first 3 films of the series (Summoned By Shadows, More Than a Messiah, In Memory Alone) he's very much an "Unbound" Doctor.

Similarly, Sylvester McCoy and Sophie Aldred appeared in a series of stories called "The Professor and Ace" which became "The Dominie and Dorothy" after another likely chain rattle.

And then there's the Airzone Solution, a non-Doctor Who film featuring Pertwee, Davison, Colin Baker, McCoy, and Nicola Bryant that could become an "Unbound" scenario too - what if the Sixth Doctor married Peri and became a TV weatherman in England? ;)

OK, that last one maybe not. But the whole Unbound concept is one way to pull some pretty divergent versions of the Doctor together.

But I bet we can move beyond the Who franchise to include other shows who have Doctor-like characters. Could they be, perhaps, Unbound Doctors?

Ducky Mallard from NCIS?
Dr. Helen Magnus from Sanctuary?
Dr. Walter Bishop from Fringe?
Gil Grissom?
Rupert Giles from Buffy? (that's one way to get Tony Head as the Doctor!)
Detective Columbo?

Have fun with this one - what Doctor-like characters in other TV shows (SF or otherwise) do you think could be "Doctor Who Unbound" material? (Darrin from Bewitched regenerated, but he doesn't count! ;) )

Alex
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

James Bond,

well he does keep regenerating...
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

Mike Collins, the comic book artist, wrote a short story for the Doctor Who charity fanthology Walking in Eternity where the fourth Doctor from "The Dark Dimension" meets several other alternate regenerations, including Jessica B. Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote (who, it turns out, was actually her witch character from Bedknobs & Broomsticks) and Jonathan Creek. It's called "Hall of Me," and it ends with a cute scene with Jean-Luc Picard and Ben Sisko as they try to enter the Captain's Table and discover they've found the wrong metatemporal bar.
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

Bernard Cumberbatch's version of Sherlock Holmes in Moffat's Sherlock feels awfully Doctor-like.
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

Mike Collins, the comic book artist, wrote a short story for the Doctor Who charity fanthology Walking in Eternity where the fourth Doctor from "The Dark Dimension" meets several other alternate regenerations, including Jessica B. Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote (who, it turns out, was actually her witch character from Bedknobs & Broomsticks) and Jonathan Creek. It's called "Hall of Me," and it ends with a cute scene with Jean-Luc Picard and Ben Sisko as they try to enter the Captain's Table and discover they've found the wrong metatemporal bar.
That sounds great. If only Walking In Eternity wasn't so hard to find... :(
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

James Bond,

well he does keep regenerating...

There was a line in one of the Who novels which had a UNIT officer implying that MI5 had their "own" Time Lord.
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

Not a TV show, but I've always reckoned JB Priestly's An Inspector Calls is the best stage version of Doctor Who you could ever hope for...
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

There are some fan edits out there attempting to explain Paul McGann's appearances in programmes such as in Hornblower as the Doctor undercover. The two I've seen both use K9 footage to try and explain the plot.

I've heard there's another Peter Cushing film where he is very Doctor like, though I've not seen it myself.

Sophie Aldred played an unnamed human in two Reeltime videos/DVDs. Mindgame and Mindgame Trilogy. With a Sontaran and Draconian. I'd hope that's a clone of Ace those though

RTD's earlier Dark Season is very Doctor Who like.

I saw a US series of TV movies once one Christmas, made in the early 1990s. Josh Kirby: Time Warrior. Barrie Ingham played a very Doctorish role in that, with a present day human (Josh) and a futuristic Leela type female as companions.
 
Last edited:
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

Bernard Cumberbatch's version of Sherlock Holmes in Moffat's Sherlock feels awfully Doctor-like.

Same writer and an actor who auditioned for the 11th Doctor (apparently so did Martin Freeman), while the 11th Doctor auditioned for his Watson - no surprise really. Plus, I've heard it said that if The Doctor was a detective, he'd be Sherlock Holmes and if Holmes was a sci-fi icon, he'd be The Doctor (sorry Spock and Data).

Then there's the fact that Tom Baker and Peter Cushing have also played Sherlock onscreen or stage.
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

Bernard Cumberbatch's version of Sherlock Holmes in Moffat's Sherlock feels awfully Doctor-like.

Same writer and an actor who auditioned for the 11th Doctor (apparently so did Martin Freeman), while the 11th Doctor auditioned for his Watson - no surprise really. Plus, I've heard it said that if The Doctor was a detective, he'd be Sherlock Holmes and if Holmes was a sci-fi icon, he'd be The Doctor (sorry Spock and Data).
Yup, I knew that, although I believe Matt Smith auditioned for Sherlock not Watson.
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

No, it was Watson. Moffat said Smith was wrong for it because he didn't look right in a supporting-type role.
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

James Bond,

well he does keep regenerating...

There was a line in one of the Who novels which had a UNIT officer implying that MI5 had their "own" Time Lord.

It's in Bullet Time, and it's MI6... (and, FWIW, specifically places MI6's Time Lord in the pre-credit sequence of Tomorrow Never Dies!)
 
Re: Applying Doctor Who Unbound to non-Big Finish Doctors and franchis

I've heard there's another Peter Cushing film where he is very Doctor like, though I've not seen it myself.

That narrows it down to about half his bloody career! Unless you mean specifically like his version of the Doctor in the two Dalek movies, in which case you're probably thinking of At The Earth's Core
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top