• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Are there two species of Gorn?

I doubt a "real" Gorn would look like a guy in a rubber suit or a crude CG, just like real computers 250 years hence won't be about blinking coloured squares or swirly blue screensavers. It's all meant to be impressionistic - the future as seen in the 1960 and today. The same world, seen through different eyes.

As for the novels, I haven't read the one in question, but The Needs of the Many has a fast-moving subspecies of Gorn never seen in TV/film Trek.
 
I've heard the insect eyes explained as goggles, or something.

Beer goggles?

Nah. They're sunglasses. The TOS gorn is hungover after a night of drinking romulan ale with his crew. Explaining why he's so slow :techman:

Hmm, him being inebriated and hitting on Kirk would actually make more sense. You heard it here first people! I sense someone's already typing away on a new slash fiction.
 
for convenience sake while reading Seize The Fire I pictured the gorn as Unas from Stargate SG-1 but with an additional central cranial ridge and without the chin horns, and larger mouths

it's not canon, but anything else based on the original gorn was cartoony, and took too much work to visualize
 
Just to complicate matters, what about the flat-faced Gorn from the last movie? Are we just ignoring him (or her) because it was in a cut scene?

Minor note; Wasn't the TOS Gorn's fingers fused so that it was esentially a two finger one thumb kinda thing?

Also, what about genetic engineering? That could acount for the differences in forms/castes?

I for one have no problem with authors or script writers using variations in costumes/makeup/CGI as inspiration for their stories, as long as they're entertaining and thought provoking, it's all good!
 
It's not cannon, but in Star Trek Online the insect eyes are not eyes. They're special ops goggles.

I have nothing to say about the hands. But separate species sounds good. :)
 
^^
He wasn't blinking, it was errrrrrrrrr

Screen-wipers, like on cars.

He probably had sand on them or something.

*Cough*, yeah that explains it
 
It's a TV show. The different look is simply the result of a higher budget and a different design team. The Gorn in TOS and ENT are the exact same species and, from the perspective of Kirk or Archer, look exactly the same.

Why does a higher budget justify a re-design?
 
^Because they would have done it differently the first time around if they were able to...
 
That was possibly written before the CGI-ed episodes of TOS showed him blink. ;)

It's possible to blink with contacts on - who's to say that these special glasses need to be of a protruding type? :vulcan:

Timo Saloniemi
 
No different than the disappearing/reappearing forehead ridges on Vulcans and Romulans. A stylistic choice and nothing more. No need to complicate things...
 
It's a TV show. The different look is simply the result of a higher budget and a different design team. The Gorn in TOS and ENT are the exact same species and, from the perspective of Kirk or Archer, look exactly the same.

Why does a higher budget justify a re-design?

^Because they would have done it differently the first time around if they were able to...

Exactly. Just look at the Klingons.
 
We can also postulate a much simpler explanation: There are simply different kinds of Gorns, even though the number of fingers and types of eyes seem radically different.

Remember, the Gorn captain Kirk encounters is much slower than the one shown in ENT. Maybe he was a really old Gorn, and the one in ENT was younger and faster.
 
Tin Man is correct about the TOS Gorn having three fingers. I just googled Gorn images and there they were.
One of my uncles has just three fingers on his right hand, hardly makes him a separate species.

And what about Scotty? Was he a different species from the rest of the Humans aboard the Enterprise?

:):):):)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top