• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor blog

Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

Don't know yet — but I like the idea of Re-watching TAS!
I've been planning on re-watching TAS for a while now, and if you guys did them it would give me excuse to get around to doing it.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

I've been watching 1 or 2 episodes of TOS per week for a while now (Actually 1-2 eps per week of each of the 5 shows!). So I was planning on hitting TAS once I finish season 3 of TOS, which at the rate I'm going may be in about 2 months. Then the movies, then the reboot, then TOS again :)
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

How long until we reach two of my favorite Spock eps from s3, The Cloud Minders and All Ours Yesterdays? TCM is one of those crazy uneven episodes that really defined s3 as The Turd Season and yet I find it strangely likable, though I suppose that's the only way one could like TCM. ;) The FX were crazy good in that episode. I loved Stratos. It was cool seeing a rough draft of Cloud City and on a 60s TV budget. I also enjoyed the relationship between Spock and Droxine based as it was on mutual respect for a like intellect rather than spurred on by space spores or Vulcan puberty.

I would go on about why I love AOY but I think enough people enjoy that episode despite it's little logic lapses that I don't have to explain myself. Still would like to read your thoughts on those two eps guys.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

^ We're re-watching the third season in its original broadcast order, so it's going to be a while. We reviewed "Wink of an Eye" last week; this week we re-watch "The Empath," and our recap and analysis of "Elaan of Troyius" will be posted on Dec. 30.

"The Cloud Minders" and "All Our Yesterdays" are from the end of the third season, so my best guess is we'll see TCM on Feb. 24, 2011, and AOY will get its due on March 10.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

Even in production order, "Cloud-Minders" and "Yesterdays" were very near the end -- episodes 74 and 78 out of 79.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

Wasn't Elaan shot first?
"Elaan of Troyius" was the second produced but the thirteenth to air, because of the time needed to create new miniatures (the Klingon battle cruiser) and effects shots. Some of EoT's thunder was stolen, however, because a few of its effects shots were borrowed for "Day of the Dove," which aired ahead of it.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

Some of EoT's thunder was stolen, however, because a few of its effects shots were borrowed for "Day of the Dove," which aired ahead of it.

Not to mention "The Enterprise Incident." The new Klingon battlecruiser miniature was seen as a Romulan ship before it was seen as a Klingon ship.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

It’s Thursday, my friends! That means it’s time for yet another installment of Tor.com’s weekly feature, Star Trek Re-watch, by Dayton Ward and yours truly.

This week’s subject of scrutiny is the third-season episode The Empath,” in which our heroes wake up in a dark, featureless space with a mute young woman who can sense emotions and heal with a touch.


This intriguing episode held up even better than I had remembered. Stylishly directed and photographed, smartly written, and beautifully played by everyone involved, this is a thought-provoking and moving hour of Star Trek.

Of course, that didn’t stop Dayton and me from making a few jokes at its expense, because … well, because we’re jerks, and that’s what Tor is paying us to do.

If you haven’t seen it in a while, watch “The Empath” now for free on the CBS website. A story of love, empathy, and sacrifice, it’s a good Star Trek story to watch right before Christmas (except for the whole torture and bondage aspect, which probably would have been a better fit with Easter).

If you’ve got time to spare while waiting for your egg to nog, take a gander at my and Dayton’s previous Re-watch entries:As always, please leave comments on the Tor.com article, to let us know we’re not just hurling electrons into the ether without purpose.

Until next week, a joyous holiday season to one and all!
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

You guys are on crack. The Empath is the worst episode of TOS, and I'd argue even worse than Threshold.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

^Ahh, I see you're a practitioner of Tellarite civil conversation.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

You guys are on crack. The Empath is the worst episode of TOS, and I'd argue even worse than Threshold.

Compared to, say, "The Way To Eden" or "Friday's Child"?

(We'll give "Spock's Brain" a pass for once, just for sheer camp appeal.)
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

The Empath is good... although I swear it goes on for 8 hours.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

You guys are on crack. The Empath is the worst episode of TOS, and I'd argue even worse than Threshold.

Compared to, say, "The Way To Eden" or "Friday's Child"?

(We'll give "Spock's Brain" a pass for once, just for sheer camp appeal.)

Yes. At least those episodes are fun in the way Irwin Allen shows were fun. The Empath is both bad and boring.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

I've only seen The Empath once, and I thought it was rather strange. It wasn't necessarily bad, just very weird.
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

Welcome to yet another Thursday and, with it, another piping-hot installment of the Tor.com weekly column Star Trek Re-watch by yours truly and Dayton Ward. This week, I’m on recap duty, and Dayton’s in charge of analysis.

This week’s episode of interest is Elaan of Troyius.” Jeez, talked about mixed metaphors: the title references Helen of Troy, the plot is cribbed from Shakespeare’s play The Taming of the Shrew, and the costumes are swiped in equal parts from Antony & Cleopatra and your grandmother’s kitchen.




This is actually kind of a fun episode … but it’s not what one would call one of Star Trek’s more “enlightened” hours of entertainment.

Catch up on our recaps of third-season Star Trek with this handy index:Make sure you remember to leave comments on the articles at Tor.com, so that Dayton and I can convince ourselves that this gig isn’t merely an exercise in futility.

Be sure to watch this space next week, when we bring you Dayton’s play-by-play and my color commentary on Whom Gods Destroy.” (Watch it for free on the CBS website.)

Until then, here’s wishing everyone a very happy, safe, and prosperous New Year!
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

Heavens help us, it’s Thursday again, and that can mean only one thing: another installment of TOR.COM’s infamous Star Trek Re-watch has escaped its cage and gone rampaging around the intertubes. This week’s episode: Whom Gods Destroy.”

So far on our nostalgia tour through Star Trek’s third season, my cohort Dayton Ward and I have revised our opinions of some episodes that frequently are maligned. This, alas, is not one of those episodes.



Re-watch this one if you like, but we’d advise you to remove any sharp objects from your immediate vicinity before doing so, lest you succumb to an overpowering urge to gouge out your eyeballs and pierce your eardrums.

Meanwhile, catch up on our recaps-and-analyses of third-season Star Trek with this handy index:

  1. Spock’s Brain
  2. The Enterprise Incident
  3. The Paradise Syndrome
  4. And the Children Shall Lead
  5. Is There in Truth No Beauty?
  6. Spectre of the Gun
  7. Day of the Dove
  8. For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky
  9. The Tholian Web
  10. Plato’s Stepchildren
  11. Wink of an Eye
  12. The Empath
  13. Elaan of Troyius
Please leave some comments on the Tor.com article—it creates the illusion for our masters at Tor.com that anyone gives a damn about these weekly blatherings of ours.

Then mark your calendar and rejoin us next week when we re-watch Let That Be Your Last Battlefield,” the stale black-and-white cookie of the Star Trek canon!
 
Re: Dayton Ward & David Mack are re-watching TOS season 3 on the Tor b

Damn, I've missed about the last three of these...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top