• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The films of David Fincher

JacksonArcher

Vice Admiral
Admiral
I've been on a David Fincher kick recently after consuming myself with The Social Network, his latest film. I was enamored with that film, and so sort of by accident I've been watching any film by Fincher that caught my eye. I've already seen two of his most notable films- Se7en and Fight Club- numerous times but I wasn't quite familiar with the rest of his filmography.

The next film after The Social Network that just happened to be on TV a while ago was The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. I remember hearing about that film when it first came out, but not paying much attention to it after hearing dismissive comments toward it. I gave it a chance and if anything I thought it was an incredibly visually lush film with great performances and an intriguing storyline. However, I have to agree that it was very plodding and dull and for a movie about life & death was admittedly very... lifeless.

About a week ago, my friend suggested we watch The Game, and so I obliged. I found myself rather liking this film. I remember seeing it years ago when it came out, but I had forgotten most of it. I know there was a lot of negative criticism over the ending- my friend absolutely hated it- but I thought it was a very stylish, well-made, slow burn thriller that was if anything, similar to Benjamin Button, gorgeous to look at.

Tonight I noticed that Panic Room was on TV, and so I decided to watch that as well. I remember watching the film back when it came out, but like The Game it had mostly disappeared from my memory. It's always interesting watching a film you don't quite remember for another time- it's essentially like watching the film for the first time, but with that sense of familiarity when you remember or recognize certain moments or actors or scenes. Panic Room may have been Fincher's most "mainstream" film up until that point (even though I think Benjamin Button takes that crown now), it was a really effectual, cat-and-mouse thriller that was wonderfully simple in its premise, but incredibly suspenseful and taut in its execution. It also cements Fincher as a visual virtuoso, with elaborate, richly textured shots of such simple things like getting a tour of the house or merely a flashlight flickering on and off. My favorite moments of the film are when there's complete silence, using the artful imagery of slow motion (probably one of the only instances where I appreciated speed ramping, verses hating it) to really extenuate tension.

I was never really a fan of David Fincher's work merely because I never honestly gave him the time of day before, but after re-discovering his filmography I've learned to really appreciate his work and his talent more and more. I also can't leave this post without mentioning Fincher's finest film, in my humble opinion: Zodiac. What a labor of love that film was- so incredibly finessed, detailed, sharp and insightful. Alien 3 is the only Fincher film I've yet to see, however I don't think I'll see that one anytime soon.

Anyone else a Fincher fan?
 
Interesting topic. I am in a similar situation to you. I have seen many of his films but never really considered myself a fan. But I loved The Social Network.

I guess I liked Fight Club but I never watched it all the way through again. Same goes for Se7en. Seeing bits and pieces on cable over the years. Actually the previous film of his that made the best impression on me was The Game.

I guess the common element for me was once I knew the outcomes of each there was no real desire to revisit those stories. Maybe it was the dark tone or the characters. While I plan to see The Social Network again to relish the performances and dialogue.
 
Strikes me as yet another director who oeuvre isn't really an oeuvre. Maybe my memory's at fault. It's been years since I've seen some of these movies. But there's no thematic unity, and very few common features in narrative structure, focus on actors, pacing, use of symbols and metaphors. Frankly, I don't even remember that much similarity in visual style, not like you can see in a Ridley flick.

But that's me, still thinking the auteur theory is kinda nuts.
 
My favorite Fincher film is "Fight Club". Just love everything about it. I have thought for a while now that Fincher would be a terrific pick to direct a "Dune" film. I'm surprised that he's not been asked. I think he'd be able to handle the scope of the universe and complexity of the characters brilliantly.
 
Definitely a David Fincher fan. Easily one of the best film makers around, right up there with Ridley Scott and the Coen brothers in my books. Thanks to Zodiac, I can never listen to Hurdy Gurdy Man again without thinking of that opening scene.

Even though it was his first film, Alien 3 really sets the tone for how he would later conduct himself as a director. Don't get me wrong, the film had some big problems, mostly caused by producers and studio execs who thought they could just push around a director who was at the time a total unknown. Despite that though, it has Fincher's style all over it and in some ways it's my favourite of the four Alien films (no, I don't count the AvP films!)

If you look at his filmography, he's one of those rare directors that's never made a dud: -

* Alien 3 - Debatable, I know. But it had style and atmosphere you could cut with a knife.
* Seven - Single handedly redefined the serial killer genre.
* The Game - An often overlooked but solid thriller.
* Fight Club - We do not talk about fight club...
* Panic Room - A great suspense film. Hitchcock would be proud.
* Zodiac - Again with the serial killer(s), but a vastly different approach and one of the most gripping "true story" films there is.

I've only see The Curious Case of Benjamin Button the once so I haven't really formed much of an opinion of it yet, but it was very well made though it was hard to get a grip on as it was a lot more sentimental that Fincher usually gets. I haven't actually seen The Social Network yet and am not in a big rush to either. Not that I don't like the look of it or anything, I just prefer to wait to see a quality film until I'm in the right mood. I'm also like that with Ridley Scott and Tarantino films for some odd reason.
 
Seven: A-
Zodiac: A
The Social Network: A-


Fight Club: haven't seen, will someday


Benjamin Button, Alien 3, Flightplan, The Game: no intention of seeing.
 
Fincher, Nolan, Singer, Reitman, Abrams... why are these young, talentless punks getting jobs that should go to Brett Ratner?!?!?!? :lol:
 
Does anyone remember the rumors that George Lucas was going to hire Fincher to direct Revenge of the Sith? I mourn for the what-might-have-been there every day.

Of the Fincher films I've seen (all but Benjamin Button and The Social Network), the only one that I don't really like is The Game. Well, I do like it, it's the best Philip K. Dick film (albeit not based on anything PKD actually wrote), but it just feels like a lesser film. It doesn't feel worthy of Fincher.
 
Does anyone remember the rumors that George Lucas was going to hire Fincher to direct Revenge of the Sith? I mourn for the what-might-have-been there every day.

That was never a consideration. It was purely made up internet wanking.

Besides...he already worked on one. ;)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top