The ladies prefer....

[GhostFaceSaint]

So who do the ladies prefer the most Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, or Carl Urban?
Post your preferences here, IE, who is your very favorite!
(Yes, I am forcing you to choose!)

 

[startrekrcks]

Chris Pine off course for me because who wouldn't love his cheeky attitude and cute smile.

 

[Traveller]

Eric Bana.

Yes, I know I cheated

OK, ok, after a long stretch of nothing... Quinto. Hated him as Sylar (as I should, he was EVIL), but his Spock is pssst.... hotter than Nimoy's.

 

[Mrs_Whatsit]

KARL URBAN! KARL URBAN! KARL URBAN!!!!!!!!!!!

...Ahem. I mean, Karl Urban.

Chris Pine is adorable, and I don't think of Sylar when I watch Spock, which is a huge accomplishment for Zachary Quinto in my book, but Karl Urban is more my type. And he makes me weak in the knees.

 

[Jeri]

There have already been at least three poll threads, wherein I voted for Chris on all occasions.

 

[trampledamage]

KARL URBAN! KARL URBAN! KARL URBAN!!!!!!!!!!!

...Ahem. I mean, Karl Urban.

Chris Pine is adorable, and I don't think of Sylar when I watch Spock, which is a huge accomplishment for Zachary Quinto in my book, but Karl Urban is more my type. And he makes me weak in the knees.

What she said, except for the stuff about Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto...

 

[DevilEyes]

There have already been at least three poll threads, wherein I voted for Chris on all occasions.

Yep:

1) Poll: nuKirk, nuSpock or nuBones?

2) Poll: Kirk or Spock?

3) Poll: Who is the sexiest star of the film? (includes female characters)

I voted Quinto each time. I also found him incredibly hot as Sylar, and as Spock he is ... but I have to say that Nimoy's Spock was still sexier. In TOS, at least, not so much in the movies. (It's the voice! )

 

[Tribbles]

I'm a Spock loyalist; Quinto all the way. (But like DevilEyes, I melt at the sound of Nimoy's voice. )

 

[Crusher Disciple]

Quinto. Character-wise, I'm a Mc Coy girl all the way.

 

[Tara]

Y'all can have the younguns--I'll take Bruce Greenwood as Pike

 

[Starquest]

Chris Pine gets my vote, but second would be Bruce Greenwood and third would be Karl Urban.

 

[Wynterhawk]

QUINTOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!

Yes, please!

 

[Myasishchev]

Chris Pine is funny looking, too fleshy. He'll be jowly by forty.

Zach Quinto, by contrast, is a tremendously attractive man.

Karl Urban's okay.

 

[NileQT87]

Zach Quinto is totally my type (tall, dark and handsome). You know I'm a Sylar/Spock fangirl, so this is a given.

Karl Urban would be second.

Funny thing: when watching TOS, my favorites remained exactly in the same order (though Pine did wonders for Kirk--I can't get over Shatner's decades of parodying himself). Nimoy and Kelley stood way out among the cast.

However, I slightly prefer Quinto (mostly because the material that he was given was honestly more than anything Nimoy was ever given--with the exception of Spock's death), but I prefer Kelley over Urban (Urban did Kelley good, though!).

Quinto is the only one that makes it super high on my sexy hot-o-meter, though.

 

[Shadowcat_559]

My favorite is Simon Pegg. I admit I have a crush on him.

 

[Tribbles]

I prefer Kelley over Urban, too, Nile. I don't dislike Urban, but he just isn't as... McCoyish to me. Which is odd, since I saw him as McCoy first...

Shadowcat__559, that's great! I don't think Scotty gets enough love. He is so fun and huggable! Just give the man a sandwich and he's happy.

 

[KirkSpockTOSFan]

Well thats hard choice for me as I love both Chris Pine and Zachuary Quntio, and I also think Karl Urban as well. I thought all them did a amanzing job in the movie. I also have to admit all three are really hot! But I have always been a Kirk & Spock fan and these versions of them are even hotter! I love the orginal Kirk & Spock from TOS and thought they were hot in there time.But thats not the only reason I love them, there are other reasons but its hard to explain. So I just love both versions of them weither the are the orginals or the new. So I just can't choose between them, its way to hard. I have to think on this one!

 

[Tom Riley]

Hey, what about us gays?

Chris Pine all the way.

 

[Kirk-Fu]

Chris Pine. He's almost as sexy as Shatner was when he started playing Kirk.

 

[startrekrcks]

I agree Chris Pine is like a younger version of Shatner. Shatner was a ladies man in some TOS episodes wasn't he.