startrekrcks
Fleet Captain
Post here
What moments did you like, what moments did you hate
- Thread starter startrekrcks
- Start date
- Status
Nardpuncher
Rear Admiral
The only thing I hated was that manga-looking nurse on the USS Kelvin.
I loved the end credits' theme. (I'm not listing all the stuff I loved, that'd be too long)
I loved the end credits' theme. (I'm not listing all the stuff I loved, that'd be too long)
All this has happened before, and all of it will happen again...
startrekrcks
Fleet Captain
Well you must can't take change
We generally like to see a little more substance than this to an opening post; I've let a few of yours slide, but I need to point out that this isn't even a particularly fresh thread title.
To date, we've had a Stuff you simply LOVED... thread. There's still an active Moments that really made you cringe or disliked thread. We've also had:
Moments when you knew you were watching Star Trek
Moments where you knew you were seeing Spock and not Zachary Quinto?
Moments where you knew you were seeing Kirk and not Chris Pine.
What moments in the movie reminded you of Shatner
What do you think are your favourite moments
What did you love about this movie
What was your favourite scenes and why
...and any number of other variations on the theme. A lot of these are threads started by you, in fact.
I'm afraid that "What moments did you like, what moments did you hate -- Post here" is too generic; it has no real direction built in and prompts no new discussion. There's just not much of a topic here.
startrekrcks, I'll suggest you give it a little more thought and come up with a specific question or aspect of the movie you want to talk about, put some of your own ideas into the opening post and give some idea of what direction you wish discussion to take. If you do that, you could have a thread which goes somewhere; with a thread like this one here, there's just not a lot of potential.
Closing.
Last edited:
- Status
