• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Scotty's Sidekick

What do you think of Scotty's furry companion?


  • Total voters
    188
  • Poll closed .
Hopefully we'll find out what species this thing is in the next movie. For all we know, Scotty found him on Delta Vega as an abandoned orphan or something and even HE doesn't know where the hell he comes from.
 
Did they go a little too far by introducing Keenser?

For those of you who haven't picked up on it yet, "Keenser" is the name of the little green guy who worked with Scotty on Delta Vega and eventually ended up on the Enterprise.

I've got to say that his addition did stike me (a little after the fact) as being too "cute". (For example, him tending to climb on things and Scotty yelling at him to get down. Keenser's not a kid or an intelligent animal. He's supposed to be a Starfleet officer.)

Did we really need our own version of an Ewok? I don't care what excuse they offer. I mean, he's here now, and let's not get rid of him, but did we really need Keenser? I don't think so.
 
Re: Did they go a little too far by introducing Keenser?

For those of you who haven't picked up on it yet, "Keenser" is the name of the little green guy who worked with Scotty on Delta Vega and eventually ended up on the Enterprise.
Yes, and there's an active thread about him here. Merging almost immediately. Hold onto your Ewoks...
 
He's either a cute semi-intelligent pet/friend who climbs furniture...

OR

He's a qualified StarFleet officer wearing a red shirt uniform...

I think the problem is that you cannot have it both ways.
 
Well, I can't feel much of anything for him yet; if they develop some kind of a story for him, then I'll get back to you.

My husband thinks the character is played by a child; he notes that Chris Pine reaches up to help him down off the transporter frame, whereas an adult of small stature would get down under their own power.
 
Keenser was played by the Charlie and the Chocolate factory dude, who also played an Ewok and Droopy McCool from Star Wars. Righteous.
 
Hopefully we'll find out what species this thing is in the next movie. For all we know, Scotty found him on Delta Vega as an abandoned orphan or something and even HE doesn't know where the hell he comes from.


He's actually Gary Mitchell in disguise.

Wait 'til you see what Liz Dehner looks like... :p
 
Ever notice how everyone in the theater seems to react in a like manner to how the poster feels about something? Like everyone laughs at the jokes they liked, and no one reacted at the scene they didn't care about and so on.

Anyway, I'm indifferent to the sidekick himself but I liked the opportunities it provided for Pegg to play off him.
 
I liked the part where Scotty is rambling on and on and Keenser is just shaking his head to Kirk like "yeah, there he goes again."
 
At first, I thought that would be the cute comic relief for the movie, and was deathly afraid of that.

But, it was actually nicely done, and I didn't mind it at all.


I agree! Well done. Cute is something Trek could use more of.

Space the darn thing? Is that the reaction Trek fans have to small people? What about Ben Folds? Louise DePalma--Danny Devito. Smurfs?

I think he looks like this guy from another franchise....

3548847093_2567a0eef8_o.jpg


Klaatu!
 
Last edited:
Hopefully we'll find out what species this thing is in the next movie. For all we know, Scotty found him on Delta Vega as an abandoned orphan or something and even HE doesn't know where the hell he comes from.


He's actually Gary Mitchell in disguise.

Wait 'til you see what Liz Dehner looks like... :p

Seen Sally Kellerman lately? The sidekick alien's sexier.:lol:
 
Hopefully we'll find out what species this thing is in the next movie. For all we know, Scotty found him on Delta Vega as an abandoned orphan or something and even HE doesn't know where the hell he comes from.


He's actually Gary Mitchell in disguise.

Wait 'til you see what Liz Dehner looks like... :p

I have.

Link to an updated pic of Sally Kellerman. Tell me there's no Ark of the Covenant for gazin' into.:lol:
 
May 20:
Hopefully we'll find out what species this thing is in the next movie. For all we know, Scotty found him on Delta Vega as an abandoned orphan or something and even HE doesn't know where the hell he comes from.


He's actually Gary Mitchell in disguise.

Wait 'til you see what Liz Dehner looks like... :p

Seen Sally Kellerman lately? The sidekick alien's sexier.:lol:

Today:
Hopefully we'll find out what species this thing is in the next movie. For all we know, Scotty found him on Delta Vega as an abandoned orphan or something and even HE doesn't know where the hell he comes from.


He's actually Gary Mitchell in disguise.

Wait 'til you see what Liz Dehner looks like... :p

I have.

Link to an updated pic of Sally Kellerman. Tell me there's no Ark of the Covenant for gazin' into.:lol:
Ain't thread necro grand?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top