The Official STAR TREK Grading & Discussion Thread [SPOILERS]

[nickyboy]

its really good, I enjoyed the humor. not enough McCoy though

 

[Bounty]

And once more on Friday just because I need to watch it in English.

Ah, the advantage of a cinema in Brussels: nobody can deicde what language they want to see the movie in, so in the end it's English with subtitles.

 

[Roshi]

Lucky bastard!

 

[ST-One]

And that prevents him from choosing to go back intentionally to fix all this....how?

It's simple. Slingshot around the sun to go back to a point before the timeline diverged and prevent the destruction of the Kelvin, presuming that's the focal point in the timeline (another argument), then go back to the point in the timeline before this whole thing started, apparently the destruction of Romulus. Prevent that, or at least mitigate the results somehow, to the point where Nero doesn't go on a time-spanning rampage, and bingo, timeline restored.

But then, JJ wouldn't have his own Star Trek universe to do with what he wants.

If you had seen the movie, you'd know that what you just said is total BS.

 

[ST-One]

its really good, I enjoyed the humor. not enough McCoy though

And not enough of Pike.

I loved Sulu's first attempt to bring the Enterprise to warp-speed...


BTW: Isn't it great that the bridge has that big ass window instead of a view-screen

 

[Bounty]

BTW: Isn't it great that the bridge has that big ass window instead of a view-screen

What's the worst that can happen? It's not like it can... dunno... crack or something. Just a completely random example of the top of my head

 

[Tom Servo]

BTW: Isn't it great that the bridge has that big ass window instead of a view-screen

What's the worst that can happen? It's not like it can... dunno... crack or something. Just a completely random example of the top of my head

Can transparent aluminum crack?

 

[ST-One]

BTW: Isn't it great that the bridge has that big ass window instead of a view-screen

What's the worst that can happen? It's not like it can... dunno... crack or something. Just a completely random example of the top of my head

Can transparent aluminum crack?

Well, it does.
But so does the rest of the bridge...

 

[ST-One]

BTW: Isn't it great that the bridge has that big ass window instead of a view-screen

What's the worst that can happen? It's not like it can... dunno... crack or something. Just a completely random example of the top of my head

Actually, I find it great that I was right about the 'window-theory'

 

[Roshi]

Modestly triumphant, I see!

 

[Whatever]

BTW: Isn't it great that the bridge has that big ass window instead of a view-screen

What's the worst that can happen? It's not like it can... dunno... crack or something. Just a completely random example of the top of my head

Well it won't crack if its transparent duratanium ,but it could blow up though,i doubt nero would be shooting snowballs at them
I'm hoping to see the movie this month ,so i can get my grading on

 

[Roshi]

Not Nero's snowballs, but I think the gravitational pull might be enough to crack a wee bit the **transparent aluminum**...

 

[M'Sharak]

<snip>

If you had seen the movie, you'd know that what you just said is total BS.

Of course it is (and I'm sure he's well aware that it's little more than his own fanfic, having little or nothing to do with the story told in the movie) but, for some odd reason, people keep quoting and responding to his comments as if they're in some way pertinent to the topic of discussion (that being the movie April keeps saying he hasn't seen yet.) Stop taking the bait, and let's get on with talking about the movie which is being shown, eh?

 

[Bounty]

Pike explicitly told them not to scratch the paint and everything!

That scene looked great dramatically, but it didn't make all that much sense. Still, nothing says "we're in trouble" now quite like it.

 

[indranee]

Actually, I've just come back from my second viewing and paid attention to it. Not at warp.

just where the hell are you watching this thing twice in two days?! it's not even been released yet!!

Early screening on Tuesday
Premiere on Wednesday
And once more on Thursday just because.

I so hate you both!

 

[ST-One]

<snip>

If you had seen the movie, you'd know that what you just said is total BS.

Of course it is (and I'm sure he's well aware that it's little more than his own fanfic, having little or nothing to do with the story told in the movie) but, for some odd reason, people keep quoting and responding to his comments as if they're in some way pertinent to the topic of discussion (that being the movie April keeps saying he hasn't seen yet.) Stop taking the bait, and let's get on with talking about the movie which is being shown, eh?

Okay.
Robau's death... well, let's just say: bad-ass, my ass
J/K.
That was one incredible beginning.

 

[Whatever]

One question ,the romulan chick from the countdown comics ....is she in? and another question about the deaths,are they gory or kiddy stuff ?

thanks

 

[Smiley]

Random thought:

At least the Enterprise wasn't "the only ship in the quadrant" in this movie.

 

[Roshi]

One question ,the romulan chick from the countdown comics ....is she in? and another question about the deaths,are they gory or kiddy stuff ?

thanks

Just a holographic pic of the Romulan lady and no gruesome death that I can recall.

 

[Whatever]

Not Nero's wife,the bad ass chick under his command