• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

World Premiere/Advance screening discussions [SPOILERS GUARANTEED]

Okay, here are some questions:

How does Nero end up in the Klingon prison?

How are the Klingons presented?

Any references to Kirk's time on Tarsus IV, or Gary Mitchell? (personally I doubt this)

Is the Enterprise a "brand new" starship when it is launched with Kirk on board, as we've heard?

Is Kirk a cadet when he comes aboard or not?

What references are there to Enterprise (besides the bit about Scotty and Admiral Archer's beagle)?

Just what is Nero's plan in the 23rd century?

What happens to Pike at the end of the movie?

IS VULCAN DESTROYED???
 
From Odo Itals's thread


Captain Pike goes aboard the Romulan ship, Spock is left in command, and Kirk leads the mission to destroy the weapon [...].
And this is where big changes start, separating this movie’s reality from the rest of the franchise. Nero, the leader of the Romulans from the future, has created an alternate reality. A point that is hit over the head a few times, by Spock & Uhura, by Ambassador Spock to young Kirk....

Obviously, the alternate reality has NOTHING to do with the design changes, because it happens well after the newly designed ship, bridge, uniforms etc. are shown to us but is rather a vehicle to make future changes possible.

I would like that (I hate the idea of this being some "ENT sequel")
It also would seem that the design changes might not be explained in any way. Good.

Seems it's a remake AND a reboot after all. w00t
it would also mean that Kirk's backstory is the way "it was supposed to happen", even in the old timeline.
 
ClayHefner said:
From Odo Itals's thread


Captain Pike goes aboard the Romulan ship, Spock is left in command, and Kirk leads the mission to destroy the weapon [...].
And this is where big changes start, separating this movie’s reality from the rest of the franchise. Nero, the leader of the Romulans from the future, has created an alternate reality. A point that is hit over the head a few times, by Spock & Uhura, by Ambassador Spock to young Kirk....

Obviously, the alternate reality has NOTHING to do with the design changes, because it happens well after the newly designed ship, bridge, uniforms etc. are shown to us but is rather a vehicle to make future changes possible.

I would like that (I hate the idea of this being some "ENT sequel")
It also would seem that the design changes might not be explained in any way. Good.

Seems it's a remake AND a reboot after all. w00t
it would also mean that Kirk's backstory is the way "it was supposed to happen", even in the old timeline.
Click to expand...
That doesn't really make sense. Why would Pike going aboard the Romulan ship create the alternate reality? Surely the destruction of the Kelvin would?
 
El Chupacabra said:
Very pleased to hear that Nimoy features a lot, rather than just in an extended cameo.

Shame about Shat. I really thought it would have been a good idea to have him do the "Space. The Final Frontier" speech at the end. Talking of which, do we hear it from anyone else?

And what of the alternate universe issue. Is Shatner Trek left "unwiped"?

Also, any 24th Century bits?
Click to expand...

Nimoy does the speech at the end.

There are 24th Century bits. :)
 
Here's my thoughts on the alternate universe, I'm going to lay out a bulk of the plot so be warned!

So basically everything is changed when Nero travels back through time, he is determined to destroy all planets in the federation as retribution for the destruction of Romulus in the 24th century. Obviously the big change to the universe is the destruction of Vulcan. I don't think this spoils Kirk in any fashion, the movie does note how in the alternate universe Kirk's father was alive and saw him make Captain, in this universe Kirk's father is killed in battle with Nero. The characteristics of all the crew members remain true to the TOS, with the exception of Spock who is in constant battle with his human half and displays a lot of emotion. I'm not sure how this will tie in with Pike's future, they do show him in a wheelchair at the end of the movie.
 
Iano said:
Here's my thoughts on the alternate universe, I'm going to lay out a bulk of the plot so be warned!

So basically everything is changed when Nero travels back through time, he is determined to destroy all planets in the federation as retribution for the destruction of Romulus in the 24th century. Obviously the big change to the universe is the destruction of Vulcan. I don't think this spoils Kirk in any fashion, the movie does note how in the alternate universe Kirk's father was alive and saw him make Captain, in this universe Kirk's father is killed in battle with Nero. The characteristics of all the crew members remain true to the TOS, with the exception of Spock who is in constant battle with his human half and displays a lot of emotion. I'm not sure how this will tie in with Pike's future, they do show him in a wheelchair at the end of the movie.
Click to expand...

Christ, a Trekverse without Vulcan? I'm not sure how I can digest that. Obviously it may well make for some interesting storytelling, but Vulcans as the refugees of the galaxy? No, this is one major difference I'm not yet comfortable with.

Still, this reaffirms my desire to treat the nuTOS characters as different characters from Shatner & Nimoy, so its tolerable I guess.
 
Iano said:
Cheebo said:
What bits?
Click to expand...

Nero is from the 24th century as is Ambassador Spock. Events unfold in the 24th Century that cause Nero and Spock to travel back in time.
Click to expand...

well this is the basic star trek countdown backstory. but did spock specifically mention that the crew of the enterprise-e tried to stop nero?

does the film give an explanation why technology appears to be more advanced compared to the original tos timeline?
 
Moved to spoilers discussion thread

"The flick starts out with a bang as the USS Kelvin is attacked by a giant Romulan ship that appears out of a black hole. The ship is almost instantly crippled, the Captain summoned by Nero, the movie’s villain who is searching for Spock. When the Captain leaves, he promotes a young man named George Kirk to captain the ship."

"Young Kirk honorably runs the ship, successfully evacuating everybody before it is destroyed, including his wife, in the middle of giving birth. It’s actually a very touching scene, about as perfectly effecting and emotional as I could have hoped for."

"It also kicks off the real split between this universe and the Trek universe we all know. Without any cop-outs, Abrams and his team establish that with this single event everything has changed. In short, it’s the perfect set up for a reboot. It can (and does, with Nimoy’s appearance as Spock Prime, as he’s listed in the credits) respect the originals while being free to do its own thing."

"Everything we have seen still exists, just not in this reality. I think it’s pretty genius, actually, but only if they stick to this universe now. I’d hate to see them go back and forth with the existing Trek reality and this one in further sequels. I like the world (or maybe universe is a better term considering the material) that Abrams and his team has created here. I like the cast he assembled, I like the way this new universe turns some old Trek landmarks on their heads, while keeping true to what’s really important to each character."


http://www.aintitcool.com/node/40675
 
Did urbandk see this? I await his review - in the meantime, perhaps Iano will at some point include some detail that hasn't either been reported widely for months or lifted from one of the many other synospes/reviews appearing online.

As far as when the timeline separates -
several reviews have made it clear that the timeline is rebooted when the Kelvin is destroyed. I think what Odo Ital is suggesting is that the events following Pike's personal surrender to Nero are the big ones that would affect events that we've already seen in "Star Trek." IOW, Kirk not knowing his father does not eliminate "Amok Time." The destruction of Vulcan, however, does.
 
What I still don't get:
Why doesn't Nero do something "productive" instead if he has all that TT tech and a mighty ship? Like forcing the Senate to evacuate Romulus in the past or something.
And/or make a short stop in the time before the disaster to grab his wife and kids and rescue them? I mean revenge is cool and all...
 
Do we get to see engineering in the movie? Does it look like the dreaded pipes we've all been seeing?

Why is Scotty swimming in the water tubes?

How does Romulus get destroyed?

Does the Narada use Borg technology? How is it so powerful?
 
Last edited:
Starship Polaris said:
Did urbandk see this? I await his review - in the meantime, perhaps Iano will at some point include some detail that hasn't either been reported widely for months or lifted from one of the many other synospes/reviews appearing online.

As far as when the timeline separates -
several reviews have made it clear that the timeline is rebooted when the Kelvin is destroyed. I think what Odo Ital is suggesting is that the events following Pike's personal surrender to Nero are the big ones that would affect events that we've already seen in "Star Trek." IOW, Kirk not knowing his father does not eliminate "Amok Time." The destruction of Vulcan, however, does.
Click to expand...

makes sense
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

The Wormhole
Spoilers Mrs. Flood Theories
2 3
Replies
40
Views
1K
Commander Troi
Commander Troi
Procutus
Spoilers Strangers from the Sky by Margaret Wander Bonanno - a look back
2
Replies
31
Views
2K
Allyn Gibson
Allyn Gibson
Steve Roby
Blade Runner: the franchise
2
Replies
28
Views
2K
Christopher
Christopher
A
I don't like this news about SNW season 3 from Screen Rant
15 16 17
Replies
338
Views
21K
Phoenix219
Phoenix219
Starscape
  • Sticky
Contest: ENTER June 2025 Art Challenge - Suggest Your Themes!
Replies
2
Views
163
Laura Cynthia Chambers
Laura Cynthia Chambers
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top