My dad always said that his dad would say there was absolutely no need for credit cards, you should only spend money that you actually have, else it will just get you into trouble. Well, I'm in trouble, ugh.
My dad said that his dad said "What's a credit card?"
I have one credit card with a $1000 limit that I use just for online purchases. If anyone scams the number I don't want $20,000 of credit available.
I pay it off as soon as the charge appears on the account. It's on my web banking page so I can transfer directly from my chequing the same day the transaction is posted. I usually never run a balance. The odd time I buy something for over $500 and pay it over 2 months, usually at Christmas when I've got more spending than usual. In these cases I don't fret over paying $2.00 interest.
When I was younger I let a card balance get out of control, that was a nightmare I'll never repeat. I don't think credit cards are necessarily bad, but the way they are structured is. I think that if you run a balance longer than 2 months they should automatically switch from the minimum payment bullshit over to an automatic loan repayment system, the same as if you took out a loan from the bank. It should then schedule itself for full repayment within a specified time, default 1 year unless you ask for an extended time.
If you need a loan, take out a loan. Don't use credit for loans. It's too easy to just sit on the principal, pay the minimum and then max it out again late in the month. My ex does that constantly, and then blames the world for not being able to pay it off.
Brent, my advice to you is to go to your bank. Take out a consumer loan with a 5 year repayment for the total amount of your credit card debt, plus $1000 or so. Put the extra thousand in a savings account, this is your new credit card to use if you're having an emergency.
Cancel at least one credit card. Keep one with a $500 balance to order pizza's and online porn or whatever you can't use cash for. The card you keep should be a high interest, no fee card that has at least some perks, like automatic extended warrenty, or "no questions" return policy. You should never run a balance on the card.
You'll probably have to do this in 6 months when your car loan is paid, unless you can convince the bank to consolodate that loan into the same payments as well. I know banks are getting weird with loans these days, but if you are cancelling credit cards this frees up credit in your credit report and they are likely to do this.