What If: Enterprise E stranded in Delta Quadrant?
- Thread starter JJohnson
- Start date
In that case, I think he would promote Data to be honest. I doubt Picard would have gotten on well with Chakotay.
I remember at the time I thought Voyager would have made a good TNG movie. In my scenario, the Enterprise, Gul Evek's ship, and a Maquis ship commanded by Ro Laren are all transported by the Caretaker. Picard has to convince the Cardassians and the Maquis that they need to put aside their conflicts and work together to get home, while he has some trouble following his own advice re: anger at Ro for her betrayal of Starfleet and of him personally. IIRC eventually Ro agrees to turn herself in once they all get home in return for the rest of her crew being allowed to go free, and Evek agrees due to the circumstances. Most of the rest of the story played out similar to Caretaker, except at the end they rig a time-delay explosive and all go home.
Really?
If anything, I would think that Chakotay would look to Picard as a mentor for archeology and anthropology
We also know that Picard is able to look beyond previously committed sins. We see him accept Ro into the "inner circle"
As for Enterprise E in the DQ, I think it's a matter of how its done
Who in the crew is killed? If Beverly is killed, it creates two wonderful plot lines (Picard losing Bev AND Data and the EMH interacting!)
If Riker does survive, what role would Chakotay play?
With both Tuvok and Worf aboard ship, it would create an interesting dynamic and clash of styles in security.
How would Bellana crush Geordi's heart
I could see Tom Paris being the helmsman because Picard is a good friend of Admiral Paris.
Poor Harry would have no role
As for the Kazon and Enterprise E, I don't buy it. Voyager was vastly beneath the Enterprise in terms of overall strength... We would see Enterprise have a much easier time with the Kazon
As for the vidiians, that one gets interesting
I honestly could see Picard spend weeks trying to help them despite their constant attacks
And I doubt that Ransom would have tried to fight Picard the way he did Janeway.
As for Seska, she never would have betrayed the Enterprise crew because Picard is not an erratic crazy woman
Picard might have taken him because of his experience with Chakotay as well
It might also have been Ro
As for Tuvok, he was already on the Maquis ship
okay. I couldn't remember how the programme started. I did recall Tuvok being a spy on the Maquis ship. 
There wasn't really many of the main cast who were serving Voyager crew members then were there: Just Capt. Kathy and Ens. Kim... oh, and the EMH.
It's a shame they don't do a trek series with more regular cast, like 20-30 or so, like soap operas have. And damn the expense. The traditional format is focusing on two or three characters in almost any scene. But It'd be nice to have seen episodes take a much wider perspective following the adventures of a bigger group. What do you think?
There wasn't really many of the main cast who were serving Voyager crew members then were there: Just Capt. Kathy and Ens. Kim... oh, and the EMH.
It's a shame they don't do a trek series with more regular cast, like 20-30 or so, like soap operas have. And damn the expense.
The traditional format is focusing on two or three characters in almost any scene. But It'd be nice to have seen episodes take a much wider perspective following the adventures of a bigger group. What do you think?
especially on Voyager!
On TNG, you had the excuse that the ship was constantly going to starbases and people could come and go
On DS9, people could leave the area around Bajor/Cardassia
But on Voyager, there isn't anywhere to go
No new people... There are 150ish people aboard. They should have had 20-30 "regular extras" and had some stories written for them from time to time (like they do in nuBSG for Helo, Cally and many more!)
And remember, the Enterprise E did have an EMH, so the only main crewmembers that couldn't make the trip to the DQ are Harry and Cap'n Kate
On TNG, you had the excuse that the ship was constantly going to starbases and people could come and go
On DS9, people could leave the area around Bajor/Cardassia
But on Voyager, there isn't anywhere to go
No new people... There are 150ish people aboard. They should have had 20-30 "regular extras" and had some stories written for them from time to time (like they do in nuBSG for Helo, Cally and many more!)
And remember, the Enterprise E did have an EMH, so the only main crewmembers that couldn't make the trip to the DQ are Harry and Cap'n Kate
Yeah TighsEye, I get where you're coming from. But I'd imagine if it were to happen he would want an experienced first officer with him, and Data has that experience. I do think though, if Riker did survive then Chekotay would have taken a tatical position and Worf more of a security (providing that Worf was even there as it's plausable he was just on DS9 if it ever happened).
As for the Kazon... Ha. I doubt they would have challenged the Enterprise the way they did Voyager.
And Ramsom, I doubt Picard would have stood for his bullshit.
As for the Kazon... Ha. I doubt they would have challenged the Enterprise the way they did Voyager.
And Ramsom, I doubt Picard would have stood for his bullshit.
That certainly would not be Picard's reaction.
It would be cool to see what kind of odd contrasts would come up between Data and Tuvok.
We have seen Picard respect races mandatory death ritual...
So, I think he would try to convince Quinn not to, and then allow him to do it
Yes, I think that would be a lot closer to the truth. But he certainly wouldn't be nonchalant about it.
On the subject of the EMH I doubt there would be any need for him at all if the E-E were in the DQ instead of the Voyager even if Beverley were to get killed. The reason being because the E-E has around 7 or 8 times more crew than the Voyager and would obviously have a more sizeable Medical staff with at least more than one Doctor. So if Crusher died then all Picard would have to do is promote the next Doctor or most senior Medical Person with the proper quialifications to CMO and that would be that.
I agree. Theres always like 10 or so medical staff running around.
Voyager had nurses as well... They were all killed
So, it's possible that almost all, if not all, of Enterprises medical staff would be killed as well
Similar threads
