• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Doctor Who – 4x08 – Silence in the Library (Grade/Discuss)

Grade Silence in the Library

  • Total voters
    158
Maybe the Last of the Timelords (TM) settles down in the future. Could be Mrs Who or his daughter from the future.

With Davies and Moffat, who the hell knows.
 
Funny, I was thinking she might be Jenny, although I know that would piss off those who wanted to Gerogina again.

Great episode, hardly felt like 45 minute at all, the only thing that felt a little forced was the cliffhanger, and the ghosting of the girl who died was so much like Kylies last moments I dont know why the Doctor didnt mention it.
 
Xeris said:
Maybe the Last of the Timelords (TM) settles down in the future. Could be Mrs Who or his daughter from the future.

With Davies and Moffat, who the hell knows.
Click to expand...

Well, in one possible future. But "always in motion is the future" - so if he gets himself killed before he meets her, all bets are off.
 
She handles all that tech so well I thought she was going to be Rani or however you spell that women's name but probably not.
 
Anyone else get a Donna dying at the end of the season vibe?

I am curious now as to what would happen if the weeping angels were in a room with the shadow piranhas.
 
biotech said:
Funny, I was thinking she might be Jenny, although I know that would piss off those who wanted to Gerogina again.
Click to expand...

And she'd have recognized Donna, which was in fact a fairly large dropping of hints that Donna - for some (ominous) reason - isn't still with the Doc when River "first" meets him.
 
At the risk of raising expectations too high - could a Moffatt run Who possibly have the potential to be the best TV show ever made?

Guess we will find out in two years, have to make a note to start driving safely...
 
biotech said:
Funny, I was thinking she might be Jenny, although I know that would piss off those who wanted to Gerogina again.
Click to expand...
I thought the same thing at first. But I figured it'd be a bit much to include a future companion, and have it be Jenny in one story.
 
You know, this is a great episode for kids.

If I were 9 years old I would be scared shitless. :lol:
 
matthunter said:
biotech said:
Funny, I was thinking she might be Jenny, although I know that would piss off those who wanted to Gerogina again.
Click to expand...

And she'd have recognized Donna, which was in fact a fairly large dropping of hints that Donna - for some (ominous) reason - isn't still with the Doc when River "first" meets him.
Click to expand...
Well, she did say he was a lot younger than she'd ever seen him, which for a Timelord could be hundreds of years.
 
biotech said:
Anyone else get a Donna dying at the end of the season vibe?
Click to expand...

According to folks who saw some location filming for the finale...

She seems to get returned home and mind-wiped, as a scene was filmed with the Doctor telling Wilf that he must never tell her about her experiences.
 
She also mentioned that he had been in and out of her life, so they must keep running into each other in different time periods, say over the course of 4 specials?
 
no has mentioned the matrix style reference (how this (her) world is a lie)

I bet the little girl is the library's main computer
 
Out-bloody-standing.

All hail Moffat, the king of Who!

Hilarious, terrifying, thought-provoking, heartbreaking, wonderful Who!

Oh, anyone else spot the tiny oblique reference to Rose?

It can be next week time nao?
 
Fantastic! Very chilling in parts; the skeleton in the suit chasing after them was great and the flesh head doodads we're freaky as hell. I suppose this episode could make the people scared of their own shadows feel justified.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top