That's one of my other preferred resolutions to the Fermi Paradox. There weren't enough heavy elements around in the early universe for life to evolve. The JWST has shown that there are perhaps more than expected, however.
That was my thought. How long did it take for the Population II stars to go thru their lives and then novae, seeding the cosmos with elements needed for Population I stars...and us? The Sun formed from molecular clouds of exploded star guts when the Universe was 8 billion years old.
It took this long to evolve us from elements present in the molecular cloud from which the Sun came 4.3 billion years ago.
I like the thought that I, a sentient being created from starstuff, is looking at stars, even exploded stars, with an object made from exploded starstuff when I use my telescope.
I think we are first.