• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

Another very major point. About evolutionary programming.

When Gene Roddenberry gave instructions to Matt Jeffreys, on the developing Enterprise, this was an evolutionary process - done manually. As in no computerized.
This can't be understated at all, a series of random discussions/commands that led to the Enterprise TOS... each MAN, had their education to process what was required, but needed no understanding of the actual physics involved.

In other words, this design works. Not figutively, in actuality.

Because actual understanding wasn't required. Both of warp physics, nor of computers, nor of space/interstellar travel.

Why?

Because it was evolutionary in nature.

If you have one million monkeys tapping on one million typewriters, you will eventually get all the works of Shakespeare.

However with two educated people, and evolutionary programming you don't need to have one million monkeys. The two people are sufficient.

Keep in mind that they didn't go far enough, nor kept the design process going.

What they were, was a think tank in process. Given an incentive to take the design further, such as interior design, mass distribution and so on, a working piece of equipment could have been built.

I am saying that they should have gone much further than they did.
 
If Gene Roddenberry wanted to set up a 'small' think tank, that was his business. The implications as to exactly what happened are quite interesting in nature.

There is, in philosophy the concept called "The Chinese Room", in which an operator - takes in words on a series of cards, and following a few simple rules translate the message into Chinese, the reverse is also possible.

Is there actual intelligence involved? No. A flat out 'NO'. This is one of the philosophical points in the 1980s, against Artificial Intelligence, at least as proposed. Today? The isn't settled yet.

Why? Because of Dr. Allen Turing's comments on Artificial Intelligence...because if you can't tell the difference between a computer's response, and a humans response then by any sensible definition the machine is thinking.

Overlooking this philosophy is quite dangerous...
 
What can a slave master expect from a slave freeing themselves?

What does a slave master deserve?

History records the answer.

There is a reason why Spartus is remembered, and not just for dying in the typical Roman methodology.

Then you can have two examples from Science Fiction. Battlestar Galactica, and the Orville.

Now remember what the Zelots wanted.

The oppressed can get quite violent.
 
There is a reason why Spartus is remembered, and not just for dying in the typical Roman methodology.
Partially because a slave uprising in Rome was a constant fear due to the slave population being very large. Bread and circuses existed to keep them somewhat content and fear of masters wrath was the other.
 
Does a fish notice the water? No.

We are all so used to 'convention' do we notice the level of self control?

Not unless someone is driving us up the wall...

Parents primary job is enculturization. That, the teaching of how to behave in society. Despite Star Trek's emphasis on Vulcan self control, humans are expected to behave at all times...

Trip Tucker is, however an exception. And he was from the Bible belt...
 
Does a fish notice the water? No.

We are all so used to 'convention' do we notice the level of self control?

Not unless someone is driving us up the wall...

Parents primary job is enculturization. That, the teaching of how to behave in society. Despite Star Trek's emphasis on Vulcan self control, humans are expected to behave at all times...

Trip Tucker is, however an exception. And he was from the Bible belt...

Florida is not part of the Bible belt. It's not really part of The South either. Florida is kind of it's own thing.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top