• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Hey, I never noticed that before....

There's only so much a good director can do with a bad script.

Yeah—the script as filmed for "The Alternative Factor" is just so badly done, both from plotting and dialogue standpoints. The editing is also atrocious. I don't know if any of that was Oswald's fault. I agree that Oswald's direction—along with Shatner's amazing performance—made "The Conscience of the King." Arnold Moss was no slouch, either. And frankly, Barbara Anderson sold Lenore pretty well too, including without limitation her descent into madness.
 
Last edited:
I believe it's one of the best-directed episodes in all of Star Trek (I'll always be in denial that the same Gerd Oswald also directed "The Alternative Factor").
There's only so much a good director can do with a bad script.
So, a few pieces of trivia regarding Gerd Oswald from my 'Outer Limits Companion'.
His father, producer-director Richard Oswald, directed the first film version of 'Around the World in Eighty Days' in 1919.
Young Gerd appeared on stage in Berlin with Hedy Lamarr.
His family fled Germany in 1933, settling in Austria, before moving to America in 1938.
He was AD on several Monogram and Republic pictures and serials in the 1940s.
His directorial debut was 1955's 'A Kiss Before Dying' staring Robert Wagner.
He directed the parachute assault on the French village of St. Mere-Eglise, which featured Red Buttons, in 'The Longest Day'.
Gerd directed 14 episodes of the 'Outer Limits' first season.
 
Last edited:
As Kirk, McCoy and Barrows run towards where Sulu is target shooting, they run along a path that appears to have been freshly mowed.

shore-leave-br-162.jpg


***TrekCore supplied this image***
 

Use of the phrase "ceased to function" - did the computer write his epitaph, or did he, prior to his death?

It reminds me of this:

 
All of these years of watching TOS and I never really noticed the disassembled Communicators in Patterns of Force. I have a good excuse; it’s one of my least favorite episodes so I kind of sleepwalk through it.

patterns-of-force-455.jpg


***Thanks to TrekCore for the image!!!***

As a Trek equipment lover, I really enjoy those elements of "Patterns of Force." (I also like the ep generally, an unpopular opinion here.) Whereas many landing party TOS episodes involve lost or confiscated equipment that is never explained or accounted for, POF has the cool moments of Spock making one communicator using parts from both, and the fun line that the "alien pistols" (the phasers) were sent to Gestapo HQ for further analysis.
 
As Kirk, McCoy and Barrows run towards where Sulu is target shooting, they run along a path that appears to have been freshly mowed.

shore-leave-br-162.jpg


***TrekCore supplied this image***

And a tree trunk marked with red spray paint, even in the plants leaves in front of it. Some kind of mark for filming?

I don't have the episode handy or remember it at all, so I can't say if that's part of the episode plot/action.
 
My first thought was a hiking trail marker, but it seems a bit too irregular for that. Hard to tell from just a still image though.
 
My first thought was a hiking trail marker, but it seems a bit too irregular for that. Hard to tell from just a still image though.
This episode always perplexed me a bit with various scenes having odd red/brown patches on the flora. As a kid sitting in front of a 1960s TV, I couldn't figure out why Yeoman Barrows' blood was all over that tree.

shore-leave-br-106.jpg
shore-leave-br-249.jpg


***TrekCore supplied these images***
 
This episode always perplexed me a bit with various scenes having odd red/brown patches on the flora. As a kid sitting in front of a 1960s TV, I couldn't figure out why Yeoman Barrows' blood was all over that tree.

shore-leave-br-106.jpg
shore-leave-br-249.jpg


***TrekCore supplied these images***

TOS film crew member Rufus T. Firefly was in charge of the red spray paint supply on that day…

spray-paint-reid-haughton.gif
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top