• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

When did Fred Freiberger jump the shark?

That didn't matter because mosto f the crew would be turned into the cubes, even if the Kelvins were too bored to neatly tidy up the corridors*. Was the racism intentional, or incidental/accidental. . . . .

Lazy five pasty-faced bastards. The sexism was appropriate given all Enterprise women shown in this episode were limited in their responsibilities. I only hope Doctor Noel transferred out with Yeoman Rand before Operation Wipeout. If there was racism, Shea and Uhura got short shrift, except when we consider:

*Kirk has never seriously relied on security guards to protect him. Their true unstated responsibility is to disintegrate, explode, fall apart and arrange for parental payoffs through Starfleet insurance credits. Shea is not the only guard to survive a mission, but he's in the lucky minority. By my ''logic,'' he and the other rare survivors have failed in their mission. Still, he gets to live.....and gets our minds off the potential racism of erasing him twice. (If you desire to see the unblocked Shea in future adventures, check out John Byrne's excellent photocomics of the 2010s. They reassigned him to less stressful duties.) However:

* Uhura was first on the Enterprise to suffer dehydrated cocaine-blocking after Rojan commenced Operation Sugarcubes. Not necessarily racist, but Rojan wiped out her and the Davy Jones lookalike before the silent female redshirt, Ensign Stoneface and Generic Third Officer got the treatment simultaneously.
According to Newspapers.com records "The Man Trap" was televised first in New York City like elsewhere.

https://ibb.co/Xb9zNSf
It seems my Hyattsville Library convention organizer provided us with false information. During that same free-con, I was expected to identify a Gary Mitchell quote which was always cut out for syndication!
Do you think if the chief engineer had been a woman that they would have zapped her and gone and found a middle age Scotsman?
Good idea. Let's retcon Mira Romaine and temporarily fire Scotty for the Argelius incidents.

I think Rojan would have, or should have kept the engineers. And if Helen Noel was on board, sparing her instead of McCoy would definitely have given Spock five less insults a day to hash out.:borg:
 
How anyone can watch season 1 of TNG and then continue to maintain that season 3 of TOS is bad is beyond me.

I honestly don't think Freiberger ever really jumped the shark, and I think he gets unfairly maligned. People cite "Spock's Brain" all the time, but I would much rather watch that episode than "The Alternative Factor" any day. There really are quite a number of good episodes in season 3 and few that are really, truly horrible. I just don't think it's anywhere near the mess that people make it out to be.
 
I'm thinking "The Alternative Factor" is really overhated, sure there are a lot of flaws and annoyances but there still also seemed to be quite a bit of fascination that was at least somewhat interesting, taking all the anti-matter concepts seriously as a big dangerous deal and not exactly convincingly so but making the whole thing at least a little interesting and worthwhile.

I think the original show had both higher highs and lower lows from tending to commit to its really out-there concepts.
 
There are just some folks that are never going to like S3. Which is too bad. Seeing so much of the Enterprise is wonderful for me, as are the Sulu/Chekov interactions that we rarely got in S2 because of George's vacation. The recurring disease theme is also fascinating to me. And the darkness inherent in (e.g.) "The Empath" and "Wink of an Eye" - wow.

Another puzzler for me is fans who adore the K/S/M relationship, but don't seem to agree that it received its best development in S3.

Oh, well.
 
There are just some folks that are never going to like S3. Which is too bad. Seeing so much of the Enterprise is wonderful for me, as are the Sulu/Chekov interactions that we rarely got in S2 because of George's vacation. The recurring disease theme is also fascinating to me. And the darkness inherent in (e.g.) "The Empath" and "Wink of an Eye" - wow.

Another puzzler for me is fans who adore the K/S/M relationship, but don't seem to agree that it received its best development in S3.

Oh, well.
vacation? he was fighting the war in nam with the duke
 
Another puzzler for me is fans who adore the K/S/M relationship, but don't seem to agree that it received its best development in S3.

Oh, well.

It is, can feel weird but I thought they actually had their most and/or best interactions in Season 1, yes technically before Kelly was in the opening credits, there were a few notable episodes and some outright good ones about the relationship in Season 3 but (aside from me really disliking "The Empath" and considering it a waste of time) it also featured somewhat more overdone versions of the characters, particularly Kirk the womanizer and McCoy complaining about everything, Season 1 it felt like McCoy was being included and playing big role, bigger than would be expected/intended because he just had to be that made sense.
 
It is, can feel weird but I thought they actually had their most and/or best interactions in Season 1, yes technically before Kelly was in the opening credits, there were a few notable episodes and some outright good ones about the relationship in Season 3 but (aside from me really disliking "The Empath" and considering it a waste of time) it also featured somewhat more overdone versions of the characters, particularly Kirk the womanizer and McCoy complaining about everything, Season 1 it felt like McCoy was being included and playing big role, bigger than would be expected/intended because he just had to be that made sense.

Interesting. I'm thinking specifically of "For the World is Hollow," "The Empath," "Requiem for Methuselah," "All Our Yesterdays," "Plato's Stepchildren," "Day of the Dove," "Elaan of Troyius," "The Tholian Web," "Spectre of the Gun," "The Paradise Syndrome," "Spock's Brain" and "The Enterprise Incident." You can make cases for "Turnabout Intruder" and "The Savage Curtain" as well. (The remaining S3 eps either split up Kirk and Spock for almost the entire runtime, featured oddly minimal McCoy like "Let That Be Your Last Battlefield" and "And the Children Shall Lead," or were unusual (and excellent IMO) pieces like "Wink of an Eye" and "The Cloud Minders.") I'm probably missing some S3 eps that might make my point or weaken it. :lol:

Assuming I'm somewhere in the ballpark, are there 14 episodes in S1 that advance and develop the KSM troika as much as those?
 
Interesting. I'm thinking specifically of "For the World is Hollow," "The Empath," "Requiem for Methuselah," "All Our Yesterdays," "Plato's Stepchildren," "Day of the Dove," "Elaan of Troyius," "The Tholian Web," "Spectre of the Gun," "The Paradise Syndrome," "Spock's Brain" and "The Enterprise Incident." You can make cases for "Turnabout Intruder" and "The Savage Curtain" as well. (The remaining S3 eps either split up Kirk and Spock for almost the entire runtime, featured oddly minimal McCoy like "Let That Be Your Last Battlefield" and "And the Children Shall Lead," or were unusual (and excellent IMO) pieces like "Wink of an Eye" and "The Cloud Minders.") I'm probably missing some S3 eps that might make my point or weaken it. :lol:

Assuming I'm somewhere in the ballpark, are there 14 episodes in S1 that advance and develop the KSM troika as much as those?
Well......landing-party wise, it was CITY ON THE EDGE OF FOREVER then AMOK TIME which seemed to cement the unholy trio's habit patterns. Even then, CITY was at the tail-end of season one, however, and four others beamed down in that one without going to the 1930s. So AMOK TIME is true-glue while CITY is a reuniting in the past for them. But season three is disgustingly KSMed to death for those who enjoy variety. Honestly, the answer to your question is ''No way.'':borg:
 
Assuming I'm somewhere in the ballpark, are there 14 episodes in S1 that advance and develop the KSM troika as much as those?
I also think that S3 did the K/S/M relationship best (same as "The Final Frontier", another case of fans not liking much the final product, yet being great in that regard).
Season 1 tended to ignore McCoy during its last episodes. "A Taste of Armageddon", "Errand of Mercy" and "The Devil in the Dark" are almost exclusively Kirk & Spock episodes ("The City on the Edge of Forever" too, though to a lesser degree).
As for the rest of season 1, I think it's generally very Kirk-centric. Which is understandable, given that Kirk was designed to be the star of the show from the beginning. But I prefer the concept of later seasons, where it was more like "Kirk at the center, but Spock & McCoy close behind".
 
I also think that S3 did the K/S/M relationship best (same as "The Final Frontier", another case of fans not liking much the final product, yet being great in that regard).
Season 1 tended to ignore McCoy during its last episodes. "A Taste of Armageddon", "Errand of Mercy" and "The Devil in the Dark" are almost exclusively Kirk & Spock episodes ("The City on the Edge of Forever" too, though to a lesser degree).
As for the rest of season 1, I think it's generally very Kirk-centric. Which is understandable, given that Kirk was designed to be the star of the show from the beginning. But I prefer the concept of later seasons, where it was more like "Kirk at the center, but Spock & McCoy close behind".

Good comments. I only disagree with your comments about "City" - they don't have much screen time together, but the KSM relationship is pretty key and receives some critical development.

Yes, "Errand of Mercy" is one of the four eps that does not feature McCoy at all. Two of the other three are pretty easy to guess at - "Where No Man Has Gone Before" of course and "The Menagerie, Part II," but the fourth is somewhat intriguing. I'm sure someone will get it immediately.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top