I would be fine with that.
What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?
- Thread starter Amasov
- Start date
I would be fine with that.
Mileage varies, it’s taken several rewatches for hubs and I to enjoy DS9; I like it more than he does. Glad she’s watching!
That's the beauty of fandom, everybody has their own personal rankings, but to see what the averaged out fan rankings turns out to be is interesting in itself.
I'm not going to diss any Trek as outright bad, but VOY above TOS?Interesting how they amalgamated many rankings from various fan ratings and combined them.
I guess everybody's personal rankings will vary drastically cause mines would look a bit different from this ranking as well.
That's the beauty of fandom, everybody has their own personal rankings, but to see what the averaged out fan rankings turns out to be is interesting in itself.
So, I guess Popcast isn't made up of Niners. Weren't they the ones pushing PIC Season 3 the hardest? Or am I confusing them with someone else?
It's a averaging of many fan sources, so take that for what is.
Many folks haven't watched TOS, myself included.
What's interesting is how close in points certain shows are to each other:
On the Global Average fan ranking:
TNG is #1 by a good margin with a 1156 point gap between it and the #2 spot
As for the #2 & #3 spots:
A 69 point gap between #2 spot of DS9 & #3 spot of TOS means that if you find other fan sites to average in points, that spot could really change.
So effectively DS9 & TOS could swap pole positions pretty easily and are effectively equal.
For the #4 & #5 spots:
The 964 point gap between VOY & SNW is interesting.
Over time, that could change as more people watch SNW with SNW equalling or surpassing VOY in popularity.
So 6th - 9th place is actually a very heated race
LDS, PIC, ENT, & DIS all being in the 7000's means that things can easily shift over time or have different fan sources added to the average could shift their rankings.
PRO & TAS are on their own little Islands in the aft end of the rankings.
Last edited:
Of course.
1. TOS
2. Everything else
2. Everything else
My reading of the Global Ranking: They can't rate a Star Trek series that came out in the 21st Century above a Star Trek series that came out in the 20th. Excluding TAS. Otherwise, they would've rated SNW higher.
My reading of the Popcast Ranking: If SNW looked like "The Cage", they would've rated it higher. And if not for the third season, they'd be rating PIC with DSC.
This is judging by where both put everything else.
My reading of the Popcast Ranking: If SNW looked like "The Cage", they would've rated it higher. And if not for the third season, they'd be rating PIC with DSC.
This is judging by where both put everything else.
Or that most Trek fans trend to be "Older" and have more experience with "Older Shows".
The newer shows haven't had enough time & episodes to come in to match the "Older Shows" yet.
SNW is taking that lead very well and with time, can probably surpass VOY.
There are some episodes of Barney I've enjoyed more than VOY.
I do not think the word "pragmatic" means what you think it means.
I'm honestly surprised ENT ranked so relatively high but given the show's small renaissance in streaming I'm glad it didn't end up in the bottom spot or runner-up.
Fair Enough, I REAALY dislike the DS9 ep "Profit & Lace".
It's the one episode of DS9 that I really dispise & refuse to watch it, even to this day.
ENT finishing ahead of TOS in the "fan" ranking was very surprising.
Agreed. I'm a huge ENT fan, but I still rank it below TOS and DS9.
Me too. On a good day it's #4 on my all-time list and on its worst day #5.
Under what?
TOS, DS9 and TNG. TNG is third place for the moment.
Similar threads
- Locked
