• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard General Discussion Thread

And if you really go by the dialogue of the scene, and Picard's reaction - you get the idea that THAT was the original intent (to rename it the USS Picard) - and Matalas for whatever reason changed his mind.

Because honestly - Jean-Luc Picard has always thought of the USS Stargazer as 'his ship' (he affirmed that to Scotty in TNG S6 Relics; and again at the start of season 2 of PICARD when he came aboard the USS Stargazer A); so yeah, the reaction to seeing the Titan - A renamed to the Enterprise - G in that scene just doesn't fit the character.

In the 1st Episode of Season 3, Picard did however refer to the Enterprise-D as not his first love, but his favorite.

But yes, especially with Jack Crushers comments, I do get the idea that it was the Picard initially.
 
I find it interesting I've been more frustrated with the current live action shows than the animated shows. I take them all seriously. But I think there's a freshness the animated shows have. Maybe it's the literal colours? The live action shows are quite dark. I'm sure this plays a part in how I feel about them. Not every TV show needs to look like a small movie.
It may come down to the animated shows being lower budget and having lower stakes, leading to more creative freedom. STLD made some massive mistakes out of the gate, but achieved consistent stability by the end its first season. PRODIGY has some tough not really Star Trek episodes, but quickly begins an unexpected meteoric rise. Whereas DISCOVERY was too big to fail, so faced constant creative instability. Only SNW will have season to season creative stability for three seasons in a row. And the live action series are so obsessed with being "cinematic", they have the real estate wasting 2.39 to 1 aspect ratio.
 
I can understand why TPTB would want the hero ship for a potential new series to be named Enterprise. For many (maybe even most) casual or lapsed viewers, Star Trek revolves largely around "the voyages of the Starship Enterprise."

It could be a much better hook for a new series---'come see the NEW voyages of the Enterprise'---than simply 'come see the voyages of the USS Heretofore Unheard Of.'
 
And if you really go by the dialogue of the scene, and Picard's reaction - you get the idea that THAT was the original intent (to rename it the USS Picard) - and Matalas for whatever reason changed his mind.

Because honestly - Jean-Luc Picard has always thought of the USS Stargazer as 'his ship' (he affirmed that to Scotty in TNG S6 Relics; and again at the start of season 2 of PICARD when he came aboard the USS Stargazer A); so yeah, the reaction to seeing the Titan - A renamed to the Enterprise - G in that scene just doesn't fit the character.

I think his reaction to the rechristening of the Titan-A to the Enterprise-G is less about what Picard considers to have been "his" ship than it is about him realizing the ship was renamed in honor of himself and of the rest of the Enterprise-D command crew. He's recognizing it's not just about him.
 
I think his reaction to the rechristening of the Titan-A to the Enterprise-G is less about what Picard considers to have been "his" ship than it is about him realizing the ship was renamed in honor of himself and of the rest of the Enterprise-D command crew. He's recognizing it's not just about him.

I expected Jack to have taken the Picard name at that point too, what with all the dialogue.
 
That was one potential outcome I was dreading (honestly, expecting) would happen, especially when talks of a spinoff started, and I was very pleased when it didn't.

I think if the ship had been named Picard (though presumably they wait for a person to be dead — can still do that on a technicality I suppose) it would have made a fair amount of sense. His ‘names are everything’ line basically amounts to the same thing as him taking the name mind you.
It’s essentially a true thing that he has every right to the name after all, if he chose.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top