• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

HBO's "Westworld", starring Anthony Hopkins/produced by J.J. Abrams

vDqtvHU.gif
I'm going to have to do a re watch it's been that long.
 
Damn, I still haven't watched Season 3. And I should be able to actually watch the new episodes the day after they air since HBOMax in part of my streaming service rotation.
 
Damn, I still haven't watched Season 3. And I should be able to actually watch the new episodes the day after they air since HBOMax in part of my streaming service rotation.

Season 3 was such a disappointment. I LOVED the first season, and the 2nd season was decent, but season 3 went off a cliff.
 
Westworld Season 3 was definitely better than Season 2 because it didn't make the mistake of ending with an absolutely confusing and disconnected coda.

I want to rewatch the series ahead of Season 4, but don't want to start until we get a concrete and specific return date, which hopefully happens soon.
 
Season 3 was such a disappointment. I LOVED the first season, and the 2nd season was decent, but season 3 went off a cliff.

Yeah I couldn't settle with S3 at all, barely remember what happened it was that memorable. I loved the first season and liked the second so will give S4 a chance but if it doesn't grab me in the first few episodes I might bail. Has that Lost NuBSG vibe of them making it up as they go.
 
^ You might feel like Jonah and Lisa are only making stuff up as they go, but you're wrong.

It's been well-documented that the series went on a self-imposed production hiatus during the middle of Season 1 and that Jonah and Lisa used said hiatus as both an opportunity to fully complete the scripts for the first season without the additional pressures of simultaneous filming and to map out a complete narrative direction for the series in full, ultimately culminating with the development of a 5-season plan.
 
I don't feel that they are making it up as they go, but season 3 was jarringly different. Much simpler to follow, much easier to understand message, much more fun to watch.
 
The first season was the only good season. The second season believed its own hype and tried to outdo the first season in terms of twists and surprises, while the third season was extremely simple and straight forward, with the only surprise being not that big of a deal.
 
^ You might feel like Jonah and Lisa are only making stuff up as they go, but you're wrong.

It's been well-documented that the series went on a self-imposed production hiatus during the middle of Season 1 and that Jonah and Lisa used said hiatus as both an opportunity to fully complete the scripts for the first season without the additional pressures of simultaneous filming and to map out a complete narrative direction for the series in full, ultimately culminating with the development of a 5-season plan.

I recall very different stories about why that hiatus happened:lol:

Besides, every mystery box show claims they have it all planned out. They all lie. They sometimes have vague notions of where they are going, but often throw most of it out the window as they go, depending on what they are finding is working on the show, what isn't, cast changes, writer changes, audience reception, network notes, critical reception etc.
 
I recall very different stories about why that hiatus happened:lol:

Besides, every mystery box show claims they have it all planned out. They all lie. They sometimes have vague notions of where they are going, but often throw most of it out the window as they go, depending on what they are finding is working on the show, what isn't, cast changes, writer changes, audience reception, network notes, critical reception etc.
Babylon 5 is one show that comes to mind that seems to have followed a plan all the way through.
 
I guess I'm the only person who genuinely enjoyed the third season.

Besides, every mystery box show claims they have it all planned out. They all lie. They sometimes have vague notions of where they are going, but often throw most of it out the window as they go, depending on what they are finding is working on the show, what isn't, cast changes, writer changes, audience reception, network notes, critical reception etc.
Even as a big defender of LOST, I have to agree with this.

Babylon 5
is the only one that can come close to actually making the longterm plan claim and even JMS had to make a lot of adjustments along the way due to cast changes (not just O'Hare, but also Andrea Thompson and Claudia Christensen), WB mandates, and the expectation of cancelation.
 
I guess I'm the only person who genuinely enjoyed the third season.


Even as a big defender of LOST, I have to agree with this.

Babylon 5
is the only one that can come close to actually making the longterm plan claim and even JMS had to make a lot of adjustments along the way due to cast changes (not just O'Hare, but also Andrea Thompson and Claudia Christensen), WB mandates, and the expectation of cancelation.

TV is just too collaborative and long form for a true, multi season arc with no changes occurring. Writers have to be flexible. They can have long term goals but writing out a full 5 year story in advance and expecting to stick to it word for word just isn't very likely to ever happen. Can't say it's impossible, because nothing is impossible, but:shrug:. It doesn't even happen with novels very often, if you look at original story plans vs final products.

Michael Hirst probably came close with Vikings as well, he is the only credited writer on the show until the final season, like JMS on B5. And he said in the first season that he planned on switching generations partway through. But even then you can definitely see course corrections on the show as it went on.
 
TV is just too collaborative and long form for a true, multi season arc with no changes occurring. Writers have to be flexible. They can have long term goals but writing out a full 5 year story in advance and expecting to stick to it word for word just isn't very likely to ever happen. Can't say it's impossible, because nothing is impossible, but:shrug:. It doesn't even happen with novels very often, if you look at original story plans vs final products.

Michael Hirst probably came close with Vikings as well, he is the only credited writer on the show until the final season, like JMS on B5. And he said in the first season that he planned on switching generations partway through. But even then you can definitely see course corrections on the show as it went on.
I think he planned to kill Ragnar at the end of season 1 though, so he actually changed a hell of a lot from his original concept.
 
I recall very different stories about why that hiatus happened

Everything that was reported about the Season 1 production hiatus that came from credible and reputable sources was consistent in identifying said hiatus as having been self-imposed by the production and HBO based on a need to complete scripts without the added pressures of filming simultaneously, with Jonah and Lisa additionally revealing that the hiatus had also provided them with the opportunity to craft a broad-strokes 5-year narrative plan.
 
Everything that was reported about the Season 1 production hiatus that came from credible and reputable sources was consistent in identifying said hiatus as having been self-imposed by the production and HBO based on a need to complete scripts without the added pressures of filming simultaneously, with Jonah and Lisa additionally revealing that the hiatus had also provided them with the opportunity to craft a broad-strokes 5-year narrative plan.
Lol here he is again believing "reputable" sources that use official studio press releases for their info.
 
Frankly if its all planned out that makes it worse. I can forgive Lost because they never quite knew how long they had left to tell the story.

Maybe it's just the world, I loved the cowboy aesthetic of the first season and parts of the second, but the third just spent too much time in the real world which was just another generic future America which wasn't that interesting. Plus maybe I'm just all 'robots are people too''d out :lol:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top