It's almost as though people are allowed to have different opinions. FWIW, I became a full-on Doctor Who fan in 2001, but I'd seen some Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker episodes here and there starting in the 1980s, read a couple of books and comics, and watched the 1996 TV movie when it originally aired.
Moffat was one of the best of RTD's writers. I was excited when I heard he was taking over. And then I was a bit disappointed. I'm not going to say he suddenly became awful, but there was a certain discipline or restraint in writing for someone else that went out the window when he wrote for himself. His arcs were either horribly convoluted (the whole Doctor's death at Lake Silencio business, for example, and River's timeline) or asked questions with obvious answers: yes, the Doctor is a good man. And there were moments of brilliance, like the sudden appearance of the War Doctor and the Night of the Doctor minisode. But Kill the Moon wasn't just awful, Moffat and the episode's writer never clued in that they'd created a bad anti-abortion story. At least, that's the story from interviews. They never intended the episode's most obvious reading.
As for the Timeless Child, we don't have the whole story yet, and maybe we never will, just as we don't know how the Eighth Doctor was human on his mother's side, or who Susan's parents and grandmother were, or whether the Seventh Doctor really was more than just another Time Lord. The Morbius Doctors were a mystery for decades. Chibnall just built on that and other writers are free to run with it or ignore it. There was a time, after all, when all the Daleks and Time Lords except the Doctor were gone. There was a time when viewers didn't even know the Doctor was a Time Lord.They're all just pieces of the puzzle that is the Doctor. Chibnall's added a few pieces but he's taken none away. Another thing I've said before and will again: people piss on Chibnall for doing the same kind of things any number of past writers and producers have done.
As for comparing Chibnall Who to pre-2005 Who: a lot of the JNT era is dire, sometimes for prolonged stretches. As much as I love Pertwee, one of the first Doctors I ever saw, many of his stories are two or three episodes longer than they needed to be. With the possible exception of Flux, about which I'll have a more considered opinion after some time and rewatching, his stories don't overstay their welcome.
YMMV.
